What foreign tourists can do for Bangladesh

Bangladesh doesn’t need foreign tourists, Rahad Abir is entirely correct in his piece in this newspaper. 

That’s not the important question though -- after all, Bangladesh doesn’t need to have the ready-made garments industry either, but we think the country’s a much better place for having it. The question isn’t whether we need, it’s whether we’d like. The answer there being yes, of course Bangladesh would like to have foreign tourists coming in.

The easy part of the explanation here is that a tourist coming into Bangladesh is an export from Bangladesh. That takes a little straining to get the mind around it properly, but it’s entirely true. When we make an export -- say, a nice jute bag, or some t-shirt for the US market -- the defining point of the exercise is that money from out there in foreign lands comes into Bangladesh. 

With that, we can then go and buy what we actually want, those imports which are the things that foreigners can do nicer, faster, flashier, than we can. Exports mean foreign money comes in, imports mean money flows out.

So, a tourist comes to Bangladesh. They’ve not earned their money to pay for their stay in the Bangladeshi economy. They’ve gone to work elsewhere and made the cash. They come and spend it inside the country -- we’ve got foreign money coming in. 

That visit by that person or couple is therefore an export from the Bangladeshi economy. We also like exports, they mean we can do more of gaining access to those imports we desire. So, yes, we’d like to have those foreign tourists because we’d like their nice foreign money.

Abir also tells us that getting around the country to be a domestic tourist isn’t all that easy. We all sympathize of course. But that’s the second benefit of foreigners. This being the bit about foreign trade that all too few people do understand.

It’s a basic truism as I’ve mentioned before, that only the top 10% of producers of anything ever try to export. That means that the things we import are made by those top 10% of producers elsewhere. We can and should go further than this as well. For foreign companies that come in and set up in business in another country are also only from those top 10%. 

They’re the only people who have the resources to be able to work at those long distances from home. But that then means that domestic industry is exposed to those practices of those top firms. Those very practices, management methods and so on, that make them the top firms in the first place.

That is, we learn from the competition against imports, we learn from having foreign-owned factories and businesses working alongside our own. 

Now think about what happens as we try to attract foreign tourists to the country? Firstly, obviously enough, those who advise the tourists are going to start telling us what they’ll expect in terms of accommodation, food, and so on. We’ll learn from that. 

We’ll also learn from the demands being made by the tourists themselves as they come. And finally, quite obviously, foreign firms will at least try to enter the market to cater to those very tourists. This will pull up standards as our own domestic suppliers have to upgrade in order to compete.

This is the thing about international trade. It’s only worth doing it with the best of whatever it is. Thus exposure to trade means exposure to the best the world can offer. In terms of tourism, that means the demands of those rich enough to undertake such trips. This then, as with the more prosaic manufacturing, pulls up standards.

True, an influx of foreigners isn’t going to sort out the entirety of the bus and train system. But the sort of people who can afford to come to Bangladesh for any substantial period of time aren’t going to be willing to travel on the current bus systems, as an example.  

There will arise a more pleasant, even if more expensive, alternative to cater to those deeper pockets. Something that we can take advantage of ourselves, or which will at the very least provide useful lessons in how to improve to the current suppliers. 

Abir is entirely right that Bangladesh doesn’t need foreign tourists. But they’d be nice to have purely for the benefits they’ll bring to our own local economy. Both their money and the influence they’ll have on everyone else trying to sell us things. 


Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.