On January 4, 1642 King Charles I, accompanied by a party of his soldiers, arrived in the House of Commons to demand the arrest of five members of parliament. Speaker Lenthall, in a historic statement, refused to cooperate: “May it please Your Majesty, I have neither eyes to see, nor tongue to speak in this place, but as the House is pleased to direct me, whose servant I am here.”
This was an extraordinarily courageous stance by a man, six of whose predecessors had been executed by successive kings for disobeying them. But Speaker Lenthall stood his ground and the king left the house empty-handed.
His immortal words are referred to every time a new speaker is elected in the British parliament. It is a reminder of a fundamental, constitutional, and democratic principle that the occupant of the chair is responsible for the defence of the legislature, be it against a king or a prime minister.
In all Westminster-style governments, including Bangladesh, the parliament is regarded as the House of the Nation. This is where the elected representatives of the people meet to pass legislation, control public finances, scrutinise government policies, hold the government to account, debate public issues, and ventilate public grievances.
None of these functions can be carried out with any credibility unless there is a fully participating opposition in parliament. Only a scrupulously impartial speaker can ensure such participation. Without an impartial speaker, the parliament becomes dysfunctional and the process of democracy stumbles.
It is an understatement to say that the Bangladesh parliament has failed to deliver since the country’s return to the parliamentary system in 1991. A cursory glance through history shows that, far from each successive parliament carrying the baton of democracy one step further, a reverse trend has been at play. The culture of boycott was firmly on the rise and, by the end of the ninth parliament, it reached an absurd proportion: From 34% during the fifth, to the 43% during the seventh, to the 60% during the eigth, and to a staggering 81% boycott during the ninth parliament.
The primary reason for such boycotts was the speaker’s apparent lack of impartiality. Furthermore, the successive speakers’ perceived or evident bias towards the government severely eroded their authority in the house, consequently whatever little time the opposition attended parliament was spent on futile, unproductive, and acrimonious exchanges.
It is generally expected that, unlike the 10th Parliamentary election, the next election, whatever form it takes, would be a participatory one. But, as things stand, there is no reason to expect that the 11th Parliament would be any less dysfunctional than its predecessors.
The question that now arises is two-fold: Firstly, why successive Speakers have failed to shake off the perception of bias; secondly, how can Bangladesh ensure appointment of a truly impartial speaker capable of presiding over a buoyant and workable parliament.
The Bangladesh Constitution simply provides that parliament shall elect from among its members a speaker. What in practice, happens is that the new prime minister hand picks the candidate.
This nomination is faithfully followed by the party MPs while the opposition has virtually no say in the matter. Furthermore, the speaker remains a party member and therefore subject to party loyalty and discipline.
He or she cannot afford to irk the prime minister as such disloyal actions would jeopardise her career. These factors weigh heavily against the occupier of the chair to maintain any semblance of neutrality. The inevitable consequence of such is that the opposition feels it has no meaningful role in the house.
Without an impartial speaker, parliament becomes dysfunctional and the process of democracy stumbles
Yet, in true parliamentary democracies, it is the government of the day which generally finds the speaker’s rulings to be burdensome. For example, David Cameron, during his tenure, found current speaker John Bercow, a Tory MP when elected to the chair, to be a constant irritant, often commenting on the substance of the prime minister’s answers.
The ministers regularly accuse him of jeopardising government business by allowing too many private notice questions, yet he is generally regarded as a great reforming speaker.
There is no universal formula for appointing an impartial speaker. The countries which can truly claim to be parliamentary democracies found different ways of ensuring the neutrality of their speakers. In the UK, the speaker is elected through a secret ballot. The successful candidate tends to be a well-respected and independent-minded back bench parliamentarian.
To stand for election, a candidate needs to be nominated by 12 MPs, at least three of them must be members of a different party. Once elected the speaker, by convention, sever all ties with his or her political party. At the subsequent general elections, the speaker stands as Independent with the major parties’ support.
In India’s Lok Sabha, the speaker is elected through all party consultation and is relieved from party affairs. In Canada and Australia, the speakers are elected through secret ballot but continue to follow party discipline.
However, in these two countries, the speakers’ deep sense of integrity generally elevates them above party loyalty. Some aspiring democracies such as Zambia and Tanzania have opted to elect their speakers from outside parliament. However, not being elected as MPs, they find it difficult to establish their authority over members directly elected by the people. That the people of Bangladesh long to see democracy flourish in their country can be gleaned from the extraordinary level of interests generated recently in the appointments of the election commissioners. The nation’s desire for a free, fair, and participatory general election is overwhelming.
However, democracy is not just an event that takes place every five years, it is also a process that needs to be nurtured relentlessly. If a neutral EC is the pre-requisite for the delivery of the event, then an impartial speaker is just as important for the delivery of the process.
The time for Bangladesh to address this is now. One option would be to borrow heavily from the UK and Indian models, for the two main parties to agree on an outstanding, widely-respected and independent-minded citizen of Bangladesh and let her stand as an independent candidate at the 11th parliamentary election, unopposed.
Once elected, both parties should invite their MPs to vote the mutually agreed candidate to the chair. The constitution requires a candidate for speakership to be an MP, not necessarily an MP belonging to the ruling party.
If such a method is turned into tradition, it is likely that the boycotts would become a thing of the past and a nurturing democratic process would find an institutional footing in Bangladesh. The current prime minister is widely credited for her visionary steps in lifting up the country from an economic quagmire. Would she show similar zeal in establishing true democracy in the country? The people of Bangladesh would certainly cheer her on.
It is suggested that as a bold step in that direction, the prime minister could appoint a search committee to recommend such an independent candidate.
If the 10th Parliamentary election diminished Bangladesh’s democratic aspirations by electing 153 members unopposed, then let the 11th parliamentary election herald a new dawn in realising such aspirations by electing just one member unopposed to occupy the chair of the speaker, the honourable speaker.
Najrul Khasru, a British Bangladeshi, is a barrister and a part-time tribunal judge in England.