Now that the government has made clear its intention to be associated with China’s Belt and Road Initiative, it will need to reconfigure the nation’s foreign policy in line with its new priorities.
The election of December last year is five months behind us, which is as good a time as any for an administration to formulate its diplomatic objectives in the new term of office it becomes privy to. For Bangladesh, the link with BRI -- and this was made known a couple of weeks ago by the international affairs advisor to the prime minister -- is a step toward closer cooperation with China in light of the strategic importance Dhaka holds in the region.
But the BRI move also entails -- and this is what the mandarins at the foreign office, walking a tightrope as they do where traditional links with India are concerned, realize -- some major concerns. Obviously, Delhi could not have been pleased with Dhaka’s new leanings toward Beijing. But the BRI step is one which diplomacy on Bangladesh’s part will need to project forcefully and meaningfully as a mark of the balance it intends to bring into its ties with its neighbours.
That balance, however, should be based on a realistic assessment of the BRI idea, given that warnings about the debt trap, into which nations like Sri Lanka, Pakistan, the Maldives, Djibouti, and a host of others have fallen, have already been sounded. The Sri Lankans have, for want of repayment money, handed over Hambantota port to the Chinese. The Pakistanis do not say it, but the fact is that Gwadar port in Balochistan is to all intents and purposes in Chinese control.
A silver lining for Bangladesh in its Chinese dealings has been the Sonadia affair, a project Dhaka eventually did not agree to be financed by Beijing. It is a position which, in terms of foreign policy formulations, ought to be upheld by Dhaka even as it joins the BRI process. How it will do that is a challenge for the nation’s diplomacy in much the same way that a resolution of the Teesta waters issue with India is a hurdle the country will need to leap across during the government’s new term in office.
Bangladesh’s great disappointment has been to experience the inability, despite its initial optimism, of the Narendra Modi government to arrive at a resolution of the dilemma with Sheikh Hasina’s government. Now that the general elections in India are drawing to a close -- and one is not quite sure if the BJP-led government will return to office or a coalition of secular parties will be in a position to stake a claim to forming a new government once the results of the vote become known -- it should be for Dhaka’s diplomatic establishment to prepare position papers on the Teesta it can logically and convincingly present across the table, as it engages in new negotiations with Delhi.
Smart diplomacy is called for across a wide swath of foreign policy perspectives. An assertive approach to dealing with Pakistan, incorporating the fundamental issue of an apology by Islamabad over the atrocities committed by its soldiers in 1971, is in order.
But with that must come a more comprehensive position on the 1971 issue, the precedent here being the pressure which was applied on post-war Germany and Japan for a repudiation of their past. Nazism has been condemned by successive generations of post-war German leaders; Japanese militarism of the 1930s and 1940s is taboo for the country’s politicians.
For Bangladesh, therefore, the Pakistan issue should go beyond the demand for an apology. For the government, there is a clear need to press Islamabad to come forth with clear explanations for Pakistanis of the causes behind the genocide committed in Bangladesh and at the same time, demand that the misleading and false teaching about 1971 imparted to Pakistani school-children in their textbooks be removed and the realities incorporated there.
Generations of Pakistani children have, since the emergence of Bangladesh, grown to adulthood through being fed stories of “conspiracies” by Bengali politicians and India behind the loss of East Pakistan in 1971.
In short, while Pakistan must publicly repent its actions in 1971, it should also have all those offending chapters removed from the history textbooks its children study in schools. For far too long, our diplomacy has rested on a ritual mouthing of platitudes. That should change, in terms of relations with the wider world.
With common interests as also issues which call for bilateral deliberations being in the picture, efforts should be expended in formulating strategies for official state visits by the prime minister to such Western capitals as London and Washington. The clear objective behind summitry involving Bangladesh’s leader and government leaders in the West will not merely be public relations exercises but an unambiguous projection of Bangladesh as a country which matters in the global scheme of things.
The Rohingya issue should have been a good reason for the prime minister to undertake meaningful tours of the West and East and South-East Asia to persuade the political classes in these regions into spurring their efforts to have Myanmar agree to take its people back on well-defined terms in line with international law.
Indira Gandhi provided a huge impetus to the Bangladesh cause on her global tours in 1971. That was diplomacy at its height.
Much a similar approach should now underpin Bangladesh’s diplomacy, through providing scope to Sheikh Hasina to argue her case vis-à-vis Rohingyas in person before the councils of the world. Diplomacy is an opening of windows to the world.It is a measure of the expertise diplomats can bring into its formulation and practice. Besides, in large measure, policy-makers in a nation’s diplomatic arena are always ready to benefit from the wisdom of their predecessors.
To what extent has the foreign office at Shegun Bagicha profited, if at all, from those who have been there before, if at all they have been approached for snippets of their wisdom?
With the foreign office being led by the minister for foreign affairs and the minister of state for foreign affairs, and with the prime minister’s advisor on international affairs holding the fort at the PMO, a thorough and goals-oriented recasting of Bangladesh’s diplomacy is called for.
Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist and biographer.