While many British politicians have continued to talk glibly about the importance of “taking ‘no deal’ off the table,” the defeat of the government’s policy has plunged the UK and the EU into a deep crisis. It remains true, as Prime Minister May says, that the only way to prevent no deal is to do a deal, and that the only deal on the table is the one agreed between her and the European Council on November 25.
As things stand, Brexit will happen without a deal on March 29, and no unilateral British legislation can alter that date. Unless the UK revokes the Article 50 secession process entirely, the EU will cut off the UK as a member state at midnight on that Friday.
An extension of Article 50 is possible, but fraught with difficulty. That the EU institutions have refused to reopen the legal text of the Withdrawal Agreement is an indication of how difficult it has been to negotiate with the UK in the first place.
Nevertheless, the EU is still willing to show flexibility over the political declaration on the future relationship between the UK and the EU.
It may be noted that this will be the key document that will accompany the Withdrawal Agreement. It was published on November 22, and endorsed by the European Council and the British government.
Some are still seeing a glimmer of hope as the political declaration is open for modification. They believe that this is possible based on what has transpired -- the conclusions of the European Council of December 13, the exchange of letters between May and Presidents Tusk and Juncker of January 14, the “meaningful vote” in the House of Commons to reject the Withdrawal Agreement on January 15, the subsequent vote (Brady amendment) of January 29, which instructed the government to renegotiate the Irish backstop, the debate in the European Parliament on January 30, the recent exchange of letters between Corbyn and May, the joint statement of Juncker and May after their Brussels meeting on February 7, and, finally, the Commons debate on February 12.
They are pointing out that the legal base of the declaration is Article 50, and the document exists only in the context of the UK’s withdrawal from the union. Its purpose is to accompany and elucidate the Withdrawal Agreement. The negotiation of the final deal can only begin after the UK has ceased to be a member state of the union and will be conducted on a different legal base and according to different procedures.
In this context, it is being suggested that as far as the UK is concerned, the declaration only informs the Westminster parliament about the UK’s direction of travel post-Brexit. It indicates the location of Britain’s final landing zone as an ex-member state. As such, it needs to be interpreted as only the start of the journey, not the arrival.
In the meantime, Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the opposition has underlined five requirements:
(a) A permanent and comprehensive UK-wide customs union, including alignment with the EU Customs Code, the common external tariff, and “an agreement on commercial policy that includes a UK say on future EU trade deals”
(b) Close alignment with the single market, underpinned by shared institutions and obligations
(c) Dynamic alignment on rights and protections, allowing the UK to keep pace with EU standards
(d) Clear commitments on participation in EU agencies and programs
(e) Unambiguous agreements on the details of future security arrangements
The rest of the world has been watching the Brexit process and the associated moments of drama with anxiety and concern. Bangladesh believes that any substantive changes that can make the deal more palatable, most notably regarding the Irish border backstop, needs to be given greater consideration in practical terms and not be treated just as an existential question.
Fabian Zuleeg has suggested an aspirational scenario in the political declaration that would deliver a frictionless border, potentially including:
(a) A common customs territory between the UK and EU (in part fulfilling Jeremy Corbyn’s demands) (b) dynamic/automatic regulatory alignment of the UK but only in areas crucial to maintain a frictionless border
(c) Where checks are necessary, whenever possible, they should be aided by technology and take place off border through alternative arrangements
(d) A UK-wide solution, maintaining the integrity of the UK single market
(e) A clear commitment that any arrangement will not jeopardize EU governance and the integrity of the EU single market
(f) Provisions for agriculture to enable an integrated agricultural market in Ireland
(g) Enabling small traders/services to continue operating across the border
(h) Continued freedom for people to cross the Northern Ireland/Ireland border, ie the Common Travel Area
This means that both sides in the British parliament would have to pay a high price for such a centrist compromise. It will require a deviation from party unity and adversarial politics. But, at this stage, it appears to be the only chance left to avoid a No Deal scenario.
Both sides also need to remember that the association agreement will have to include arrangements for a deep and comprehensive free trade area. Given their high level of economic interdependence, the parties will also have to agree to work together for the sustainable development of both the UK and Europe, based on a competitive social market economy aiming at full employment and social progress.
Muhammad Zamir, a former ambassador, is an analyst specialized in foreign affairs, right to information and good governance, and can be reached at muhammadzamir0@gmail.com.