It’s no big secret that good researchers are always falling prey to predatory publications, and that publication of their work in predatory journals is causing them serious grief.
The repercussions of such actions are loom large in the academic scenario, and we need to raise more awareness of this incredibly pertinent issue.
Defining what makes for a “predatory journal” is a fool’s errand -- but all we need to know is that there are certain establishments floating under the auspices of many publishing houses in the web who seek to dupe hard-working academics.
Predatory journals generally lie about publishing costs. Such journals allow researchers to submit their papers for free, and later ask for payment.
Publishing arms of predatory journals usually publish the papers online and then refuse to remove them from their websites unless the researchers pay the requested amount of money. As a result, researchers are prevented from publishing their papers in other journals.
Some of these dishonest establishments design their websites to look exactly like that of an already reputed, established, high-ranking journal and then swamp researchers with spam emails, inviting their submissions to their journals to try and dupe them. And they are convincing.
Publishers operating under predatory journals organise international conferences with the promise of publication of the presented conference papers in their journals.
Questionable predatory journals cajole researchers into presenting their papers in the conferences, falsely listing the distinguished guest speakers in their conference advertisements, and, on top of that, charge exorbitant conference fess.
Also, they drop a lot of tempting buzzwords, trying to convince that they would help the researchers get their presented papers published into Scopus-indexed journals.
Some of these dishonest establishments design their websites to look exactly like that of an already reputed, established, high-ranking journal and then swamp researchers with spam emails
Questionable predatory journals,or “start-up” journals, invite both budding/established researchers to be a part of their editorial board or panel of reviewers, and even have several of the reviewers to ask their fellow colleagues or research students to submit papers or articles for their journals.
The gambit of their publication policy is that, for a few years, they cannot mention the publication fee in any public forum. Later, the researchers find out with dismay that the predatory journals have revamped much of the information provided earlier, particularly the clause about mentioning the publication fee.
Many distinguished experts fall prey to such underhanded schemes, and they find it hard to erase their names from websites of such dubious, questionable establishments.
Predatory journals often offer quick, bogus peer review processes which are quite next to impossible in accomplishing. This is the distinguishing yardstick/criterion between predatory journals and journals of some repute.
The low quality that these predatory journals have set as a bar are indicative of their keen interest in getting money through submitted publication fees --these journals often even forgo any peer-reviewing processes altogether, in order to run their publishing business by keeping researchers submitting papers one after another.
Questionable predatory journals publish a plethora of articles in one volume, and there are as many as 12 issues in a year compared to the two or three issues that more reputed journals tend to release in a year. They have realised that the more they publish papers or articles, the more money goes into their coffers.
Conscious researchers can observe the substantial number of spelling or grammatical mistakes which can be found in websites of predatory journals.
It is the responsibility of the researchers to widen the horizon of the world, and the underhanded actions of these dishonest publications stand to get in the way.
Something needs to be done sooner rather than later.
Md Kamrul Hasan is a PhD scholar in Applied Linguistics, Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia.