The prejudiced mind

Political writing is often fraught with certain risks, none of which should discourage the writer, of course. 

In the more than three decades that I have been writing for newspapers, I have had the dubious pleasure of seeing a good number of critics pouncing on me for reasons that are as spurious as they are silly. 

Those who have been followers of the BNP brand of politics have always taken umbrage at what they have seen as my Awami League leanings. But whenever there have been moments when I chose to upbraid the AL over some of its faulty moves, a good number of BNP-wallahs told me how right I was to write as I did. 

Conversely, people in the AL have congratulated me on presenting before my readers all the gory sins which the BNP remains guilty of.

But that, I presume, is how things always are. Some months ago, someone complained to a friend of mine -- and this friend is a journalist -- that I had deserted the AL camp and gone over to the enemy. And how did that come to be? 

Here’s how: I had paid tribute to Tajuddin Ahmad on the late leader’s birthday in July and, therefore, this critic, obviously unwilling to acknowledge the wartime prime minister’s role in our history, assumed that I was no more a follower of Bangabandhu. 

He had clearly not read my biography of Bangabandhu. And I can only assume that late in August, a couple of years ago, when I was the keynote speaker at a program on Bangabandhu’s role in Bangladesh’s history, this critic was not there. The only other speaker was Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.

What worries me, and not just about readers’ responses to my articles, but to write-ups by others as well, is that a fairly large number of readers in this country are often unable to take the larger view. 

My opinion about General Ziaur Rahman is a matter of record, for I hold that he is one man who did the biggest damage to Bangladesh in the post-1975 phase of its history. 

But, at the same time, I have not been among those who have condemned him over his alleged links with Pakistan even during the War for Liberation. The truth is simple: In 1971, Zia was one of our heroes and must be given credit for the announcement he made on Bangabandhu’s behalf on March 27, 1971. 

In his years in power, he certainly distorted history. But why, in like manner, should we suppress history?

That takes me to a recent complaint from a reader, who makes it clear at the outset that he is not a Bangladeshi. In his response to an article, he calls me an anti-Pakistan columnist. 

He makes that charge principally because of one single reason: I have always been vocal, like so many others in Bangladesh and elsewhere, against the atrocities committed by the Pakistan army during our War for Liberation. 

And, yes, ever since I stepped into adulthood, I have considered the partition of India on the basis of the “two-nation theory” a blunder. Neither of these positions can be ascribed to an anti-Pakistan position on my part. 

If it were, I would not be listening to old Pakistani songs; I would not have the kind of friends I have in Pakistan; and I would not have been to Pakistan four times in the last 20 years to be part of a process of South Asian dialogue. 

I read Faiz Ahmed Faiz; I marvel at the cultural dimensions of Lahore. And, of course, I went to school in Pakistan.

But I do not blame this reader who, I assume, is a Pakistani. And I do not blame him because in the past so many decades I have come across readers like him, people who are unable or unwilling to engage with writers at an academic level. 

A few weeks ago, I wrote an article on the role of the Pakistan army in the history of Pakistan. Most of the responses were all right, with people disagreeing or agreeing with me. But one reader had a strange response (it was not the first time). He said I knew only two subjects, Pakistan and Sheikh Mujib. 

What do you do about such shallow readers? You ignore them. And there is the instance of a reader who thinks I am a communist because of the way I express my opinions on national issues. I wonder how he came by that impression. 

Another reader (I think I know who he is) was upset by an article where I focused on what an ideal editor should be. Probably, he thought I was being critical of the editor he served. Perhaps he was right. But it was his tone which was unpleasant, and not for the first time. I blocked him on Facebook.

Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist.