With 57 scheduled and six non-scheduled banks which contributed 2.96 percent to GDP in 2016-17, the banking sector dominates the Bangladesh finance sector. But alas! The sector which could have been our pride and a major growth engine of the economy has instead, ended up doing everything it can to unscrupulously enrich its owners, at the expense of everyone else, especially the government.
Our government and the woes of NPLs
Ever-increasing bad loans, especially in state-owned banks, has crippled Bangladesh’s banking sector. For decades, state-owned banks have lent large amounts to big, influential and politically favoured borrowers, who have been known to be lax with repayments. Measures are rarely taken against defaulters. Instead, loans are routinely rescheduled to allow further lending to the same borrowers. Between 2014 and 2018, NPL ratio has been hovering around 10 percent which is much higher than the international standard of five percent. NPL ratio would go up to 17 percent if restructured or rescheduled loans are taken into account.
Banks cannot turn available deposits into loanable funds as the amount equivalent to bad loans has to be set aside as provision. Consequentially, the banks’ funding costs rise, leading to an increase in the lending rate. The increase in requirements for provisioning has also served to weaken the banks’ capital. The government has announced a bailout package of around BDT 20 billion so that the state-owned banks can meet some of their capital shortfalls. This move has drawn flak from the public as the taxpayers’ money has been diverted from development to pay for these handouts. While the amount is meagre when compared to the amount demanded (BDT 203.98 billion), the bailout is continuously being offered despite banks failing to improve their NPL positions or quality of portfolio.
The curious case of Farmer’s Bank Limited (FBL)
FBL, which came into being following political consideration, has garnered a lot of attention recently owing to the fact that not only has the bank been unable to collect any new deposits, existing depositors are trying to withdraw their funds. Furthermore, the bank has been unsuccessful in returning their money. The owners of FBL reportedly requested the government to inject funds. The government, now is pushing state-owned banks and financial institutions to buy stakes of the troubled FBL. This bizarre method to keep FBL afloat has raised eyebrows and rightly so. First comes the question that whether the public sector banks, which regularly request the government for capital replenishment, are at all financially sound enough to buy the stakes in a troubled private sector bank. Second, why should these banks invest in FBL which has near zero possibility of turning the tide? The bank is yet to do any due diligence on their troubled portfolio, security-collateral shortfall and thereby capital shortage. But criticisms weren’t welcome even when they were constructive.
Behind the anemic performance of the banking sector
Distribution of credit based on political influence, culture of impunity, abuse of power in loan distribution and weakness of existing laws contribute to the decay of the banking sector. Additionally, regulatory requirements become a problem area when changes in regulation prompt regulators to roll out action plans without thorough research or understanding the future implications and ability of the banks to comply with it. This not only confuses stakeholders but also delays implementation. Lack of technological expertise is also a major issue as depicted through the Bangladesh Bank heist in 2016. It is speculated that, besides possible involvement of rogue employees, lax computer security practices (the Bank had no firewall installed on its network) enabled the hackers to obtain necessary information and transfer $81 million successfully to the desired beneficiaries. Abrupt collapse of the central bank’s Credit Information Bureau (CIB) server on March 6, 2018, for nearly a week, disrupted lending activities of banks as no loan can be sanctioned/extended/renewed without obtaining the client’s credit status from the CIB report. This further illustrates how much our banking sector is lagging behind technologically.
The road ahead
Although the number of banks has increased over time, the industry’s capacity has not kept pace with it. We must remember that while no growth comes without its share of pain, faster growth causes even more pain. It is essential that banks focus on improving supervision, reducing risks by avoiding high concentration of loan to a particular borrower or in one sector, improving the legal and financial framework for loan recovery. Enforcement of regulations ought to be ensured and the practice of loan disbursement, as well as other favours based on political affiliation, ought to be curbed. Banks stand to gain by investing in technology to improve governance. Cohesion among the Central Bank, Finance Ministry and Prime Minister’s Office can go a long way towards revamping our banking sector.
Mamun Rashid is a leading banker and economic analyst