North Korea won’t back down

On September 11 this year, the UN Security Council unanimously passed a sanctions resolution voted 15-0 against North Korea. The sanction has been seen as the strictest ever. Drafted by the US, the economic sanction was imposed on the rogue state in a response to its sixth, and most powerful, nuclear test conducted on September 3. Through the resolution, the UN banned North Korea’s textile exports, capped imports on crude oil, ended additional overseas labourer contracts, and stopped joint ventures with Pyongyang, which will cause a reduction of around $1.3 billion in the total annual revenues of North Korea.Sanction after sanctionPrior to the last sanctions imposed on September 11, the UN had adopted several resolutions since 2006 -- including resolution 1718 in 2006, resolution 1874 in 2009, resolution 2087 and 2094 in 2013, and resolutions 2270 and 2321 in 2016 -- aiming at ending North Korea’s irrational nuclear weapons program. Even on August 5, the UNSC approved the sanction resolution 2371 against DPRK in a response to DPRK’s two long-range missiles tests on July 4 and July 28 respectively, which was also seen as the toughest sanctions in history. Through resolution 2371, the export of objects, including lucrative products, coal, iron ore, seafood, and some North Korean artwork are banned, which will cause a reduction of around $1bn in the total annual exports of North Korea. It also banned banking activities and other joint endeavours with overseas companies. Though the UNSC members voted unanimously over sanction resolutions to punish the world’s most isolated regime, Pyongyang still threatens to test missiles off Guam Island, a Western pacific territory of the US. Imposing sanctions is apparently the best available option, as military options are too costly and their effects would be unimaginable, but there is also scepticism about whether such tougher sanctions will ever have any substantial impact on Pyongyang’s nuclear weapon development programs or not.It’s all in the details History says both China and Russia supported the previous sanctions against North Korea during the Obama administration, but they could not sufficiently exert true pressure on Pyongyang as North Korea shares border with both China and Russia -- traditional allies of North Korea. Even in the sanction resolution 2371, China and Russia removed a clause in order to import fuel to North Korea, and the resolutions did not impose any sanctions on non-state actors, particularly some Chinese giants that are running their businesses in North Korea. Oil import is viewed as one of the major parts of China-North Korea’s economic relations. The last defender of dictator Kim Jong Un -- China alone imports around 80% of North Korea’s oil. Also, in 1961, North Korean founding leader Kim Il-sung and the first premier of People’s Republic of China, Zhou Enlai, signed the “Sino-North Korea Mutual Aid and Cooperation Friendship Treaty” -- the key pledge of which is to provide military and other supports if either party to the agreement is attacked by a foreign power until 2021.
Since the previous sanctions against North Korea did not work, then the new sanction does not bring hope either
China also has political interests in keeping Kim in power as North Korea is important to China’s regional security. To protect its own security, China offers crucial aid packages to North Korea and plays a vital role in protecting Pyongyang against the US and other regional powers in East Asia. Despite the growing pressure and increased number of sanctions from other countries, North Korea found a way to avoid the resolutions.Kim fears none Merely sanctions will not work as a peaceful means to dissuade North Korea from developing nuclear weapons, nor will it suffice to compel Kim to sit on the negotiation table. Without appropriate diplomatic maneuvers and Chinese support, sanctions will never be able to prevent Pyongyang from testing missiles, as North Korea thinks nuclear weapons are the only tool to survive and to protect its territorial integrity. North Korea’s track record does not demonstrate that the country will sit on the negotiation table so easily, backtracking on the nuclear program. Therefore, China should come forward to take major action to deter North Korea as the former has been a significant player in the region. It is a good sign that China finally announced a ban -- effective from September 05 -- on the import of iron ore, iron, and coal from North Korea. Earlier this year, Beijing had announced banning coal imports. Also, bilateral relations between the two neighbours have not been so good, particularly since Kim took office. Exchange of high-level visits between the two countries have been on hold even since Kim executed his uncle Jang Song Thaek, who was said to be a Chinese patron.What now? In addition to sanctions, diplomatic exertions should be increased, and the US should avoid its military drills if it feels like the diplomatic endeavours are promoting peace and stability in the Korean Peninsula. Kim is the most unstable dictator in the world and can strike any region at any time without the slightest warning. Even after adopting the last sanction against North Korea on September 11, Pyongyang is still a looming peril to American national security.Md Saifullah Akon is a Research Analyst, Microgovernance Research Initiative (MGR).