Men, women, and children

When it comes to the plight of men, women, and children, it is perhaps the case that each group is ensconced in its own personal bubble, and within that, each individual is inside further and smaller bubbles of solipsistic vulnerabilities and insecurities.

Whether it is the men who complain about days like International Women’s Day (because really, where are the men’s days?), women who complain about privilege (who respond that every other day is men’s day), and children, who don’t really have the voice or the eloquence to complain in kind, resorting to the voices of sympathisers and empathisers to give their complaints some sort of narrative, there is, conceivably, a divide between all of us.

There are those who try and cross over to the other side. Men who identify as feminists, speaking of the constant, daily struggle that women are subjected to. Some go “overboard” perhaps, a result of the transatlantic influence, showing us instances of male privilege through “manspreading” and sexist air conditioners and the wage gap.

And there are women who don’t identify as such, recognising the double standards that such religious adherence to feminism can result in. Some see it as a humanist problem, not a feminist one, which can, depending on its mood and its supporters, be exclusionary, leaving out people of other genders, races, and cultures.

And what of the children? Do they too try to cross over? Some do, pretending they are older than their minuscule ages will permit, latching on to beliefs and faiths and ideas as if they do not require years of experiences and critical analysis before one can decide, clearly, irrevocably, to a certain extent, what one’s views are.

But that is unfair on children and teens who are either unaware or have hormones raging through their bodies. Everyone, in their own way, sometimes, at least, tries to understand. And I, too, cannot help but understand, as futile as that may seem.

I understand that each individual has their own form of suffering that they wish to impart upon the world in some way so that someone understands. And that this suffering, this disenfranchisement, of feeling left out or too much in the loop, of being identified as a result of their genders and sexes and ages, is a relative experience, and cannot be measured on a scale.

In a recent article in Tribune’s own Weekend Magazine, the writer interviewed men who had been raped or sexually abused by their partners. The running theme was that most people find the rape of men unimaginable because, when it comes to their abuse at the hands of women, the sex isn’t penetrative and that it is next to impossible to see women as sexual and predatory beings. As people who take as opposed to people who are taken from.

This is one of many examples where our collective inability to empathise, or understand, the plight of an individual who is and whose experiences are so intrinsically different from ours. If people can’t understand how men get raped, how are we surprised when we see people not understand why women can’t just “dress less provocatively” so that chances of rape and sexual abuse are reduced?

How can we expect people to understand that children, sometimes, cannot always choose how to behave, or that each person is a result of multitudinous experiences and influences that shape them, and they choose to behave in the way that they have been, from the very onset of their existence, taught to.

But, it is a difficult endeavour to curb that knee-jerk reaction of people, since that, too, is a result of the very same, sad, inevitable truth.

To reiterate Stephen Dedalus: “Does nobody understand?”

Not really. Since our pain and suffering are so personal and intertwined, and we exist in a plane that is hovering within the impermeable bubbles of our minds. But it may not be too much of a stretch to give each individual the benefit of the doubt, and to learn to doubt ourselves.

A woman in Delhi gets raped in a bus and the perpetrators say that she should be thankful because they didn’t kill her. A man gets raped and we ask how that is even possible. A child gets raped by a family member and we refuse to believe him or her. Before we ask why, why don’t we ask “why not?” And if so, why is this the way that this sequence of events took place? Why is it that the culture in our country (and everywhere else perhaps) permits such suppression of anomalous voices, and the inability to entertain a thought different from ours?

The more questions we ask, the closer we may get to accepting the flaws of the system, and changing the way it works. If at least we don’t understand, we may change our actions that allow for the peaceful co-existence of a diverse group of people. Because empathy, like any other skill, can be nurtured.

Or, to quote Sylvia Plath this time: “Is there no way out of the mind?”