Don’t play with our food

In Bangladesh, food is a basic right affirmed by the constitution of the country. However, a large number of people are still food insecure in this land of 160 million people.

According to the World Food Summit in 1996, food insecurity exists when there is not enough food available to meet the food demand; there is a lack of access to available food at all times to all people at an affordable price; and when available food fails to meet the safe and nutritional demands of the given population. In Bangladesh, high population growth, frequency of natural disasters, and low productivity are traditionally considered as causes of food insecurity.

However, data shows that these problems are no longer prominent in the debate of food security, because the fertility rate has declined from 7.0 to 2.3 between 1974 and 2013. Along with resilience to floods and cyclones, innovative farming (eg saline tolerant seeds and floating gardening) and green revolution since the 1980s have accelerated the overall food production (especially of rice).

In 1972, food production was 10 million metric tonnes (MT) for 70 million people (3 million MT shortage), while today it is around 35 million MT for 160 million people (surplus of 11 million MT).

In contrast, today, Bangladesh has the third largest hungry population after China and India. According to a World Food Program (WFP) report, 65.3 million people are food insecure in Bangladesh (45% of the population).

This gap between production and distribution requires a deeper understanding of the causes of food insecurity with specific focus on institutional weakness (both political and economic institutions). Weak political intuitions (ie non-functioning and turbulent democracy) generate weak economic institutions which make the majority of the population vulnerable to poverty and hunger. The average number of hartals between 1991 and 2013 was 46 days per year.

According to an UNDP report, Bangladesh loses 4.5% of GDP per year as a result of such hartals. Hartals and blockades increase the transport cost of agricultural input and output.

It not only increases the price of food, but also reduces the gain of the farmers. According to a recent survey of WFP (2013), the hartal resulted in a 10% to 25% income fall for the low-income groups, and farmers received 9% to 50% less than on normal days (especially those who produce perishable foods like fish and fruits).

In Bangladesh, where 80% of the people are engaged in the informal sector, political turbulence hits like deadly bullets. Falling wages and loss in production lead to unethical practices (eg use of unregistered pesticides and food syndication).

Out of 10,000 samples tested by the Institution of Public Health, 60% were found adulterated with poisonous chemicals.

Absence of strong economic institutions and legal mechanisms (eg effective food distribution, crop insurance, cold chain, and proper monitoring) threatens not only nutritional safety of the population (at present 36% of people suffer from stunting), but also the accessibility of food.

In developing countries where institutional mechanisms are weak, food security is threatened from both local and international frontiers. In Bangladesh, when farmers don’t get sufficient price for their produce, they often export it to neighbouring countries through the black market.

The existence of parallel weak institutions in the neighbouring countries hamper food security and safety in our own country.

Most of the illegal chemical pesticides found in Bangladesh are imported from India. Moreover, countries with fewer checks and balances is a dreamland for MNCs to dump products that might not get access if legal institutions were strong. For instance, the genetically modified Bt Brinjal (introduced by Monsanto-Mahyco corporation) is recognised as a “poisonous brinjal” by physicians because of its negative environmental and health externalities, but the government of Bangladesh has allowed it in 2013 (while it is not allowed in India and other regions).

What’s the solution?

It is evident that national level food sufficiency does not ensure food security at an individual level. Moreover, food security is not the result of a single factor, but an amalgam of multiple factors, and it affects people differently with regards to their gender, race, geography, and entitlements.

Reforms at two points are essential to ensure sustainable food security, within institutions and through institutions.

To begin with, reform requires the establishment of functioning democracy and accountability. It requires both goodwill of the political leaders, and also pressure by the civilians.

Bangladesh has made remarkable progress in many socio-economic indicators with the help of NGOs (it is often called the NGO capital of the world) and this “magic bullet” needs to be triggered at institutional reform this time to bring effective change in food management systems.

Amartya Sen showed how India escaped famine after independence with functional democracy. This was absent during the pre-independence period when it experienced severe famine that killed 5 million people.

Similarly, in Bangladesh, NGOs, the media, and other development actors can play an important role to ensure participation of the masses in the process of planning and execution in order to ensure accountability in the governance system.

Secondly, reform through institution is required in the food chain. Nutritional aspects and food safety are threatened by the excessive use of harmful pesticides. It requires both positive check and preventive check. The positive check is possible through institutional settings that can support, firstly, massive awareness campaigns and farmers’ learning centres on the consequences of harmful chemicals, and secondly, by establishing a cold chain in order to secure freshness of the food.

Countries like the US, China, Brazil, Canada, and Australia ensure safe food for citizens without using toxic preservations. In Dhaka, the problem of formalin can be solved only by establishing 100 cold storages in 50 markets.

This small step can be then replicated in other big cities, and from big cities to small cities; and finally, alteration of the nature of farming (eg crop rotation and use of organic fertilisers) that will not only improve soil quality, but also ensure safety of the food. 

Preventive checks require proper monitoring and implementation of the law (ie Food Safety Act 2013). The government can also introduce licensing at production and distribution levels in order to check the use of food chemicals by greedy farmers and salesmen. Moreover, local governments need to be more vigilant, and should be supported with sufficient laboratory options to test food quality.

All these mechanisms implemented through effective institutions will not only improve earning capacity, but also ensure nutritional diets that are needed to rescue us from a nutritional poverty trap. Besides, efficient distribution and security programs can also ensure food security at community and individual levels.