The language of freedom

If my mother tongue is shaking the foundations of your state, it probably means that you built your state on my land

-- Musa Anter, Kurdish writer assassinated by the Turkish government in 1992

February 21 is recognised by the UN as International Mother Language Day. On February 21, 1952, police fired on students protesting the imposition of Urdu as the national language, in Dhaka -- Abdus Salam, Rafiq Uddin Ahmed, Abul Barkat, and Abdul Jabbar were martyred. This sowed the seeds of independence on the basis of Bangla linguistic identity in a province that had, only six years ago, voted overwhelmingly for Pakistan, based largely on religious identity.

That long struggle finally achieved Bangladesh’s liberation in 1971. February 21 has also become a rallying day for various language and identity-based struggles in South Asia, which has long been a hot-bed of linguistic politics.

The concept of the present-day Indian Union, that is, a Hindu-dominant territory claiming historical continuity with Delhi or Hindi belt-centred empires of yore, had its blooming during the 19th century Hindi-Urdu controversy. Urban Hindus of the Hindustani region (roughly the upper and middle Gangetic plains) wanted to displace Urdu, that is, Persianised Hindustani in Nastaliq script, as the official language and replace that with Hindi, that is, Sanskritised Hindustani in Devanagari script.

Urdu and Hindi became proxies for Muslim and Hindu mobilisation. In that process, shoring up Hindi numbers became crucial. Many languages of the Hindustan region (like Awadhi, Bhojpuri, Rajasthani, Braj, etc) were nominally fused with Hindi by elite Hindus as a political tactic with devastating long-term consequences for the counted-as-Hindi-but-not-Hindi languages. The tactic proved successful as far as petitioning the British were concerned. Hindi acquired the official language status that Urdu already had.

The Hindi movement had two important mobilisation planks: Firstly, Hindi people were at a disadvantage in the field of jobs when Urdu was given official status. Secondly, official documents, like court documents, in Urdu, prevented their understanding by non-Urdu peoples. Ironically, after Partition, the non-Hindi people have now inherited all of Hindi’s 19th century disadvantages.

They are disallowed by the government of India to take most academic or professional exams (like IIT or AIIMS entrance) in their non-Hindi mother tongue. The government of India allows the Allahabad High Court to run its affairs in Hindi but doesn’t allow Madras High Court to do so in Tamil. The officially sanctioned text of the Constitution of India is only in Hindi and English.

Post-1947, Hindustani political plans to make Hindi the sole official language by January 26, 1965 was opposed in non-Hindi regions. It became a youth-led mass movement in what is present-day Tamil Nadu. The government tried to violently repress the massive protests. The police murdered Rajendran, a student. The movement took epic proportions. New Delhi sent the army and central police forces to Tamil Nadu.

The forces ended up killing at least 63 protesters -- unofficial numbers run into a few hundreds. The ruling Congress party in Tamil Nadu was decimated in the next election. No national party has ever emerged as the strongest force in Tamil Nadu ever since.

These protests managed to indefinitely retain English as an official language along with Hindi. The 1965 moment was preceded by anti-Hindi conventions by the Academy of Telugu as early as 1956. Similarly, Hindustani areas saw sporadic anti-English protests spearheded by the Samyukta Socialist Party, and later on by the Jansangh. 1965 destroyed the sole official language plan.

Similar preferential treatment of Sinhala in Sri Lanka was among the many reasons that later coalesced into the cause for the liberation of Tamil Eelam. In Pakistan, Urdu has been long imposed on Sindh and Balochistan and the Sindhi and Baloch nationalist narratives draw heavily from this imposition.

Language movements in the sub-continent can’t be reduced simply to a Hindi-Urdu or Hindi-Tamil conflict. In Bengali, the majority Cachar district of post-Partition Assam state protests erupted after the legislative imposition of Axomiya as the sole official language. In Silchar, the hotbed of the protesters, Assam Rifles, Madras Regiment, and other security forces initiated flag marches. On the day of a protest strike on May 19, 1961, security forces killed 11 Bangla language protesters, including a 16-year-old girl named Kamala Bhattacharya, near Silchar Railway station. Bangla was thereafter recognised as an official language in Cachar.

Bangla itself has had a record of dominating other languages, especially during the British colonial period when Banglas were extremely dominant as intermediaries and education professionals in the administration. The Bangla script was imposed on Meitei after the conversion of the Manipur sovereign into Bengali Vaishnavism. Odiya and Axomiya were treated as dialects of Bangla with Bangla being the medium of school instruction in largely Odiya and Axomiya speaking areas.

With the rise of a sizeable intelligentsia in Assam and Odisha, who could affect the colonial government’s policy in spite of deliberate obfuscations from sections of the Bengali intelligentsia, Bangla imposition was rolled back. In the post-partition period, Bangla has encroached on Tripura’s own languages like Kokborok. In Bangladesh, ethno-linguistic minorities (most notably the Chakmas of Chittagong Hill Tracts) have had Bangla thrust upon them leading to a slow cultural “assimilation.”

Some would call the Tripura and Chittagong Hill Tracts situations as cultural annihilation. In West Bengal, an assimilationist attitude continues towards speakers of Kamta/Rajbongshi.

The Jharkhand movement was originally a left-nationalist mobilisation for the cultural, political, economic, and linguistic rights of the sons of the soil. Jharkhand state was carved out with deliberate tribal minority, so as to protect the interests of economically dominant settlers and outsiders.

It’s a Hindi state for most official purposes. The Maoist investment into Gondi language and communication is crucial to their Deccan power-base which maps onto the Gondi-speaking zones. In Chhattisgarh, the government imposes Hindi on Gondi-speaking children through primary education, thus artificially alienating the Gonds from their own culture and society.

Primary education as a tool of strategic hamletting is cruel new “security” innovation. All through what is erroneously called the Hindi belt, multiple language movements are brewing, each wanting their own identity and stopping their ennumeration as Hindi speakers. Bhojpuri and Rajasthani language movements are at the forefront of these demands. The recent Chennai Declaration of Language Rights has become an important document bringing oppressed linguistic communities together.

Language movements are now also conducted in cyberspace. The hashtag #StopHindiImposition trended on August 15, 2015 during Narendra Modi’s Red Fort speech in Hindi. The Indian Union has successfully wiped out 220 languages in the last 50 years.

Almost all nation-state entities in South Asia have imposed their language of choice under various garbs like national/official/link language on the rest. Central governments have treated their unity-anxieties by promoting and expanding the imposition of their chosen language.

Those who have a problem with equal linguistic rights and support the preferential imposition of one language over other people, under the specious argument of building unity, actually have a problem with diversity, dignity, and equal rights.

February 21 underlines the present mother language struggles, hopefully, towards a world without linguistic dominance and imposition under the excuse of “national” unity, without mandatory Hindi or Urdu or Sinhalese, towards a world where all mother languages have equal rights and so do their speakers.