It’s not exactly a common occurrence for me to nod in agreement with the sentiments expressed by one of the many members of the current cabinet. Frankly, as a principled believer in freely elected governments, there is precious little I find to admire about those who rule in Bangladesh today.
Yet, it’s heartening to hear the doubts expressed by the public administration minister about the wisdom of getting entangled in the Saudi Arabia-led mysterious alliance of Muslim-majority countries which pointedly excludes Iran and, likely, considers the Persian nation as the nemesis.
The wisdom is all the more stark considering the incredible rise in tensions between Saudi Arabia and Iran. There are those who would dismiss such concerns under the guise of “well, what’s the difference?” Well, there is a difference and, fundamentally, it is about how the future is likely to shape for these two Middle Eastern neighbours.
Despite the narrative often found in the mainstream Western press, Saudi Arabia and Iran are not exactly alike. Sure, both have ruling systems that rely heavily on ancient scriptures to make laws, administer justice, and order society. Beyond that, the divergence between the two entities is almost stunning.
Iran is actually a real country with a history, culture, and civilisation which go back more than two millennia; Saudi Arabia is, on the other hand, a classic embodiment of what the late Egyptian President Gamal Abdul Nasser called “tribes with a flag,” being the only country of the world named after a particular family.
Nobody in his right mind will confuse either one of the countries with a pluralist, representative democracy where freedom abounds. Yet, thanks to her incredibly rich culture, tradition of scholarship, separate public institutions, and a fledgling civil society, Iran has a far greater likelihood of moving into the column of freedom someday in the next generation.
The epic upheavals of conquests by Arabs, the English, the Russians, and homegrown theocrats have failed to extinguish a culture that boasts the likes of Hafiz and Saadi.
Despite the terror unleashed by kangaroo courts, regime sponsored “Basij” thugs, and a criminal justice system that doles out the death penalty for erroneous thoughts, Iranians have still managed to get together to make quality cinema, write novels, and clandestinely debate ideas on university campuses.
As the aftermath of two stolen elections showed, the youth of Iran have not given up on the idea of someday getting back the right to rule themselves and breathe free. And when that someday comes, a vibrant multi-dimensional commercial sector, some good universities, and a trained cadre of brave journalists and lawyers (remember Shireen Ebadi?) will be there to help Iran reach the promise of a society where pluralism and individual liberty thrive again.
Underneath the jackboots of the revolutionary tribunals of turbaned terror, there is an Iran as an idea, an entity, a society that is bruised and bloodied but not broken.
The same isn’t the case for Saudi Arabia which, literally as the name suggests, is more a family fiefdom than a country. Unlike Iran, there are no discernible public institutions, no written constitution, no penal code, and no civil society. Even the theoretical premise of basic equality of men and women is scoffed upon in Saudi Arabia where, in 2016, it remains illegal for women to drive a motor vehicle or go to co-educational classrooms for learning.
The rudimentary idea of courts of law with lawyers and qualified jurists is simply alien to the Saudi mindset as is the concept of public assemblies and rallies; those who test these mores by means of writing Facebook posts or getting together in a town square to protest pretty much guarantee themselves a swift trip to eternal abodes.
With the absence of any native culture that is girded in scholarship, literature, or the fine arts, essentially little other than royal largesse, religious fervour, and abject fear keep the façade of a “society” alive in the desert kingdom by the Red Sea. While Iran’s global terror outreach has been almost exclusively orchestrated by its ruling theocratic oligarchy, terrorists coming out of Saudi Arabia are almost entirely from the “private sector” where little other than mischief is left to occupy the minds of the pampered, well-off, and frustrated youth.
In the absence of debating societies, cinema, novels, poetry, or even the opportunity to see the faces of the opposite sex, it is not particularly surprising that the appeal of phony martyrdom has a certain cache amongst so many young people in Saudi Arabia.
I have no crystal ball to predict what the future holds for these two countries. If I had to bet, however, I would wager that 25 years from now Iran’s culture and resilient society will overcome its theocratic masters and rejoin the modern world as inheritors of a great ancient civilisation; its big Arab neighbour across the Gulf will probably go back to what it was before it struck oil.
In doubting the wisdom of the Saudi-led alliance that leaves Iran out, the public administration minister may have a point worth pondering.