Bureaucrats vs teachers

My father was a radio engineer and a first-class gazetted officer. He took much pride in it. If there was any sort of disagreement between us, he used to say: “Be a first-class gazetted officer first, and only then I will listen to you.”

I secured my place on the top-20 merit list in my SSCs, secured a talent pool scholarship, and later went on to write many cover stories for Bichitra, but nothing would impress him.

“What kind of an officer?” I asked him. He said the best way was to become a BCS (administration) cadre. “Can I become a magistrate?” I asked myself.

I was rather irritated, but I sat for the BCS examination with no preparation at all. I just entered the exam hall and began to write. I stood second in the BCS (administration) exam and told my father that I had become a first-class gazetted officer. He smiled and told me that I would have to actually start working the job.

Eventually, I started working as a first-class government officer (magistrate) in Sirajganj in 1991, and soon realised that this was not the job for me. I joined the Bichitra again without my father’s knowledge, holing up in a house in Dhaka.

After a few months, I joined the Law Department of Dhaka University as a lecturer. I wondered if my father would agree to it -- to my utter surprise, becoming a university teacher apparently meant more to him!

That sense of overwhelming joy has remained etched in my mind throughout my life. My friends became High Court judges, major generals, and one or two full-fledged secretaries. Some of my adored ones became law-makers and ministers, and one of them even became a speaker for parliament! Many people close to me have risen from rags to riches.

I have no regrets. In fact, it really does mean a lot more to become a university teacher than any of these, I believe.

The greater insult

My firm belief is now shaken. The government has announced the new pay scale, according to which, university teachers will be the highest paid third-grade employees.

My friends who have joined the administration or the army are going to be the highest-paid first-grade employees. I have always had better results than most of my friends.

After my studentship at Dhaka University, I did my PhD abroad and obtained a post-doctoral fellowship, and 90% of the teachers of my department did the same while many of my friends in the administration did not go beyond their Master’s degree. Yet, we are third-grade and they are first-grade employees.

In the new pay scale, teachers have had a big increment. The increment is more for those who are in the administration. Even before the new pay scale was announced, they had enjoyed some other perks and facilities.

In any civilised country, teachers are paid much more than bureaucrats. It’s not really the salary that matters, it is a matter of honour and dignity. Why are we third-grade?

What makes them better?

There is propaganda out there right now which seeks to justify the new pay scale -- the major complaint being that we do not impart classes in public universities.

This might be true for some, but definitely not true for most. The key objective of teachers is to broaden the horizon of knowledge, and it is a round the clock job. Granted, there are neglectful, incompetent, and comparatively less meritorious people among us. But is there any profession in existence that doesn’t have incompetent practitioners? Does incompetence not exist within the government?

We engage in politics, we are partisan, yes, it’s all true. But don’t bureaucrats do the same? If they don’t, then why are hundreds of influential bureaucrats of one regime made OSDs (officer on special duty) with every changeover in power?

We have tarnished the image and glory of the university during both AL and BNP rules, for which we are considered to be a pro-establishment force in many instances, apparently.

What needs to be done

Public universities are autonomous institutions, but steps can be taken to standardise public universities.

My personal suggestions would be that we have to curb the power of the vice-chancellor to defy the decisions of academic committee, bring an end to partisan elections to different posts, including that of dean, put a ban on the questionable powerful deans committee, be more accountable and tough on the restructuring system that makes automatic promotions, introduce compulsory teacher assessment by the students, and impose a ban on the partisan politics of teachers and students on campus.

The government can make these happen quite easily. It is pointless to blame teachers and universities as an excuse for lowering their pay and belittling their place in society.

Demeaning university teachers is tantamount to insulting their students and the university itself. Humiliating university teachers is equal to humiliating the dignity of higher education. It is our earnest request to the government to understand the agony we teachers are going through.