In quest of status

A principal cause of the current strike of university teachers, we are told, is discrimination in new pay scales between university professors and secretaries to the government. The demands include, among other things, salary and allowance parity between senior professors and senior secretaries, and between professors and secretaries; and upgrading the status of teachers in the Warrant of Precedence. In other words, it is just not money that they are after, it is something else.

Many good things have happened in the country since we got our independence. Our literacy rate has doubled, our places of higher learning have grown ten-fold, and we produce more university graduates in a year than the total number of students who took matriculation exam in the country 45 years ago. 

But what has not changed is the mindset of our people, which we have inherited from the colonial days, first from the British and then from Pakistan. In our minds, a government job and the hedonistic compensation it provides (power and status) hold such a powerful attraction that no other profession can match.

From the colonial days, an otherwise lowly position of a thana officer yielded more awe among people than the job of a college professor, a district magistrate drew more respect and wielded more power than the wealthiest tycoon, and a secretary to the government would be respected as a deity. 

Somehow, a government job offered greater social status to an individual than other professions, no matter how low or high it was. But often the government job alone was not sufficient to warrant a place in the hierarchy of social ladder. The importance of the individual was also determined by the position that person held in the world of precedence.

We have a thing called Warrant of Precedence, prescribed and followed since the colonial days. Warrant of precedence lays down the relative precedence in terms of ranks of important functionaries belonging to the executive, legislative, and judicial organs of the state, including members of the foreign diplomatic corps.

The warrant, or the order, is generally used for the purposes of invitation of dignitaries to state and important official functions, including their seating arrangements, waiting in time to receive and see off VIPs such as the president and the prime minister when they go abroad, and also receive their counterparts within the country. 

There have been many tugs of war between interested parties in ordering and reordering this warrant of precedence both during the Pakistan days, and later in Bangladesh, particularly with military and civil authorities. Many an awkward incident has occurred over seating arrangements of who precedes whom, who is higher in rank, and where they stand in the grand order of protocol. 

In all of the past battle of ranks, teachers had never been in the fray because they are academics -- erudite scholars who are devoted to an honourable profession of educating the whole nation. I do not recall any time in my student days at home or abroad, or later through my interaction with people from this learned profession abroad, where a teacher would compare his status relative to others. Money, of course, was important then as now, but money by itself was not the biggest attraction. 

The biggest compensation was the respect and honour they received from their students and peers. Their biggest pride was the institution they served, people they taught, and research papers they published. Rankings in the warrant of precedence never occurred to any true academic. 

But we are not talking about the time or a country where education, dedication to learning, and teaching are valued anymore. In the last 45 years, during which our country made great strides forward in material welfare, we made equally great strides backward in institution building, moral values, and in breaking down the edifices of higher learning.

Unfortunately, the breakdown of the educational edifices came not from a lack of investment in bricks and mortars, but from a lack of investment in human resources that go hand in hand in building and strengthening these fine institutions.

This started with political parties extending their political outreaches to educational institutions and establishing control of the institutions through students and teachers. The logical conclusion to a politically saturated campus is an education that nurtures and produces values that are counter to good education, and good leadership.

The current university teachers’ strike may have a legitimate cause if it is anchored in directing the attention of the government to grievances related to monetary compensation. But it loses its legitimacy if it is diluted by demands for status, or a place in the warrants of precedence that may have nothing to do with showing true honour to a university teacher.

The status of a university teacher cannot be compared with any other position. It is unique. It is earned by the individuals from their students and peers. It will be demeaning to associate the status of a bureaucratic high flaunting position to that of a university professor. It is just as demeaning to the universities to associate with politics of any kind.