Why pay tax?

Not only do I pay tax, I pay supertax. I am a salaried person, after all. My income for the last two decades has been higher than the highest tax slab in existence.

The incumbent government, in order to tax the rich, has placed a supertax on those with a reported income of Tk43 lakh and above. This means that a person earning more than Tk43 lakh has to pay a 30% tax.

In order to skim off the wealthy, the government has imposed a wealth surcharge for anyone with a reported wealth of more than Tk2 crore. For Tk2cr to Tk9.99cr, the surcharge is at 10%, being charged as tax on the taxable amount.

I borrowed money from the bank to buy a piece of land. Because of that loan, I could not hide or understate the price of the land, and reported this in my wealth statement, known as IT10B.

Like myself, many bank officials and salaried persons cannot show their property at a grandfathered level. We can’t spend more and avoid taxes due to the NBR very intelligently placing a cap on our tax-free benefits too, known as perquisite limit.

We have some money in FDRs, but the FDR interest income is paid net of 10% advance income tax.

The rest of the earnings, again, attract 15% plus tax incidence once that is reported in the tax return. Most professionals, therefore, end up paying a 32% tax while the highest slab is 25%.

While the individual tax rate could be a little lower, even then we have gladly accepted this. We can’t do much for the country or community. If the government takes away a portion of our earnings and invests in the development of our nation, we don’t mind.

Most of us, the high-salaried ones, also have the luxury of visiting tax officials or referring to tax consultants, explaining some of our earnings, requesting for a review, and obtaining tax clearance.

A tax commissioner once asked my tax consultant: “Mr Rashid is often seen joining television talk shows and writing for newspapers -- how about reporting those earnings, if any, in his tax return?” I wasn’t exactly unhappy, but I thanked that lady for being so astute.

I served at the jury panel of the DHL-The Daily Star Business Award for almost 10 years. One of the conditions for the award was “contribution to the national exchequer.” We even had the NBR chairman included in the jury panel.

There has been a very sweet debate over social media about a popular economist being investigated for his allegedly undeclared assets or income. Banks were asked to submit reports in this regard, in fact.

I personally thought that while this was alright as per NBR rules and guidelines, the exact timing of this wasn’t exactly the most right.

The economist in question was deemed to have grown much difference of opinion with the government, and hence the government had been trying to harass him by investigating his unreported or under-reported income. A few months ago, we saw Nobel laureate Professor Muhammad Yunus meeting the same fate.

However, what I don’t like much is the commonly given logic of “since most politicians don’t even pay taxes, why should a lowly economist be doing so?”

This is exactly the kind of situation where the phrase “two wrongs don’t make a right” comes into effect. NBR can and should investigate anyone’s books or bank accounts.

If they find any discrepancies between someone’s lifestyle and reported earnings, or sniff out large undeclared assets not reported in their tax returns, they have the legal right to not only realise additional taxes from him or her, but to also take legal actions against that individual.

Any undeclared earning is “unearned money,” and can legally be interpreted as “laundered money.” Any individual has to face legal action for laundering money, plain and simple.

I was talking to an esteemed member of the NBR the other day, a friend of mine for many years, and I thought he should be concerned about the rather high income tax collection target.

However, he showed me the other side of the story. “If half of the individuals and institutions paying a 10% source tax can be followed up and made to pay the rest of the taxes, our income tax earnings can almost be doubled.”

Teachers, consultants, construction companies, and business houses get away by paying a 10% “tax at source” and nobody keeps track of their ultimate tax payment.

Due to this reason, the majority portion of our tax earning is indirect tax.

We are not able to tax the right people in the right way, thus most of the unorganised revenue streams remain untaxed or under-taxed.

On the other hand, in the process, we are killing the golden goose -- large business houses and foreign investors.

Telcos, financial institutions, or even corporate houses, end up paying more than 50% of their revenue to the national exchequer. For this, many of them can’t make adequate investments in network development or product-solution.

Even though I am paying a high amount in tax, I can bet that the tax authorities can’t track all my income and apply tax incidence even today.

 I also know for certain that, with more integration of the NID, more bank accounts, and more points of sale, gone will be the days of tax evasion.

At the same time, I am looking forward to a day when I will be rewarded for regular tax payment, and the NBR will return my excess tax paid with a note of thanks.