Creating a win-win situation

To keep the natural ecosystems undisturbed, and save natural resources from illicit exploitation, Community Based Adaptation to Climate Change through Coastal Afforestation project (CBACC-CF) in Bangladesh has created “ownership” and “win-win” options outside the ecosystems, resulting in the emergence of new ideas on ex situ co-management of natural resources.

Drawbacks of in situ co-management

In situ co-management with regards to ecosystems is defined as “a partnership agreement in which a resource user group gets the right to use natural resources on a defined area of state-owned land along with the responsibility to sustainably manage the resources.” Within the ecosystem, it is difficult to create a win-win situation or develop options for true ownership.

In most projects, support is provided to each family or a group of beneficiaries for capacity enhancement to manage the natural resource, and they result in benefits for some time, usually till the end of the projects. Under current in situ co-management, resource user groups are encouraged to equitably share the benefits at the maturity stage of existing resources, but it requires 10 to 15 years’ waiting time to reap the benefits.

By that time, they are compounded with complex problems induced by climate change. In most cases, subsidies are exhausted after the end of the project, and those “groups” are compelled to find their own ways to survive through illicit exploitation of ecosystems. In situ co-management is not sustainable because its success is determined within the time-frame of projects, and it is apprehended to face threats in the long run.

In fact, what is urgently needed for protecting natural resources is to create options for recurrent resources and income generation to sustain livelihoods.

Ex situ co-management in sustaining livelihood and natural resources

Instead of allowing coastal communities to plunder in the existing ecosystems for earning their livelihoods, the CBACC-CF project involved them in diversified livelihood options outside the forest and aquatic ecosystems. The project applied the FFF (Forest-Fish-Fruit) model outside the coastal forest ecosystem in 2012-14, and the VFF (Vegetable-Fish-Fruit) model outside the aquatic ecosystem in 2014.

Co-management -- outside forest ecosystems

Outside coastal forest ecosystems, hundreds of hectares of inundated and salinity-intruded khash land are lying fallow for years, which are susceptible to encroachment. The project employed the adjacent landless communities and empowered them by distributing these lands through special government notification and the applied FFF model in Naltona union of Barguna Sadar, Barguna in 2013 and in Jahajmara union of Hatiya, Noakhali in 2014.

This FFF model comprises agriculture, fisheries, livestock, and forestry severely threatened by climate change, and is a unique integrated model to adapt to climate change risks. This model has ensured recurrent resource and income generation contributing to the sustainability of land-use and livelihood security of participating landless communities. FFF beneficiaries have realised that it is essential to protect and conserve the adjacent coastal forests for the sake of saving their own resources from the adverse impacts of climatic events, and they are regularly providing voluntary guarding to the forests. Thus, ex situ co-management outside forest ecosystems reduces the illicit exploitation of natural resources which are very common in coastal Bangladesh due to manpower constraints in the government’s Forest Department (one forest guard is responsible for protecting more than 1000 hectare).

Co-management -- outside aquatic ecosystems

It has been identified that hectares of sporadically excavated land near the embankment remains barren for a long time after the construction of earthen embankments throughout Bangladesh. Earthen embankments are eroded by tidal surges, but the Bangladesh Water Development Board is not mandated to repair partially-eroded embankments until or unless it has totally disappeared.

The project has applied techniques to excavate large fresh water reservoirs instead of excavating sporadically during the construction of earthen embankments at Char Kukri Mukri in 2014. Char Kukri Mukri is an isolated island and the last settlement of Bhola where more than 15,000 people reside and mostly depend on fishing from the surrounding aquatic resources.

Before the construction of embankments, this island was inundated at least five times a year during high tides, and, as a result, residents were compelled to buy vegetables from the main land at high prices. The CBACC-CF project applied the VFF model and used these large reservoirs (excavated at the time of constructing earthen embankments) for resource-generation by involving local, landless communities and empowered them with ownership rights.

Within one season (June-October, 2014), the beneficiaries of the VFF model harvested 45,000kg of different types of vegetables and more than 21,000kg of fresh water fishes from eight reservoirs by June, 2015. After fulfilling the nutritional demand of whole island communities, surplus vegetables and fish have been sold outside of Char Kukri Mukri.

The result has created a win-win situation, and now the VFF beneficiaries are taking care of the partially or totally eroded earthen embankments. Availability of fresh water fish from reservoirs are minimising the exploitation of the surrounding aquatic resources contributing to the conservation of aquatic diversity.

The CBACC-CF project has transformed barren lands into highly productive ones. It has also provided land ownership rights to the landless and has created a win-win situation in integrating innovative livelihood models outside the coastal forest and aquatic ecosystems, ensuring the protection and conservation of natural resources through co-management.

Thus, based on the results of CBACC-CF project, the ex situ co-management can be defined as: A partnership arrangement in which a landless community gets land ownership rights on state-owned fallow land adjacent to natural resources, and is responsible for the protection of natural resources along with sustainable management of land for livelihood security.