The Blair Witch resurfaces

As a student of history, I was taught that major events in human civilisation come back after a period in some format or the other. Most of us have heard this but seeing the drums of war being beaten with gusto in the West in less than 20 years is not what many global event watchers expected.

Seeing David Cameron arguing vociferously in parliament: “We must defeat this evil and go for military action” -- is something of a déjà vu. Go back a little more than 15 years -- the same scene was acted out, almost similar rhetoric was used with an overbearing manner of forcefulness.

Needless to say, the two versions fit one template.

War, war, war, military action to exterminate radicals, clandestine developer of weapons of mass destruction -- the similarities are hard to ignore. That time, we were told or maybe harangued, of a collection of superior weapons which in reality was pure conjecture.

This time the rationale given: An ultra-radical militant force occupying large swathes of Iraq, Syria, propagating a creed of death and it needs to be subdued. In official rhetoric -- IS, attacking Western societies, disrupting social harmony, must be eliminated.

The thing is, in all this brouhaha about adopting a military strategy, not once did any of the leaders of the West ever state clearly as to why and how IS has come into being. The origin matters because, no matter how we try to find the genesis of radicalism, the finger is pointed right back at the West, who, during the relentless subterfuge of the Cold War years, recklessly exploited religious groups, communities, and societies as a way to score a point above the opponent.

Yes, Cold War matters still because the reverberations of the acts before the fall of communism are felt in current-day social/political upheavals.

Ghosts of John Le Carre’s characters keep on resurfacing in the real world; the game between Karla and Smiley was never about time-bound fiction but about an unending, always-evolving conflict.

The world cannot do without history and neither can the past be completely erased. Regrettably, a cynical observation that comes to mind: History teaches us one lesson and that is we never learn from it.

Powerful nations which had to experience tragedies may feel that, unless they show some force, their authority in the face of the world and, in front of their own people, stands to appear feeble. So, aircrafts filled with bombs are unleashed, photos of damage inflicted on the enemy proudly shown by the media, the frenzied masses are somewhat pacified.

The popularity ratings also show signs of rapid rise, as with the case with the French premiere!

Time and again, especially in recent weeks, we have heard leaders committing to “complete destruction of IS,” though this line, with a little thought, appears to be mere bravado devoid of meaning.

Is it possible to exterminate an idea which has now spread across the globe?

Take the latest California shooting into perspective. The two people involved -- a Muslim man and his reportedly introverted housewife -- had no direct connection with IS whatsoever, yet they operated as lone wolves influenced by the ideology.

I have said this earlier: Pummeling oil depots and military outposts can reduce fighting capability; they will hardly defeat/dent an entrenched belief.

One can always adopt a meek stance while carrying out volcanic rage inside the heart! Shall we call it Trojan subservience?

From what we have read in the reports, the woman in the California killings had a child, led a life away from public gaze, spoke very little English, and was shy. This means she was never deemed a threat.

There are millions of such women in almost all Western societies and no one knows who will, at a certain stage, feel the urge to break from passive existence to an aggressive one.

With reported rising of Islamophobia in many towns in the West, any ordinary person, hitherto harmless, may suddenly feel a desire to erupt.

As leaders stand in parliament, foaming at the mouth, demanding military action to eliminate a pernicious force, they also need to acknowledge that it was their follies along with impetuous acts, defended with ferocious intensity earlier, that have thrown the world into a whirlpool.

It’s greatly distressing that innocent people have to give their lives in such horrific circumstances; in Paris, Beirut, California, people who have no part in making foreign policy.

In retaliation, the standard approach is a bellicose one, which, in the long run, will lead to a sort of paranoia in Western societies where Muslims in general will be looked at with deep suspicion.

The possible result of that is a total fragmentation of the much vaunted multicultural fabric -- alienating one section from the rest to a level in which more extreme acts can germinate.

Several social analysts feel that disenchantment within the Muslim communities in Western states emanates not exclusively from the perception that their religion is being targeted but also from a growing feeling that, they, as part of a different society, are never allowed to break the glass ceiling and hold better employment plus social status.

Recently, I had the chance to talk to a British Asian who went to Cambridge and the version that person held on the recent happenings was: Imperialism pursued remorselessly for centuries and the shenanigans of the Cold War period must have some form of repercussion.

Maybe more attention has to be given to addressing the unspoken grievances within the Muslim communities in Western societies. The resurgence of the Blair witch may present images of gallantry and military virility, but silent transformation of people into dark wolves can’t be contained. And therein lies the actual threat.

A quote from Bertrand Russell comes to my mind: “Most of the greatest evils that man has inflicted on man have come through people feeling quite certain about something which, in fact, was false.”