It’s hugely disturbing to see mobile phone footage capturing unarmed, unsuspecting, often wounded civilians in Paris running away from assailants. What is even more disconcerting is the fact that the targeted people were killed, reportedly, as a protest against a country’s foreign policy. It seems the standard rule of warfare followed in the days of canons, muskets, and horses, where two sides faced each other, is lost. Despite many historical wars having layers of subterfuge preceding them, the actual battle eventually was face to face.
Here, in modern times, the fight has taken a diabolical form. With so many civilians dead in Paris, and France in a state of emergency, one is compelled to think beyond banal fiery rhetoric. From what we have heard in the news, the killers were on a suicide mission: Kill and then kill yourself.
The question that immediately comes is: How can one fight or expect to win against an opponent that wants to die? Just a few days ago, while listening to the news, the French government’s decision to send her aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle to fight IS militants came and, for a second, the thought of possible reprisal surfaced and disappeared. It seems now that my premonition was not just a fleeting apprehension.
With so many dead, the French government has issued a declaration of war. While this sounds courageous and resolute, the question remains: War against whom? As a global citizen, do we have any idea about the structure of IS or its area of operation? In fact, if we take several unconnected incidents across the world which were claimed by one militant group or the other with some form of allegiance to IS, then the realisation is that any individual, working alone, in a state of disenchantment bordering on hatred or xenophobia, can carry out a massacre in the name of doing his or her part for IS.
If that is so, the first war many Western nations have to fight is within their own country, addressing the stark social divisions which resulted in many people taking up the radical cause. An international channel, after the Paris carnage, stated that, despite France having the largest concentration of Muslims in Europe, there is a sense of resentment among a vast number of Muslims over the country’s foreign policy.
Now, this disapproval will not compel most people to carry out acts of violence, however, there will be some, maybe a handful, who will be inclined to take the extreme path.
In the UK, there was a visible social outcry when young girls were seen to be heading for Syria, and while many in the families of those who left later on said they had no clue about the intentions of their sons or daughters, it can’t be denied that failure to integrate into British society and disillusionment arising from possible prejudiced treatment at work, or other places, provided the foundation for the UK-deserting motivation.
Dropping bombs and sending military aircraft for thousands of sorties can do widespread material damage, but maybe the first priority has to be a candid dialogue with Muslim expatriate communities in Western societies about foreign policy, which appears to be the single, most plausible reason for resentment to brew and erupt.
Let’s go back a decade: When the coalition forces, on the basis of fallacious information and deluded beliefs, attacked Iraq, there was simmering discontent all over the Muslim world. Saddam was never an untainted man, but for over a decade he was made, armed, and controlled by the powers that later killed him. In the Iraq-Iran war, the first acts of bellicosity were carried out by Iraq, evidently with Western blessing.
The much-needed ally then turned into a global threat plus pariah because, reportedly, a defector from the Iraqi cabinet provided “undisputable” information about the presence of weapons of mass destruction.
The Iraq invasion may seem ages ago, but that and the Libya escapade, in which large number of pro-Gaddafi fighters left with sophisticated weapons to a safer place, gave birth to severe ideological plus political polarisations -- one of the results of which is the IS
Well, that is what most laypersons, including this writer, understand. Can anyone show any positive outcomes of an invasion? Afghanistan is unstable, Somalia dysfunctional, Libya torn by ethnic conflict, and Iraq hanging by a thread.
One should look up the vociferous arguments that Tony Blair put up before the British parliament to justify engaging in Iraq. With so much evidence now suggesting that the notion of WMD’s was just a hoax, Blair is left blushing.
Meanwhile, the damage has been done.
Problem is, these acts sowed deep hatred in many of the Muslim communities within Western countries. Extremists do not have to come in, they are often home-grown.
It’s deeply upsetting that people out for fun at the beginning of the weekend should be gunned down just 10 months after a similar attack on a magazine in the same city. The war that France has declared should be aimed not overseas but within the country first, because, unless social cohesion is ensured with trust won from the Muslim sections, warplanes, ships, and soldiers will only prolong a savage confrontation with no side coming out victorious.
May the souls of those killed in Paris rest in peace.