Done to death

Let us now rejoice at the sentencing of Rajon’s infamous killers, who have been handed down the death penalty for torturing the boy on camera. The convicts were Kamrul, Moina, Tajuddin, and Zakir. Zakir, so far, is in hiding. They were also slapped with a fine of Tk10,000 each.

Let us now also rejoice at the awarding of the death penalty to Rakib’s killers: Sharif and Mintu. These blokes were owners of a certain Sharif Motors, with Mintu being Sharif’s uncle. Beauty Begum, Sharif’s mother, who had held him back while Sharif and Mintu tortured him and, eventually, brought about his death, was acquitted. Woe is us.

Word of mouth and the Internet reek of pleasure. Justice has been served, they say; these inhumane humans will receive, finally, what’s coming to them. The Hand of God, via these uncapitalised hands of ours, will strike them down with Divine Justice.

I see words of jubilant celebration echoed in the intonations of my friends, colleagues, acquaintances. The death knell rings for these insipid souls; their impending death is merely a fraction of the pain and suffering they had wielded at their hands, against children no less, against minors who had done little to deserve to be at the end of such unwarranted violence.

Yay.

Indeed. In this narrative of subjectivity, one finds it difficult to be objective, to be rational, unbiased. But one can try. And if the “one” sounds too inclusive, like too much of an attempt to bring you into the fold of an unwilling attempt, then I shall use the singular first person henceforth.

But yes, it has become increasingly difficult to say the right thing for the wrong people. With so much death, violence, rape, harassment, corruption, traffic jams, heat, et cetera, et cetera, infinite et cetera, why would someone wish to try and puncture this happy, jubilant balloon and let the public not have its one, singular moment of joy?

Death penalties are a complex issue. But fact: No developed nation in the world has the death penalty, except for the United States and Japan. Fact: There is no evidence that supports the claim that the death penalty prevents future crimes. Fact: Innocent people get killed due to insufficient evidence, incompetent lawyers, ineffectual trials, inadequate technology, with the number being a whopping one out of 25 in the US. Fact: Death penalty trials are longer and hence, more expensive for us, the citizens, the tax-payers.

Opinion: Murder for murder cannot be a civilised reaction in the 21st century. Not to go around touting an old Gandhian proverb, but a blind world cannot be on our agenda for the future. Violence has always begotten violence, and when the world, and especially our nation, is so bogged down by such excesses of it, continuing that culture of taking life away when it need not be, is redundant, morose, ugly.

One was witness to the same kind of fervour during the Shahbagh protests. If I’m not mistaken, most of the protesters were composed of a liberal mindset, constituting the more progressive nook of the Bangladeshi middle and upper-middle classes.

It was surprising to see the same crowd call for death, the same crowd who are so intent on valuing life in the now. But perhaps that is a false dichotomy perpetrated by Western media: Republicans vs Democrats, pro-lifers vs pro-choice, pro-capital punishment vs the opposite.

What we “need,” however, is a relative matter, unless one is citing food and air. Do we need capital punishment?

Opinion: We don’t. If one were to take God out of the equation, just for a moment, then death seems almost merciful. Spending life inside the confines of a disgusting prison cell (the quality of prisons is another issue, for another time) seems more fitting for child torturers and murderers, where they may be exposed to all sorts of other, similarly heinous individuals and politics, who treat them with cruelty that is “befitting” their crime.

Opinion: Even if one were to reinsert God back into the equation, and believes in the idea of life after death and divine justice, God will take care of the person when his time comes, while he watches a flashback made-for-TV movie on the big screen of judgement day. There is, of course, the paradoxical argument which claims that God oftentimes works through us, and we are left wondering who wields the hand that ties the noose and brings down the sword: God or us?

Opinion: It makes us the better person, the bigger individual, to not respond to violence with violence, to murder with murder. The right to take life away has not been bestowed upon most of us, then why the government? If we are not allowed to kill someone who has killed someone we love, why should the state?

Having never lost a dear member at someone else’s hands, my claim to objectivity is definitely easier. Opinion: We should strive for objectivity in our viewpoints when we are fighting for a cause that affects more than just us, and think about the long term ramifications of not just having an archaic system such as the death penalty, but other similar concepts leftover from bygone days.

Fact: Taking major decisions while angry, hurt, sad, basically under the influence of emotions has almost never resulted in picking the more effective long-term choice. Opinion: A future of violence is as little palatable to the taste-buds as a history of one.