For a developing nation like Bangladesh, the child labour issue, especially as domestic help, is a bit of a paradox.
Morally, it cannot be endorsed but, when looked at from the perspective of the worker who would rather earn a living than starve or remain as a perceived burden on a large family, this is one practice which has to be accommodated.
Of course, once we begin to attach some basic ethical values in this arrangement, the atmosphere of work can be tolerable, and at times, a joy for the young worker, be it a girl or a boy.
Unfortunately, the actual reality of domestic help below the age of 15 is often very harsh, as we have come to find with the outrageous case of a girl who was tortured by none other than a national cricket team player.
The sportsman in question and his wife reportedly beat the 11-year-old-girl, employed to look after his infant, with a cooking spatula, forcing her to sleep in the toilet allegedly for about a year.
The girl has told law enforcement that the physical torture was the final layer after initial reprimand involving verbal abuse.
This case involving a national/international level sports personality has been featured in all media outlets, bringing to the front the plight of young children who work in urban homes.
In true knee-jerk fashion, a lot of us are filled with repulsion after the misbehaviour of the cricketer and his wife came out in the open, but maybe when we are unitedly pointing a finger at someone, it’s wise to keep in mind that the blame lies on the whole of society and not just one couple.
To trace the root of employing young children from under-privileged backgrounds, we need to go back to the 70s when a famine in the country drove thousands from the villages to head for the city and towns to look for work.
In those post-war situations of confusion and privation, the only demand was food, three square meals a day and nothing else. For about four to five years, thousands worked in urban households only for food.
In that atmosphere of desperation, the first ground for exploitation and abuse was formed.
The domestic help accepted that, as part of their work, they will be punished and, sometimes, physically abused.
To be blunt: This ill-treatment was not confined to middle-class households only. The same culture prevailed in wealthy or affluent homes where slapping, deprivation of food, and locking in toilets were common.
While the improvement of the economic situation brought in the blessing of a monthly salary, unnecessary punishing of domestic help, especially the young ones, continued.
The attitude of the employer seemed to suggest, in exchange for food plus money, everything needed to be tolerated.
The common “faults” included eating pieces of meat or fish without permission (a grave sin until the early 90s), hiding toys belonging to the family child or even taking them or, stealing a clothing item.
Still today, in many homes, two types of rice are cooked: The fine variety for the home members and a coarse one for the workers. This distinction was even more pronounced in the late 70s and 80s.
For minor transgressions, young maids were beaten up; in fact, one of my cousins scalded a young girl working in their house with an iron.
The episode was quickly hushed up with a little extra money to the mother. In a twist of fate, that cousin works part-time as a baby-sitter in the USA now; I wonder if she remembers the cruel streak she had in Bangladesh.
A few years ago, there was a hullabaloo in the house of one of our relatives, and we found that the young girl, almost crossing adolescence, was being chastised because she had stolen a few undergarments belonging to a family member.
The anger was filled with venom, the rebuke scathing. The girl, with head bowed silently, faced the accusations: Thief, low born, ingrate ...
It never occurred to anyone to just think for a few moments about the episode and what had driven the girl to do what she did. Coming from a poor background, growing up in a city home, it’s only natural that at a certain age she would feel the desire to own things beyond her reach, perhaps out of sheer romanticism that accompanies the age, obscuring the line between privileged and non-privileged.
Would it have been a mammoth sacrifice if the items she had taken were to be given to her with the added line that, if she liked something she could ask for it.
No, that does not mean everything has to be handed out, but these small mistakes do not warrant severe punishment.
Come to think of it: Politicians in Bangladesh have always gone scot-free, stealing million times more and doing far more diabolical acts of venality only to be revered in society.
I find it funny when the wife of a known corrupt tax official living in my area resorts to strenuous bargaining over the monthly salary of a house-maid. According to her, it’s criminal for a worker to demand a Tk1,000 increase.
If there is a social survey, the startling revelation will be that most young domestic workers hardly earn over Tk1,500 per month, the amount most urban households spend for a few burgers in one evening.
The domestic help, the boy or a girl, will eat a little more, take a few toys, or break a few things because they are just like any one of us, humans with faults; the question we never ask is why, living with so much hypocrisy all around, compromising with them readily (fawningly), we only want the young people working for us to be the examples of moral correctness?
I am not a saint, but know that the people who work as domestic help will forget some instructions, save a few hundred from the shopping to keep it for themselves, make up a false illness to take a day off, pinch a clothing item, take it to the village and say it’s lost, or break something while working absent-mindedly.
Honestly speaking, being imperfect myself, I can live with that! Can you?