Last month, when Republican presidential candidate and retired neurosurgeon Dr Ben Carson shared his views on a future Muslim president, he was, with some justice, the recipient of an avalanche of criticism around the globe, including pointed rebuttals from even some of the most conservative candidates in his own party.
None other than the darling of right-wing populist Republicans, Senator Ted Cruz of Texas, took the physician to task by reminding everyone that the American Constitution, unlike many others in the world, specifically prohibits any religious litmus test for holding a public office.
Ben Carson is currently polling at number one or number two in every poll at the national and state levels for the Republican Party nomination and, thus, has a possibility, if not a probability, of becoming America’s president. Thus, for obvious reasons, what he says matters a little more than the average politician seeking elected office.
The problem is that his critics on the issue heard him without listening to him. I am no fan of the good doctor’s politics; quite the contrary, truth be told. In the interest of full disclosure, I am an avid supporter of Governor Jeb Bush, Carson’s opponent for the presidential nomination and brother of former President George W Bush in whose 2000 campaign I had the privilege of working.
The distinguished neurosurgeon actually never said that the US constitution prohibited a Muslim from becoming president; he simply said that he would have trouble voting for one. Furthermore, as he quickly clarified, he would gladly support a Muslim candidate for president if that individual renounced fealty to the desert law code known as “Sharia.”
Frankly, I too cannot support a candidate for public office who believes in the public application of any religiously derived set of social controls, be it from the Talmud, the Old Testament, the Qur’an, or the Upashinads.
Private observance of religious rituals and worship are uplifting for many; public implementation of social controls mandated by religious texts is a major human rights problem, as has been shown repeatedly in our own times in Afghanistan, Iran, Saudi Arabia, the ISIS “caliphate,” and the late Ziaul Huq’s Pakistan. Heck, we don’t have to go too far out of Dhaka to hear regularly occurring stories of how some village shaalish or mullah pronounced a fatwa against a woman or a member of a religious minority.
Sure, academics and professional apologists alike can debate till the end of the day about what Sharia really means, and how glorious were the days of desert empires of 10th century Baghdad or the decadent empires of 15th century Constantinople.
But we live in 2015, and the only real version of a phenomenon we know for a fact is what we see on the ground around us, a sight which is not pretty in this instance. In its mildest manifestation, Sharia today reflects an overbearing obsession with women’s attire and an equally unhealthy desire to curtail the rights of religious minorities. The more draconian versions, of course, have unelected despotism integrated with barbaric practices like grotesque limb amputations, sex slavery masquerading as polygamy, child marriages, hatred of individual liberty, and gratuitous intolerance of dissent.
Despite toiling away in the trenches of higher education, I am a practical man who values concrete contemporary evidence far above the minutiae of academic abstractions. How noble or “liberal” past societies ruled by Sharia may have been is immaterial to me; even less important are the endless television debates about what the “real” Sharia means for the 21st century.
Like a vast majority of modern men and women who value their freedoms and respect the inherent equality of individuals before the law, I look at how public life is lived in Saudi Arabia and Iran, in Pakistan’s tribal hinterlands, and in Daesh’s “caliphate,” and shudder at even a hundredth of such dystopian barbarity in any society of which I am a part.
Perhaps the framers of the 1972 constitution of Bangladesh knew a thing or two about how the lure of triumphalist religiosity could unleash demons of retrogressive bigotry full scale; hence, they were careful to pencil in secularism as a state principle. That some of those very framers, within years, betrayed secularism, democracy, and individual liberty does not take away from the nobility of those timeless ideals.
The words of Dr Ben Carson are unartful and, indeed, hurtful to many of his fellow citizens; but the wisdom behind those words is worthy of reflection by all of us who take certain modern freedoms for granted or aspire to the same.