The second national debate of the 15 Republican candidates hosted on September 15 by CNN left millions of Americans, and millions more watching outside the country, wondering even more seriously about their views and their policies than after the first debate held a month ago. There was also very little in the way of vision from any of the candidates.
What the 15 succeeded in doing, nevertheless, is, through a series of personal attacks and rebuttals on one another, to establish that the Republican Party has a very serious problem looking into the 2016 polls. They have no one yet in the pack that stands out to become the 45th President of the United States.
Donald Trump, who went to the debate leading the pack by a significant margin, underlined why the debate not only failed to resolve the problem of the Republican Party in choosing a candidate, but also further complicated it. He entered the debate with a 33% rating, with his nearest candidate, an African-American retired surgeon, Dr Benn Carson, at 20%, and most of the rest in the single digits.
He got those numbers despite his bizarre performance in the first debate, and even more bizarre follow-up on that bizarre performance. In fact, his bizarre views and bizarre performances that have put him on top are still keeping him there.
The second debate showed that the Republican Party has unwittingly fallen into the disastrous path that Donald Trump set since announcing his candidature and participating in the first debate. Most of the 15 hopefuls were thus bashing the immigrants, competing with one another to take the country to war against Iran on the nuclear issue, abusing President Putin like he was some third-world leader that America could abuse and humiliate. They also seemed like they were in a competition to insult President Obama.
On planned parenthood, the candidates pushed the party to extreme positions and turned gay marriage into a major issue for the 2016 presidential election. In fact, the economy, that in past presidential elections had been the most important issue to determine the winner and the loser, figured in the second debate only at the fag end, like it was an after-thought.
It was palpably evident after the second debate that whatever the candidates expressed so far on national issues were those that appealed to sections that together would be far short for sending a Republican candidate to the White House. If that was not bad enough, the world-view of the candidates underlined how far they were from reality.
With the exception of Governor Kasich, to some extent, the rest expressed views on foreign affairs (that surprisingly topped the list of issues debated) like it was the unquestionable right of the US to tell the world what to do. In expressing such an unrealistic and absurd world-view, the candidates nevertheless also made unashamed efforts to put the interests of Israel ahead of even those of their own country, like the voters to whom they were appealing were Israelis and not those in the United States.
All the candidates blamed President Obama for US’s present position in the world, where they believed it has little respect. Thus, when Donald Trump stated that he would build the biggest wall with Mexico and make the latter pay for it, there was no protest from the others. Likewise, when he expressed the desire to put ground troops, thousands of them, in Iraq to annihilate ISIS, others were equally hawkish.
Again, with the exception of Governor Kasich, all the other candidates stated that the Iran nuclear deal was a bad one. Senator Cruz stated that, on his first day as president, he would tear the deal and throw it into the waste-paper basket.
None of the candidates cared to even think about what the rest of the world would do with such a world-view of a future US president. For instance, they were all in denial that US’s European partners had endorsed the Iran nuclear deal, and had openly urged the US to do so. These candidates were also in denial that China and Russia, who have also signed the deal, would refuse to accept the view expressed by these candidates, and the US simply does not have the ability to impose its will on the world stage with these two major powers in opposition.
The debates exposed and underlined that Washington outsiders now have the Republican Party, with their Tea Party mind-set, cornered on their perceived notion that the rest of the country is unhappy with the federal government. Thus, people like Donald Trump, Ben Carson (a retired surgeon), and Carly Fiona (who is a former CEO of Hewlett Packard) are the front-runners overwhelmingly, and senators, former senators, governors with Washington experience, and all seasoned politicians are languishing at the bottom and talking like Washington is the root of all the country’s problems.
If this trend does not change, the Republicans will end up choosing someone from a small town in the south -- someone with no clue about Washington or the world, contesting for the most powerful political office anywhere.
The elections are, however, 14 months away -- the Republicans will choose the final candidate at the Republican National Convention, to be held in Cleveland in July of next year. And, in making that choice, the powerful Republican National Committee that has not yet stepped into the act would play a very important role. The committee, which hoped that Donald Trump would sign his name off into oblivion with his bizarre performance, must now be worried that he is still holding on to his lead. It is also worried that the candidate with whom it would feel comfortable to win the White House, Governor Jeb Bush, performed poorly in the last debate.
The Republicans’ worries have been further exacerbated because Donald Trump, with his extreme and bizarre views, has influenced other candidates to follow his path to reach the extreme right of the party to get the nomination. Thus, even if the RNC succeeded in denying him the nomination, Donald Trump may have already caused the GOP enough damage for the eventual fight against the Democratic candidate for the White House, and the longer he stays in the run for the nomination, the greater the damage he would be causing the party.
The Republicans now have a few major problems in its hands: First, to deny Donald Trump the nomination; second, to move the party back to issues that voters would be interested in in a presidential election; and finally, to choose a candidate who would be able to articulate those issues in running his/her candidature.
The Democrats have taken great comfort from the second GOP debate, although their own front-runner Hillary Clinton is showing a decline in her ratings nationally, owing to her problems with the “emailgate.”
Nevertheless, Eugene Robinson, in an op-ed for the Washington Post on September 14, argued that although “she keeps putting obstacles in her own path ... Hillary Clinton remains the odds-on favorite to become our next president.” The columnist argued for Hillary Clinton based mainly on the Republican Party debates that revealed and underlined “total anarchy” prevailing in the Republican Party.