It was unfortunate -- and unacceptable -- to see that the private university students, who were protesting to withdraw the levy of the 7.5% VAT from higher education, were injured by rubber bullets shot by the police on September 9 in front of East West University.
As we all are guaranteed “protection of law,” the “right to assembly,” “freedom of movement,” and “freedom of thought, conscience, and speech” by the constitution of Bangladesh, they have exercised these rights to protest on the streets.
But Wednesday’s shooting left a black mark on the police’s image, an action that needs to be investigated properly and the police personnel concerned should be brought under judicial trial for not using proportionate force against the students.
In recent years, we have seen a growing tendency of using force and lethal firearms by law enforcement agencies on civilian protesters around the world, which are often being criticised as being unjustified and not proportionate. In cities like Damascus, London, and Kiev, civilian protests have faced unnecessary, indiscriminate, disproportionate, widespread attacks by law enforcement agencies.
In Bangladesh, it has been a growing concern for us that the number of deaths by “crossfire” or by shootouts with law enforcement agencies has been increasing. According to Ain O Salish Kendra, 128 people died in “crossfires” and “gunfights” between law enforcers and alleged “criminals” in 2014, while the number was 72 in 2013.
Now, there needs to be an investigation with the highest focus on what provoked or compelled the police to fire upon the unarmed student protesters on Wednesday. Could they have not used batons or water-sprays or any other form of non-lethal weapons? Could they not have arrested the students instead of firing on them? Or just stand, wait, and negotiate with the students? Was it a riot which had gone out of control? Did any of the students vandalise vehicles?
Although rubber bullets are considered less harmful than the metal jacket bullet, when fired from a close distance, they can be lethal. From the pictures and videos that have been shared on social media, newspapers, and TV, the police were seen firing at the students from close range, violating the clear provisions of Rule 152 (ii) of Police Regulations Bengal, 1943. This left several members of the faculty and students of EWU injured.
In the legal field, there is a principle called the “doctrine of proportionality.” None of the jurisprudences around the world allow punishment that is greater than the actual offence. This is the same moral principle of “to shoot out of cannon into sparrows.” This forbids us from taking unnecessary and indiscriminate measures on the opponent.
Most modern constitutions provide citizens with a set of rights and freedoms, with the guarantee that all forms of expression are protected. But these constitutions have also allowed the state machineries to limit or intrude upon these protections, as long as the respective states do so proportionally.
This has created a dilemma. On the one hand, citizens’ life, liberty, and property are protected against police intrusion. On the other, the police are entitled to do what is necessary for public safety and order. The debate on what is considered “proportionate” use of force remains unresolved.
It mostly depends on the interpretation of the court within the concerned local boundary. Although there is no hard and fast rule to determine the proportionality, the following questions are considered in international humanitarian law: Was the target a legitimate object? Was the legitimate object specific? Was the specific legitimate object a threat to law and order? Was the action necessary? And was it the last resort to deal with that specific legitimate object?
The doctrine of proportionality is also used in other fields of law, like civil, criminal, or business law. However, the above questions of humanitarian law can also be invoked in other areas of law in order to determine proportionality.
We can ask the same questions to determine the proportionality of police force used against the EWU students. As they were protesting for their “right to education” in a non-violent way, they were not “legitimate objects.” They were not demanding anything illegal.
The police did not have a specific target, since two university teachers were also injured, although they were not protesting along with the students. Were the students really a threat to law and order?
Their protests were organised and peaceful, and there was no vandalism. Nor have they called for any violent moves.
Was it really necessary to fire on the students? The deputy registrar of EWU complained that the police fired on the students without any precaution, while they were returning back to EWU after the blockade. Was firing the last resort for the police to disburse to the students? The answer is a simple no. Instead of being more patient, tactical, and responsible, the police put innocent lives in danger.
Police are permitted to use firearms for the following three purposes only: If they see that a person’s life or property is in danger and the right of private defense is necessary to be exercised, for the dispersal of unlawful assemblies, and if a person creates obstacles to be arrested.
The police cannot kill someone during arrest. The use of firearms is strictly limited to the situation where it is the last resort. On Wednesday, the police did not follow any of these legal provisions.
It is high time that we ratify the “Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials,” which was adopted by the Eighth United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders at Havana, Cuba in 1990. Our civil and criminal laws should also be reformed according to these basic principles.
Moreover, we need to reshape and develop police training with more emphasis on basic human rights and principles so that our police can learn to respect and protect citizens, instead of hurting them when they are not justified in doing so.