The cabinet, last Monday, approved the new pay scale for public servants. Though the number of public servants is around 1.4 million, the pay rise is expected to impact the salaries of almost 2.1 million people, including the armed forces and people serving in various autonomous and semi-autonomous or quasi-government bodies.
The government, or rather the finance division, has decided to implement the recommendation of the eighth national pay commission, in phases -- the basic payment from July 1 this year and allowance payment from July 1, 2016. The country has spent Tk44,452cr for the payment of salaries for its government employees in the last fiscal. This year, this is going to cost the country Tk60,356cr.
Net increase due to the pay rise would be Tk15,904cr. While it was 17.7% of last year’s budget outlay, this year, it is going to be 20.1% of the Tk295,000cr budget. Next fiscal year, with the implementation of the full recommendation, or inclusion, of allowance payments, the figure is going to be Tk69,918cr with an overall increase of Tk23,828cr.
Was it the right thing to do? Yes, possibly -- government employees have deserved a pay rise in last six and half years in tackling price hikes and inflationary pressure. Did they deserve a 91% to 101% increase in their salaries? That’s fine as well. Was it right to do away with time scale and selection grade? This time scale or selection grade was creating too many anomalies within the system. Primary school head-masters were already shedding tears, being the most impacted party.
With no time scale or selection grade, people will be identified according to their grades. Why only 20 grades? The secretaries committee has, in fact, recommended for 16 grades. History tells us, there were more than 3,000 different grades during the Pakistan period. It was brought down, or rationalised, to 20 grades in 1972.
It became 30 grades in 1977 and became 20 grades again in 1980 onward. How do you draw a rationale between lowest and highest payments? While the lowest basic is Tk8,250 and highest is Tk78,000, the highest is 9.5 times higher than the lowest. In India, it is 12 times higher. I personally like this special Boishakhi allowance and annual increment tied up with basic pay.
How is the government going to generate the additional money required for this pay rise? The generic reply is: “From the additional earnings of the government.” The least discussed source is: “The savings of the fuel price reduction,” which was not passed on to the common people. Will it trigger further price hikes in the market or create inflation? Possibly not ... that is, other than the episodic or speculative rise in the prices of day-to-day essentials.
This is, again, likely to reflect through house rent and conveyance, especially rickshaw fares. Our economists have conventionally been blaming import-pushed inflation driven by commodity prices. This time, thanks to slowing demand in China, most of the commodities have seen drastic reductions in prices. With a bit of market monitoring, inflation will not rule over the market this time.
Economists feel that the impact of the inflation depends on the size of impact on aggregate demand. The size of aggregate demand depends on the extent of the pay rise and the share of public consumption expenditure.
While the share of public expenditure is 10% of the GDP, the extent of pay rise is around $2 of the GDP. This means aggregate demand may rise by 0.2 percentage points of the GDP, if the entire increase is spent on consumption.
Assuming there will be no output response to aggregate demand increase, this implies temporarily adding 0.2 percentage points to inflation for the pay rise. The number will be lower if there is any positive output response to the aggregate demand increase, and if part of the pay rise is saved. However, it may be higher if the public sector pay increase spills over to private sector wages.
However, the million dollar question still remains unanswered: Will this pay rise increase the productivity of public servants, or help reduce corruption? I guess we don’t have much in the way of good news here. While the pay rise will, of course, help some very honest public servants, as a whole, corruption will not go down at all. Should this motivate public servants to improve their service delivery or overall attitude towards the public good? Not really.
A police sub-inspector I met the other day told me: “Sir, all my friends from the same batch trained in Sardah Police Academy and are serving in the districts or sub-districts, while I have come to Gulshan. Do you think that happened all by itself?” I didn’t have answers for him, but knew for sure that an increase by a few thousand taka is not going to pacify him at all. Seniors often say “chore na shune dhormer kahini” (a thief will not listen to religious guidelines). Only accountability and improved governance can reduce the plight of our people.
Another big question remains entirely undiscussed: What about downsizing the government? Why don’t we reduce the number of ministries? Why don’t we go with optimum capacity modelling (OCM) for the civil and military organisations? Do we need so many secretaries, so many generals?
Our finance division is finicky about some public universities, or certain departments in the universities, having more professors than lecturers. How about reviewing the future manpower requirement of the civil and military organisations? Should the pyramid model be in effect everywhere?
No matter how much we increase our revenue earnings, we can’t allocate more money into social infrastructures such as education and health, if we have to continuously pay for large and semi-efficient public servants, that is. This is equally applicable for budget allocations and directly related to efficiency and accountability improvement of the government itself.