Tax and wane

When we were taught about human rights, we came to know about the “need-based approach,” the “charity-based approach,” and the “rights-based approach.” All these three approaches are considered ways for a modern nation-state to secure the rights of its citizens. Now, the question is: Which approach should the state follow?

A need-based approach is a kind of temporary solution that is followed during an emergency, usually for a particular need. A charity-based approach is a kind of top-down approach, where people receive aid from a higher or influential authority or from a privileged section of society.

But the rights-based approach always says that the state shall respect and abide by the internationally settled norms and principles of human rights in each and every decision that the state makes. It is the people’s inherent and indivisible right to be protected by the state during times of peril. In this sense, the state cannot make such rules or regulations that hamper or curtail the enjoyment of these rights by its people.

Now, the first question is, as a state, is Bangladesh obliged to follow the rights-based approach in every aspect of its affairs or not? And, secondly, is the right to education protected and promoted by Bangladesh as one of the fundamental human rights?

According to the preamble of our constitution, it is declared that rule of law and fundamental human rights will be secured for all citizens. We also have declared in the preamble that it is our sacred duty “to make our full contribution towards international peace and co-operation in keeping with the progressive aspirations of mankind.”

In Article 11, it is said that the fundamental human rights shall be guaranteed by the republic and it will be ensured in administration at all levels through effective participation by the people through their elected representatives. And in Article 25, the republic confirms that it will respect the international law and the principles enunciated in the United Nations Charter.

This means, being a signatory, Bangladesh is bound to respect and oblige by the internationally settled norms and principles of human rights according to Article 55 and 56 of the UN Charter. So, from our constitution and the UN Charter, it is evident that Bangladesh is not only bound to respect the rights-based approach, but is also bound to promote and implement internationally settled principles and norms of human rights in every sphere of the state’s affairs.

That is why the right to education under Article 26 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 13 of the International Covenant of Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) should be followed by the Bangladeshi government as well.

Unfortunately, according to our constitution, the right to education is neither considered a fundamental human right and nor does it have any judicial enforceability, resulting in us being unable to approach a regular court if our right to education is curtailed or if any decision is taken which is detrimental to the enjoyment of it.

Article 15 of our constitution puts it under “basic necessities” and the state will take effective measures to promote the educational needs of society under Article 17. But, according to Article 8 (1) of the constitution, these principles in Article 15 and 17 shall be applied by the state in the making of laws and shall be a guide to the interpretation of the constitution and of other laws.

Moreover, if we take the essence of the Masdar Hossain case, which was decided in 1999, the state cannot bypass the obligations to follow the fundamental principles of state policies that are enshrined in part II of the constitution. So, from the abovementioned national and international laws and principles, education shall be considered a “human right,” not a commodity.

According to Section 41, 42, and 44 of the Private University Act, 2010, private universities cannot collect and spend any fund except to promote education, being non-profit entities. But, VAT is considered a form of consumption tax that is imposed on commercial bodies.

Now, can we say that the private universities are peddling a commodity? Is education a commodity, or is it a human right? If it is a human right, is it justifiable to levy a 7.5% VAT on private education? Does that decision comply with the national and international laws, norms, and principles?

The answer is a simple no. Our government should neither impose VAT on the right to education, nor should it derogate from the principles laid out in our constitution, the UN Charter, UDHR, and ICESCR. Any attempt like that should be protested and stopped by citizens.

As a government that is failing constantly to provide free education to us, despite spending billions of dollars in the misguided policies, and fanciful projects, it should not interfere with any private initiative providing education.

The historic Mujibnagar Government of 1971 declared the Independence of Bangladesh based on equality, human dignity, and social justice. Perhaps it is the legal version of our much debated “swadhinotar chetona.” But by imposing a 7.5% tax on our students, what kind of equality, human dignity, and justice will we achieve?