There was a time in the Indian Union, not too long ago, when travelling by car meant one of two things -- either you were in a private car, or you were in a taxi. However, smartphone app-based instant-hire car services have become extremely popular amongst certain sectors of the population in some cities of the Indian Union.
Companies like Uber and Ola have been doing extremely well in India and their name recognition has been increasing very quickly. Business has been so good that Uber claims Kolkata to be its fastest growing market after the USA, and having better growth than London.
In the Indian Union, Mumbai is its second fastest growing market after Kolkata. Other leading Indian Union cities aren’t far behind. Services like these have undercut the business of traditional licensed taxis in many parts of the world, and the same goes for the Indian Union.
The app-based hired-car business model has been termed unfair by taxi drivers, taxi owners, and unions, who have protested against companies like Uber in places as far apart as South Africa and France. Regular taxis are often almost a part of the public sector, given the control that the government has in many aspects of its business, including determination of fares.
With such a growth in a certain sector of the private transport business, one might wonder about the state of public transport in the cities of India. A very intensive study called the “Future of Urban Mobility 2.0,” covering 84 large cities world-wide, has come with up a ranking of these cities.
It does not limit itself to hegemonic notions of “advancement,” but also takes into account crucial things like “share of trips made in public transport, smart card penetration, road density, frequency of public transport, and initiatives taken in the public sector.”
Mumbai, coming second in India, is actually slightly better than Washington DC, with Chennai being better than Los Angeles. Delhi scored very poorly -- the fifth worst among the 84 cities. Kolkata scored the best, ranked at 31, making it better than New York, Montreal, Toronto, and Sydney. It is also the city with the lowest rate of private care ownership among major cities of India.
Incidentally, when we come to Bangladesh, Dhaka did better than Los Angeles, Osaka, and Bangalore and, crucially, did better than Kuala Lampur and Bangkok, long held by certain Bangladeshi politicians as models to aspire to. Hong Kong was ranked best among the 84. However counter-intuitive, it is not a coincidence that the two Indian cities best ranked in public transport are also the top cities when it comes to giving a record boost to a certain kind of private transport service expansion.
Significant sections of Indian cities have always been divided cities -- divided by class, caste, and various other parameters. A relatively elite class who are not rich enough to always move around in their own cars everywhere but belonging to a costly, “trendy” lifestyle, often, once, would have to submit to public transport. There, they would have to sit, smell, and get pushed around with a class of people they would otherwise, never associate with.
Instant-hire app-based cars provide a separation from the public, in a real sense of space -- they do not travel inside the same vehicle. Secondly, it also separates them from the public in time -- due to a 24-hour-service, they can fashion their lifestyles around hours when public transport is thin. The regular users of anytime-anywhere-car classes form a very small sliver of the population -- Uber or Ola caters perfectly to a particular psycho-social “need” for such separations in space and time.
But their influence on public discourse on every issue, unfortunately, is disproportionately high. It is due to this skewed and lop-sided nature of influence that a question as important as women’s safety in public spaces can be hijacked and reduced to merely banning Uber, and checking the background of its drivers.
A staggering majority of brown women in urban public spaces have nothing to do with private transport, owned or paid, whatsoever. Whenever influential sections of public discourse formation log out of certain public services, the maintenance of those services go down. The government then re-allocates some of the resources from more democratic public services to those kinds of services that will disproportionately benefit the creamy layer.
The deterioration of better-in-the-past institutions like government hospitals and government schools are a living testament of this, and it cannot be unrelated to the creation and expansion of alternative institutions to provide quality healthcare and education to the elite.
Considered along with the government’s aggressive promotion of private car-owning through subsidies, one wonders what implications does the spectacular rise of Uber and Ola have for the chaotic but generally efficient urban public transport services. More crucially, what are the implications of having a government-priority influencing class that aspires to physically separate from the greater public?