One of the essential criteria of a democratic government is that it is formed with the popular mandate of the people, expressed through a general election. Hence, the importance of a general election -- the first step on the road to democracy.
The type of democracy may vary from parliamentary to presidential, but the essential features of an election are immutable. While the election must not be above public scrutiny at any time, it must be conducted through secret ballots and without hindrance.
Most importantly, the election must be credible and, to this end, it has to be ensured that the entire election process has been transparent, free, fair, and participatory. And it is for the Election Commission (EC) which is the arbiter, to decide and ensure that the election held is credible. In democracies, the EC is the most powerful independent state institution, there to ensure that the parliament truly and genuinely reflects the democratic aspirations of the people.
Now, let us talk about the state of our democracy, and more pointedly, about the January 5 parliamentary elections held in 2014 through which the present AL government came to power, and which is determined to hold on to power for a full five-year term. Can we say by any stretch of the imagination that the election was free, fair, and credible, as envisaged in a democracy?
The election was boycotted not only by the BNP, one of our two mainstream political parties, but also by all other opposition parties on the ground that in the absence of a non-party caretaker government and, more precisely, under the ruling AL government which had politicised the state institutions, including the police, the bureaucracy, and the EC, no free, fair and credible election was possible.
The contention of the BNP and all other opposition parties was borne out of the fact that in the January 5 elections, in as many as 153 constituencies in a 300-seat parliament, voters could not exercise their democratic right of electing their representatives. That is because in each of these constituencies, there was only one candidate put up by the AL-ruling alliance, and the EC had already declared them elected unopposed.
In the remaining 146 constituencies also, there was not much of a choice for the voters because it was a ruling party affair, involving, as it invariably did, an AL candidate pitted against either a rebel AL candidate or an alliance party candidate or candidates.
Besides, voter turnout was poor, hovering around 10% or so. One polling officer of a polling centre was seen getting a haircut, courtesy of a private TV channel transmission, because he had nothing else to do.
This deeply flawed general election of January 5 has given us a parliament not only with impaired legitimacy, but practically a one-party rule. The JP, the so-called opposition party in the parliament, is very much a coalition partner of the government, with its chairman HM Ershad being a special emissary of the prime minister, with the rank and status and perks and privileges of a cabinet minister, and another three of its MPs being members of the cabinet as well.
Such elections are unheard of anywhere else. Holding such an election was not only a futile exercise but a colossal waste of money for a developing country like ours. In a democracy, someone has to be held accountable.
Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has defended holding the January 5 election on the grounds of constitutional necessity. But the president using his authority could have very well deferred holding the election until an amicable settlement was reached between the government and the opposition.
After all, nothing is more supreme than the interest of the state and the well-being of the people.
Does not the constitution demand that the election be credible and reflective of the wishes and democratic aspirations of the people?
Holding a one-party election and denying more than half the voters of the country their democratic rights of exercising their franchise run counter, not only to fundamental norms of democracy, but also to the spirit of the constitution our ministers and lawmakers are oath-bound to protect.
Now, what will happen when this government completes its five-year term in 2019?
If the government does not agree to step down and opt for a neutral care-taker dispensation to oversee the next parliamentary election as is being demanded now by Begum Khaleda Zia, it may pave the way for a repeat of the previous election, and the continued AL rule for yet another term, and yet another term fitting into the oft-repeated wish of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina to preside over the celebration of Bangladesh graduating to mid-income status and, finally, to developed country status.
And should this happen, it may as well be a new “standard” for democracy for Bangladesh.