Though the crisis emerged out of the North American meltdown and the PIIGS crisis in Europe, it is Greece that has been in the headlines for the last month or so. Most are, by now, aware that the debt/GDP ratio of the Greek government has risen too high. While the size of their GDP is about $238bn, their government debt has risen to almost $320bn, ie 180% of their GDP.
There is a saying: Don’t borrow beyond your means. In the banks, we were taught how net cash generation in the borrowing entity must be higher than its financial obligations. Some analysts feel that Greek authorities might have not done enough to manage its escalating debt.
Certainly, the Hellenic Republic came into the debt crisis with hemorrhaging budget deficits, and they could have done more over the past few years to prevent that debt rise. However, the fiscal adjustment that the government has undertaken over the past five years is nothing short of being tantamount to swallowing many bullets.
The revenue increases and spending cuts that the Greek government has enacted over the past five years have led to a correction in the cyclically-adjusted budget balance worth almost 20% of the nation’s GDP.
Questions may arise if the Greek government has done a good job in reducing its budget deficit -- if so, why then has the country’s debt/GDP ratio escalated by 80% since 2007? As a Wells Fargo report shows, between 2008 and 2011, the Greek government debt rose about 40%.
Although Greece was undergoing some serious fiscal adjustments during those years, it was still facing sizeable budget deficits, and these deficits added to the outstanding debt amount.
Debt fell sharply in early 2012, when private investors were forced to accept a debt restructuring that included cuts in excess of 50% of the face value of the bonds they held. Government debt rebounded a bit over the next few quarters, but outstanding debt balance has remained more or less unchanged in recent years.
The real GDP of Greece is currently down by 27%, from its Q2-2007 peak. It will probably fall further in the near term due to the freezing of commerce that has occurred with banks being closed over the past three weeks. As history shows, the real GDP in USA plunged 26% between 1929 and 1933.
However, positive economic growth resumed in 1934, and by 1936, the level of the US’s real GDP had reclaimed its 1929 peak. Greece has endured a US-like depression, but after eight years, the economy has not even begun to recover.
Rather, the significant fiscal consolidation that the government has undertaken over the past five years has reportedly pushed the economy deeper into a hole. It is likely to be years, if not decades, for the real GDP in Greece to reach its peak.
The country recently reached a conditional agreement with its lenders for a third bailout that could total more than 80bn euros. IMF recently raised eyebrows when it announced that Greece’s debt dynamics were not sustainable, and that Greece’s debt can now only be made sustainable through debt relief measures that go far beyond what Europe is ready for.
If the Greek government makes stringent fiscal choices, it will achieve a primary budget surplus of 4% of its GDP in 2019, and with a fasten-your-seat-belt 4.5% in each year in the next decade, the government debt/GDP ratio will recede to less than 100% in 2030.
However, the IMF tells us that a few countries have managed to maintain primary budget surpluses of 3.5% of its GDP for decades. If the primary budget surplus slips back to 1.5% of the GDP in the next decade, then the debt/GDP ratio will go much higher.
Widening budget deficits in the immediate aftermath of the global recession contributed to the increase in the Greek government debt in those years. However, Greece has undertaken an extraordinary amount of fiscal consolidation since 2009, and the level of Greece’s government debt has remained more or less unchanged over the past two years. The increase in the debt/GDP ratio over the past few years, therefore, reflects the continued slump in the country’s nominal GDP.
The activities which are required to bring about a sharp reduction in the country’s debt/GDP ratio in the coming years sound too optimistic. The government would need to undertake further fiscal consolidation and maintain austere budgets into the next decade.
Additionally, the country would need to experience strong economic growth. A recession or inability to maintain austere budgets would slow down, if not completely arrest, the decline in the debt/GDP ratio, which could then raise renewed concerns about the sustainability of the country’s debt, or possibly even the country itself.
The Greece government and its lenders may reach an agreement in the coming weeks for a third bailout package, and market attention with Greece may then dampen. However, unless Greece enjoys the benefits of low borrowing costs, austere budgets, and strong economic growth on a sustained basis, concerns about the country’s debt sustainability will continue, or even increase.
The lenders, who hold the majority of its debt, may eventually need to take large cuts on their holdings. Otherwise, it will be true that “we learn from history that we learn nothing from history.”