It has been a long time in the making.
When Gore Vidal’s The City and the Pillar came out in 1948, the book was thrashed for portraying a homosexual character in a positive light. Back in those days, homosexuality was still considered decadent and would face legal consequences. Gore Vidal was blacklisted, banned from literary circles, and no newspaper would review his books for six years.
It was not until another 10 years that the Supreme Court of the US (SCOTUS), in a landmark judgment, would find homosexual publications not automatically obscene and thus protected by the constitution. This was thanks to litigation by the notorious gay magazine One, published by Mattachine Society, one of the earliest gay rights organisations.
This verdict was probably the first major legal victory for the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) persons who began to come out in droves in the 60s, when the Stonewall Riots propelled the movement to a new height.
And then it took 57 years (and millions of brave souls) from the first SCOTUS ruling for the nation to celebrate marriage equality last Friday. The US now joins the league of 18 other nations where same-sex couples can enjoy mainstream married life -- a house, a dog, and a mortgage -- just like their heterosexual counterparts. After all, why should only the heterosexuals taste “Delhi ka Laddu”?
On a serious note, this verdict now means that millions of LGBT persons in the US are no longer second-class citizens; they are equal before the law, can enjoy the same federal and state benefits, and can form a family with the person they love. It boggles the mind as to why any state would deny such a union of two committed souls on any ground, and why it hadn’t been done already.
Apart from the “nature vs nurture” debate around the cause of homosexuality, one of the primary arguments of the opponents of same-sex union is the traditional definition of marriage being only between a man and a woman. But traditions, which are very culture and time-specific, cannot be grounds for discrimination towards any citizen whose rights are enshrined in the constitution.
A society, which perpetuates discrimination and violence in the name of tradition, is a society in need of reformation, needless to say.
Another argument that rocks the opponent’s boat is the procreation aspect of marriage. But has there been example of any state denying or revoking the marriage right of any heterosexual couple that could not procreate? No. Besides, in this time and era, couples, both hetero and homo, married or not, can procreate by artificial insemination, surrogacy, and adoption.
For a significant faction of the movement, marriage equality means no real change as long as racial profiling, gender-based discrimination, and inequality in housing, education, and health exist. While great strides have been made in terms of lesbian and gay rights, the issues faced by the disenfranchised transgender and intersex community are all too ignored. The LGBT movement, which started to ensure social justice and equity, cannot be complacent now and must forge ahead to win the remaining battles.
Having said that, what does the SCOTUS ruling mean for Bangladesh, a Muslim-majority country where the LGBT movement is just beginning to gather momentum? Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook might have the answer.
Soon after the verdict, Facebook unveiled a new feature to celebrate and support the verdict by superimposing one’s profile photo with pride colours. In just a couple of hours, the feature swept across the globe and rainbowified profile photos became the in thing to do. With hashtags, status updates, photos, and tweets, the Facebook newsfeed itself became a pride parade.
Though the verdict has no direct impact on the lives of Bangladeshis, we soon joined the bandwagon either to express our solidarity or just to try out the cool new feature. Whatever the reasons might be, the profile photo frenzy surely created avenues for debate on the subject like never before -- from outright denunciation to virtual hugs. The debates were so intense that it caused friendships to fall apart, some hearts to break, and, at the same time, some new relationships to form.
While it may have been a bit too dramatic for us to go berserk over a third country’s decision (but then it’s in our character), the issue surely touched some nerves and exposed not only our bigotry but also our inherent ability to accept something new. And this is what matters.
And this is where America matters because whatever they do, it has a ripple affect across the world. We can condemn the country for its controversial foreign policy, but at home it has managed to take care of its own people and stay on the right side of history. It also generates hope for millions of LGBT people across the world that change, though it may take time, is possible.
As for the nascent LGBT movement in Bangladesh, marriage equality is not on the cards. Right now, all that matters for us is to ensure that we are not marginalised, abused, violated, discriminated against, and murdered in the name of religion and tradition. For us, the fight is as basic as survival and hoping to live at least a safe, dignified life.
For now we revel in a changing world and look up to those who rainbowified their profile photos to stand by us when the time comes. Otherwise, this Facebook feature will be nothing more than just a fading trend.
Here’s hoping that it will not be far too long for us to also say “love has won.”