There has been a noticeable amount of hullabaloo over a TV advert showing an elderly government employee, who has been honest all his life, refusing to budge from his principles when his daughter asks for a fancy mobile phone as an Eid gift.
Unable to buy the gadget with his income, the man is offered a bribe in exchange for his signature on a paper, and while he is about to relent and take the money to meet the daughter’s demand, his morals prevail.
Coming back home, he asks forgiveness from his daughter, who, in tears, replies, in a choked voice, that life won’t end without a phone. The advert ends with the pronouncement: “We are in search of such honest men.”
The stab at the heart is sharp, the advert’s objective is met -- human emotion is stirred. As an advert, this is a success because even the most cynical of us would possibly feel a wave of virtue, though for some, this shiver of righteousness may be transient.
For some odd reason, this advert got me thinking, leading me to go beyond the small sequence. Hypothetically speaking, the father, due to his strict moral values, could not accept something underhanded, and the daughter understood his position. But how will this man bear the expenses of her marriage when the time comes?
Here, we need to go beyond the simple issue of buying a trendy phone to touch on the matter of honesty, as we are led to believe. Does being honest mean a person has to be financially hard-up all the time, strangulating material desires of his/her family members?
Sorry if I sound cynical, but we have been witnessing a campaign centring honesty for some time now -- in search of honest people, or shoth manusher khoje, with the interesting thing being that, in almost all cases, past and present, the adverts seeking such people inevitably portray someone who is struggling or making ends meet with difficulty.
So, the message here is clear -- honest people are materially unsuccessful whereas those who are comfortable in life are almost always a little crooked in some way.
Now let’s place the situation of the phone advert against other, rather relentless popular culture representations of the honest man. From the 70s, movies, theatres, and dramas in Bangladesh have given us the template of the principled man with the line … uni bhalo manush chilen, jibone kichu korte paren nai (he was a good bloke and therefore could not achieve anything in the material sense).
Again, the word “bhalo manush” has been used interchangeably with “shorol shadashida manush,” which translates to “straightforward simple man.”
I am sorry to say, in most cases, such people have been seen with pity and never with pride. The bhalo manush actually means the foolish man who was duped, deceived by all, but never harmed anyone else, hence remained a pauper in the end.
My question is: Can’t someone be successful in the material sense without compromising their principles? Once again, let’s take the case of the government employee as shown in the phone advert, placing him against countless other honest people in reality who are straight but also smart.
The core basis of moral values is that one should not accept anything which contravenes an established set of laws. Fine, we have countless people who, after their office work, either run a small business or provide part-time evening services just for a supplementary income.
The best example comes from journalists who, as far as I know, have been, for the longest period of time, the most lowly-paid professionals. In the 80s, the standard unflattering image of a journalist was a scruffily dressed man in a rusty 50cc bike.
I know this for a fact, no landlord wanted to rent-out a flat to a reporter on the belief that they never got paid regularly. In the list of preferred grooms, the journalist always came at the bottom.
The modern-day journalist is a far cry from that rather hope-deflating picture, he or she has one full-time job, engaging in a variety of other consultancy work, from teaching to giving lectures, to working as communications experts.
The same theory applies for teachers, government employees, and hordes of other people for whom one job can’t provide enough for a better living.
I see many modern-day journalists leading well-off lives equal to that of corporate professionals with an added bonus -- the freedom to do things their way.
I would not call all this moonlighting wrong, simply term it a smart approach to life. Honesty does not mean one has to adopt a rigid stance, diving headstrong into privations. Sorry again, such a blinkered outlook would only produce failed people.
The fact is, in a consumerism-driven society, life cannot be defined by an unbending definition. Also, lest we forget, the bhalo manush in the traditional sense never meant a wise one.
Perhaps it’s time to make some amendments to the honest man tag. That man who could not get his daughter a phone is hardly someone society would respect/lionise in reality. Celluloid romanticism has always glorified absurd notions of moral rectitude without ever equating it against a practical situation.
So, after much thought, I came to the conclusion that the advert wanted to celebrate not just integrity, but honesty laced with impractical sense, or, in clear language, an honest man who is foolish.
Such portrayal of storybook honesty will do us more harm than good. Maybe people should be asked to be clean but also clever. As the Indian sage Chanakya said: “A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first and honest people are screwed first.”