On the heels of the human trafficking and Rohingya exodus becoming big items in the Bay of Bengal basin, it is not surprising that a more nuanced eye has been turned to the different kind of migration that has taken plenty of largely educated men and women to the shores of Europe and North America.
Unlike the temporary migrants in the Middle East or the trafficked ones in South East Asia, the diaspora in the First World contains both the economic type immigrants and those who went there for something more than a merely bigger paycheck. It is this kind of, shall we say, “white collar” émigré that has come for some harsh treatment in more than a few media outlets, including a very poignant piece in another major English daily which presented five stories of such individuals who, once settled abroad, seemed to have forgotten their roots and obligations thereto.
That is a fair concern and rests on sound ethical ground. Where the narrative goes wobbly is the unsaid but strongly suggested premise that somehow those of us of the diaspora on these shores are living a life of luxury to the last man and woman. Undoubtedly, some of these absurd assumptions are results of tall tales that become taller each time they are relayed to the point that the cabbie in New York becomes known as the “CEO of a Manhattan-based transportation business.”
Sure, a few individuals do make it big, just like they would in Bangladesh; but for a vast majority of white collar non-resident Bangladeshis in Europe and North America, the luxurious lifestyle of Beverly Hills mansions and French Riviera vacations that the aforementioned article alluded to, are simply features that are seen on television reality shows.
Why? Because, for starters, your earnings are taxed at a progressive rate, be they from business or salaried jobs, and there is far less scope to get out of paying taxes unlike in many developing countries. As a modestly compensated civil servant with technical expertise, on paper my compensation looks pretty good … until the taxes are accounted for: By my rough calculation, by the time the plethora of income taxes, social security taxes, sales taxes, and property taxes have been paid, my salary is halved! Heck, I even have to pay an annual city tax for keeping my dog!
To the taxman’s generous cut, add the fact that beyond the mansions of the truly multimillionaire types, regular household help is largely unheard of here. So, the most menial tasks that are often relegated to domestic help in middle class homes in Bangladesh end up on the chore list of doctors, teachers, and accountants every week … sweeping, dusting, cleaning toilet bowls, cutting the grass, clearing cobwebs, and so on.
For families with children, any semblance of luxury for the professionally employed diaspora is almost a joke as two parents juggle regular jobs with the task of raising children bicultural in a competitive environment, often without the help of the network of family and relatives that would have been available in the old country. Almost all private sector employers in the United States operate in a legal context of “at will” employment whereas termination without cause is very much a possibility in bad economic times … thus adding further to the decidedly non-luxurious stress.
None of that is to say that too many people regret the choice of making these shores their home. For some of us, the unorthodoxy of our articulated and documented opinions on sensitive issues makes the risk of physical danger a real deterrent from venturing out in lands where the rule of law is shaky at best. Even with the drawbacks of a rather demanding routine in a modern country, we prefer living in a society where our religious views don’t get us killed, our desire to delve deep into historical facts does not get us held in contempt of court, and satire about political leaders does not get us arrested.
Many others leave near and dear ones and struggle so that even in a very uncertain economic and political climate, they know that their merit and ability matter more than the family connections and calls from ruling party legislators to company management.
Some simply want a life which, while hardly luxurious, has a basic minimum of peace and tranquility that simply cannot be found in an environment where political pluralism, tolerance, and the rule of law have ceased to exist.
Fundamentally, the professionals who come to North America and Europe come for an opportunity to live in peace and relative freedom rather than for a guarantee of anything approaching luxury. Some get the opportunity, some don’t. A handful few do make it big into lives of enviable luxury.
Not all of us are rich. In fact, most of us live very modest lives with simply a different set of challenges than our peers in Bangladesh.