That India’s competitively-elected parliament finally approved the constitutional amendment to make the Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) with Bangladesh a reality is indeed something to be praised.
While I have not reviewed the most recent version of the LBA and am not unaware of the judicial pitfalls which still lurk before its implementation, it is a step in the right direction by South Asia’s giant. Unless, of course, you ask the instinctive Indiaphobes who, along with the pathological Pakistan-bashers, form a very real part of the chattering classes in Bangladesh.
Come to think of it, those obsessed with India-centric or Pakistan-centric conspiracy theories can be found in just about every corner of middle-class and upper-middle class Bangladeshi society. Hence, it is hardly a surprise that one of the first themes of reaction from the Indiaphobes in this instance was along the lines of “see, see, I told you, the Awami League is India’s agent and wants to make Bangladesh into India by giving everything away.” I wish.
Please take a deep breath and hold off tarring and feathering me as some kind of RAW agent or an apologist for the ruling regime. Au contraire, I am the grandson of men and women who left it all in 1947 in what became the Republic of India, and never looked back. The “I wish” is a tongue-in-cheek comment.
But truth be told, from a cold and evidentiary perspective, there is indeed a whole lot that Bangladesh could have emulated in terms of governance from a neighbour that has defied two long-held hypotheses in the theory of democratic consolidation.
The first such hypothesis, drilled into the heads of political science students in graduate school in any respectable North American university, is that countries where a majority of the population lives under the poverty line are unlikely to have their democracies take root; the second hypothesis, obviously favoured by today’s rulers in Dhaka for very transparent reasons, is that economic progress has to happen before there can be a pluralist democracy.
India stands as a proud counterpoint to both these otherwise reputable -- if not exclusive -- claims of scholarship. Barring the aberration of the 21-month Emergency period in the mid-1970s, India has continued as a vibrant pluralist, multi-party, representative democracy from her first moments of Independence in the August of 1947.
This phenomenon has been helped by a thoroughly professional civil service, a fiercely independent and activist judiciary which has not backed down from jailing sitting ministers, and agency heads, and an Election Commission which performs miracles by holding the world’s largest electoral exercise every five years with a transparency and fairness that is breathtaking.
None of this is to suggest that India’s rowdy, noisy, and often ugly democracy is perfect; far from it. Indians have probably only a little more respect for their politicians than Bangladeshis have for theirs.
But Indians can and do take rightful pride in knowing that they are governed with the consent given freely at the ballot box in a process guarded jealously by a highly respected Election Commission which has no compunction punishing anyone and everyone summarily when found tampering with the conduct of elections.
And should those who govern them not be proper guardians of their liberties, Indians do have access to a higher judiciary which is not only actually independent but actively involved in ensuring that the rule of law holds everyone accountable, be it the common man, ministers, or so called “student wings” of any incumbent ruling party.
Joining the independent judiciary is a plethora of truly autonomous and effective organisations like the Human Rights Commission, the Central Bureau of Investigation, and the University Grants Commission, all of which work entirely independently of what this or that minister pronounces on a given day.
And look where this faith in strong institutions, pluralist democracy, and independent judiciary has gotten India: An economy where the confidence of investors and the creativity of entrepreneurs has created a foundation upon which a giant is set to enter the exclusive OECD club of major democratic economies very soon.
Even with the glaring income inequality and large pockets of almost medieval backwardness, India lifts up more people from poverty to respectability each year than the entire population of some countries.
When I think of India, I look at a country whose cultural and linguistic heritage is not too dissimilar to Bangladesh, but whose governance has consolidated, albeit imperfectly, all the things we wished we had in Bangladesh: Strong autonomous institutions, fair elections, multi-party democracy, independent judiciary, and a free press.
If anyone wants to make Bangladesh more like India in that sense, I say all the power to them.