The grass is hardly greener

With the contorted faces of illegal boat people trying to end up in a better country to work plastered all over the newspapers, the complex issue of the “foreign bug” comes to the fore once more. Many of the people stranded at sea in the flimsy boats with little or no shade, have opted to dare this highly risky voyage to end up in a country where they can either claim refugee status or simply disappear, adding to the millions of unregistered labourers.

In most cases, the goal is straightforward: Work in a different country and earn a living. But these boat journeys are not hastily assembled operations -- on the contrary, they are part of illegal migrant trafficking which demands that each passenger in a boat pay a hefty amount.

In recent weeks, we have seen several newspaper reports elaborating precise locations in Teknaf, from where countless people, caught by the foreign bug, have headed for the sea in rickety vessels, based on vague promises by unscrupulous traffickers.

The trend is never-ending. What is surprising is that, despite mounting tales of woe and suffering, the allure of plenty on a far-off land never fails to win over gullible minds. In certain cases, we hear that Tk3-4 lakh have been exchanged just for a passage to a different state, with no certainty about possible work once the voyage ends safely.

To give a realistic picture -- many trips end with death at sea; some often make it to shore but people landing illegally either end up in jail or are sent back.

The truth remains, suffering linked to foreign travel for employment is not a new phenomenon; it dates back to the late 70s when the Middle-East-oil-boom-triggered economic development required workers from developing countries by thousands.

While most people who worked in the Gulf states in the 70s will say unanimously that it was the golden period of overseas employment, it would be wise to recall the proliferation of “Hai Hai Companies” even at that period, swindling many with false promises of the desert dream.

Just for clarification, the term “hai hai” roughly translates to “all is lost.”

In the 80s, the hai hai was replaced by the term “adom,” literally meaning man, but again, this was used pejoratively to hint at dodgy manpower exporting organisations.

Adoms never disappeared; they only transformed their modus operandi. Today, countless such foreign manpower exporters operate individually without an office, using only their power to convince. And trust me, persuading someone of a better life abroad is possibly the easiest task.

As some target working-class people, others have well-furnished offices, creating the hallucination of the immigrant status where dollars flow because life is filled with roses and honey.

The reason why traffickers and illegal human exporters thrive is because, deep down in us, and that includes people from all classes, a desire persists, which believes there is something far better waiting for us.

By the laws of nature, from every 1,000 people who go abroad, one will obviously, through luck, make it big, and this case is held up as the example.

In rural Bangladesh, in every little village, there is such a miracle story -- one Ramizuddin or Khairullah who is now a foreign citizen, earning good money, owning land and property back in Bangladesh.

This one success overshadows all failures. Therefore, once the foreign bug is in, there is no way to end the dreaming.

A few months ago, a known person came to me asking for advice about sending his brother to France by a visa obtained by a so-called Europe returnee who purportedly owned an IT café in Paris.

Not too many read newspapers nowadays and the mere mention of Europe for them conjures up images of abundant wealth and luxury. Very few know and understand what recession actually means.

Dare I say, almost all of Europe is in a sluggish state, with France not doing too well either. In such a condition, how could a Bangladeshi manage to hire a fellow from his country to work in Paris? I asked the man this, telling him to disassociate from this venture.

He listened intently, nodding to every word I said deferentially but went and paid the money anyway. The man from Paris disappeared without a trace, which in a way was good for the victim because he did not have to endure a tortuous boat ride or deportation from a foreign airport.

It’s indeed heart-wrenching to see helpless young men sobbing on the phone while talking to relatives back home.

However, some rational forethought is needed before embarking on a journey for the unknown.

If someone can pay Tk3-5 lakh to catch a dream which is just make-belief, then why not spend that money to set up a small shop or business here in the country?

The return may be small, but one thing is certain -- death from starvation on the sea, in a cramped prison, or in an impenetrable slave camp will always remain distant.

While Bangladesh has sent workers abroad since the mid-70s, with many coming home with a secured future, it’s prudent to keep in mind that, with the economies in many developed nations in shambles, anti-immigration sentiments are rising, making situations dire for newly-arrived foreigners.

Know the facts first before going, understand what economic downturn means. Most importantly, stop clasping onto the common saying: Ekbar gele kichu ekta paoa jaibo (once you are there, some opportunity will eventually arrive).