The recently concluded Dhaka North mayoral election was a disappointment for those who had been hoping to see the rise of non-AL and BNP candidates.
Dhaka South and Chittagong were two-horse races, but Dhaka North had a number of interesting third-party options, most notably Zonayed Saki, Mahi B Chowdhury, and Abdullah al-Kafi.
As it happened, Mahi did not cross 15,000 votes, Saki did not cross 10,000, and Kafi did not cross 5,000 votes. In fact, all small party candidates combined barely scraped together 50,000 votes compared to the 325,000 recorded by the BNP-backed Tabith Awal and the 460,000 bagged by AL-backed Annisul Huq.
Now, one should not read too much into the numbers, and certainly the fact that BNP as well as Saki withdrew from the race in the early afternoon on voting day, together with the irregularities that marred the process, combined to deliver a result that tells us less than we would have hoped.
However, any way you slice it, it wasn’t a good outing for third-party candidates.
So why did the small party candidates do so badly? Is it conclusive evidence of the enduring popularity of the AL and the BNP? Is the take-away that these two parties retain an iron grip on the affections of the Bangladeshi voter and that there is no room in the political firmament for anyone else?
By no means.
What we saw in the DNCC mayoral election was nothing more than the realpolitik of the Bangladeshi electoral system writ large.
Bangladeshi voters are nothing if not shrewd and calculating. They understand the rules of the game and how the game is played.
In the first instance, they understand how difficult it would be for a small party candidate to deliver if he or she were to win. Navigating the mire of city politics would be challenging for anyone, but for someone without major party backing to be able to operate effectively through all the intricacies of ward-level politics would be a tough ask.
In the second, they understand that there are advantages to ending up on the winning side. Many Bangladeshi voters vote for the party they believe will win, not the one they think ought to win or would like to see win, because they know that when the dust settles that the winning party will remember which localities turned out for it and which localities did not.
The spoils of governance will be apportioned accordingly, and wards which return a high proportion of votes for the winning side can expect far better service delivery than those that choose the wrong side. Too many votes for the wrong side, and we have seen this time and again in the aftermath of elections in Bangladesh, and the retribution sought will be physical as well as material.
Most crucially, despite everything, the advantages that supporting a major party offers at the polls still outweigh the promise of something fresh and new.
The real problem third-party candidates face is that our first-past-the-post electoral system loads the dice heavily against them, making it extremely difficult for even an excellent third-party candidate to get traction at the polls.
It could be that many voters would have preferred to vote for one of the smaller candidates but calculated that it was best to vote for either AL or BNP as these were the only two that had a realistic chance of winning.
If you really wanted to stop AL, then a vote for BNP remained your best bet. And if you really wanted to ensure that BNP did not come to power, then you had no choice but to vote for AL. This is how it has always been in Bangladeshi politics.
In short, the failure of the third-party candidates does not tell us that there is no market or appetite for them and their wares, only that under the current electoral system, that they will always remain shut out.
This is true of third-party candidates the world over, and not just in Bangladesh.
But the take-away from this should not be that third-party candidates are failures or cannot deliver, but that if we want a more participatory democracy, with more voices being heard, and giving the voters the chance to empower someone other than the big two, that our current electoral system is not equal to the task.
The disappointing showing of third-party candidates in the DNCC elections suggests more about the failings of our electoral system than it suggests about the candidates’ inability to connect with voters.
If the big parties really feel that third-party candidates cannot and do not connect with voters, they should be happy to put that theory to the test.
But until and unless that happens, a poor showing at the polls tells us very little about what voters think about such candidates or whether they would vote for them if they felt they could vote their conscience and their preference.