If it is the case that voters, as consumers, need the personal identification of brand values and benefits, rather than simple, traditional “brand loyalty,” to stimulate “purchase” by voting, this election may well mark the end of government by deeply held beliefs and commitments.
The lack of maintenance of the brand values that so inspired traditional loyalties, together with a growing plethora of competitors, appears to have alienated all but the most diehard loyalists; many of whom appear to more need their loyalty, than to actually believe in it.
The traditional “noblesse oblige,” of conservatism, accepting the responsibilities for the “under classes,” as the quid pro quo for the rights they enjoy, that matched the reforming, caring fervour of socialism, appear to have both been disavowed by younger, professional politicians apparently unaware, or careless, of the vital importance of that brand loyalty that was built of traditional values.
Blair, of course, with New Labour, undertook a brilliant relaunch that seemed set to have garnered most, if not all, of the loyalty of traditionalists in the cause, only to over reach, and alienate the new generation as well as dubious traditional loyalists. The charisma of personality, for a time, seemed to reassure such doubters.
The Conservatives seem to have slowly emphasised selfishness and greed as an acceptable tradition; however, a degree of distaste appears to hover at its fringes amongst many of the loyalists.
The new brands, based on historic nationalism, or such new ideas as environmental concerns, obviously have an appeal to voters alienated from traditional loyalties, or younger people looking for something new, more modern, to believe in.
And, equally, where leaders of substance and status traditionally led the older brands, they have been replaced by a somewhat more anodyne generation of personality embodiment of the great causes they seek, and claim, to represent.
The “MBA” generation of self-made graduates with plenty of book learning, but limited real world experience, lacking real personality, despite the contrivance of publicists. This, of course, mirrors such leadership in both public and private sector organisations; from corporations such as the once giants, Unilever and BP, through publicly-financed behemoths from the UN itself, to major INGOs.
Under these circumstances, uncertainty and disaffection, allied with perceptions of narrow self-interest and short-term loyalties, have changed the political game. Not, perhaps, in quite the same obviously disastrous way in which it has evidently changed in the USA, where it seems that hugely well-financed, often freaky non-entities are now readily elected to office in a completely dysfunctional Congress, but possibly even heading to that latter outcome in UK.
The polls are unmoving, but it seems reasonable to recall that when Thatcher won her lengthy term of office in 1979, even the exit polls got it wrong. Subsequent research suggested that voters were embarrassed to admit to voting for her.
Perhaps they are also keeping their counsel this time around. Or perhaps, as many commentators suggest, on the whole they find the options so unpalatable that they are resisting deciding anything.
Added to the uncertainty are the revelations that a new computerised voter registration system may have excluded millions of voters from the list of those entitled to vote; and conspiracy theorists will find grist to their suspicions if, like me, they find half the family voters left off the list, despite their having received letters assuring them they had been included.
On double-checking, they were not on the register; could their voting-record be known, and their exclusion deliberate? There are nations where such suspicions could well be justified, but surely not in the UK! Surely?
So, the unmoving polls lend credence to the prospect that one-party governance is a thing of the past. We are looking at some, potentially unholy coalitions in prospect. The Conservatives propped up by the United Kingdom Independence Party is surely very unappealing, even to, at least, more liberal Tories.
And the Labour Party, with the Scottish National Party stalking it, is equally unappealing, at least, even in Scotland itself, to the Unionist majority.
To some, the prospect of a Liberal Democrat Party in coalition with the Conservatives seems so last year as to be implausible, especially in the light of the abuse Cameron and Clegg and their associates are heaping on each other as their erstwhile coalition partners. Been there, done that, and, perhaps it worked, as Clegg consistently claims, as having ameliorated the worst excesses the Conservatives would otherwise have inflicted on the nation. Nevertheless, it seems unbelievable that no one would try to make a change.
So, with half the official four-week campaign passed, if the traditional half-time refreshment was being handed around to the players, the pieces of fresh orange must taste pretty sour. Goalless at the break, and no sign of any of the many attacks mounted from all sides having any real or noticeable effect.
All of which, of course, only matters to the rest of the world, including Bangladesh, insofar as it seems to mark another stage in the decline of a United Kingdom that has been, for at least half a millennium, a force to be reckoned with in at least half that world.
Foreign policy, in fact, has scarcely been mentioned, except in budgetary considerations. The fact that one of the few contributions that the UK might make to the world through its long tradition of the diplomacy in which the foreign office, left to its own devices, has been traditionally highly respected, has had its resources sadly diminished, seems to have occurred to nobody.
Membership of the UN Security Council seems to be taken as a right for what was once a world power; but the responsibilities that accompany such rights now seem undeliverable, diplomatically, as well as increasingly militarily. Whilst a 10% cut in the overseas aid budget might well double the budget for diplomatic activity, this may be regarded as another failure to appreciate the real, potential strengths of the diminishing UK.
The evident contradiction at the heart of the Conservative campaign, in which Cameron strongly stated belief during the Scottish independence referendum last September: “The Union is a thousand times more important to me than the question of membership of the European Union,” seems to grow, almost by the day. Both Cameron, and former prime minister, Sir John Major, are becoming ever more strident in their demonisation of the Scottish National Party.
Not a position designed to secure maintenance of the Union after the election, whoever wins; and failing to answer the question of how Cameron, if he is returned to office and carries out his promise of an “in or out” referendum on UK’s membership of EU, which produces a majority vote to exit, amongst English voters only, whilst Scottish, Welsh, and Northern Irish voters opt to remain within, can possibly hope to hold the Union together.
Bribes, it seems, and devout expressions of fiscal responsibility made by politicians evidently lacking in credibility, have so far failed to move the voters. Politics has become, largely an open market for any politician offering short term benefits. Perhaps, if that is what the voters want, that is democracy.
But voters need, maybe, to be reminded that old, decaying brands, and fly-by-night newcomers, can neither of them offer guarantees for consumer safety; someone needs to point out that they vote at their own risk, with no one to blame but themselves for unsatisfactory, even disastrous outcomes.
Maybe the ballot paper should offer a pause for thought, such as: “Ill considered voting could severely damage your standard of living.”