Joe: Every town has a boss.
Silvanito: Yes, but when there are two around, I’d say there is one too many.
If you haven’t, see A Fistful of Dollars, starring Clint Eastwood, click on Netflix and press download. Watch a movie directed by an Italian, filmed in the deserts of cheap, Franco-era Spain, about an American gunman in a Mexican town. That classic 60s Spaghetti Western, sums up the seemingly permanent Khichuri of Deshi politics.
Let us remind ourselves of the story.
The Man with No Name, let’s call him Joe, rides into town, on the prowl for some money-making opportunities. Holing up at an inn in the main square, he asks the world-weary, sad-eyed owner, Silvanito: “Who runs this town?” The answer is simple. On one end of the square we have the Baxters Family. On the other, we have the Rojos, led by Ramon. Both families vying for control.
Joe: “Baxter’s over there, Rojos there, me right smack in the middle.”
Silvanito: “If you are thinking what I suspect, I tell you, don’t try it!”
Clint Eastwood (Joe) works it out immediately. He figures that the feud can be leveraged, by him in the middle choosing one family and then promiscuously heading off with a loaded gun over to their enemy. Playing one off against each other.
Joe: “You shoot to kill, you better hit the heart ... which of the two is stronger?”
Silvanito: “Which of them is stronger? Well ... the Rojos. Especially Ramon.”
The incumbent regime, with all the organs of state power at its disposal, has to be the favourite to come out on top. In this battle of attrition, it seems single-minded in wiping out the Baxters. In the story, the Baxters are decimated. The Rojo family wins.
If one were a betting person, one would conclude that a family which has to outsource political activism to petrol-bomb throwing desperadoes, doesn’t look like winning this war. Already ideologically hollowed-out, they are hanging on by their fingernails.
For the moment, we are merely impatient observers. We are all #JesuisSilvanito, the innkeeper in this one. We have seen this film being played out on the streets of Bangladesh since 1991. Our eyes are also filled with sadness. We too long for a more fruitful future.
A bigger game
The climax of the film is, of course, the duel between Joe and Ramon. Joe tricks Ramon and then kills him and his brothers. Instead of taking over, he rides out of town.
So, the triumph of the Rojos over the Baxters did not last for long. The organisational principle of the Rojo Family, the glue that kept their followers together, was based on the destruction of the Baxter family and thus a monopoly where riches could be distributed to the favoured few.
There was no ideology pursuing the betterment of the people. The townsfolk were to work hard, provide their surplus and forget about challenging the status quo.
At the end, with both families extinguished, the Sad Eyed Innkeeper, Silvanito, asks if Joe wants to double up. Clint Eastwood considers his options: The imminent arrival of the Mexican government or the US Army.
Joe: “You mean the Mexican government on one side? Maybe the Americans on the other side? Me right smack in the middle? Uhn-hn. Too dangerous. So long.”
Silvanito: “Adios.”
You see, while these families were enacting their self-destructive, insane struggle, they had not fully appreciated the virtues of their location. The town was situated near the Rio Grande, crossing which led to the rising industrial Superpower of the day, the United States of America. Ramon’s ambition was merely to massacre a group of American soldiers and steal their guns and gold. That is what brought the attention of the Americans in the tale.
Meanwhile, the writ of the Mexican government barely functioned in the town. Had Ramon been more ambitious, less greedy, and more wise, he and his brothers might have understood that there was a world to explore, promising riches beyond their imaginations. That the town might have become a hub, a staging post with hotels, eateries, manufacturing workshops, and a thriving economy where property prices would shoot through the roof. Everyone would get rich. Alas, he could not see the bigger picture.
As the political village that is Dhaka fights it out, far Greater Powers are indeed circling the place. They sigh at the parochialism of the politicians. Like the Mexican and American governments in the film, will they conclude they have no choice but to clear up the town, all in their own self-interests, of course?
Some Economists, a few knowledgeable businesspeople and surely the Middle Class realise that much grander opportunities await Bangladesh. Which if it played its hand skilfully would transform this nation and the region.
The competing multi-billion dollar interests of India and China, the Silk Roads, the Ports, the new railways, bridges and roads, new industrial sectors and zones, millions of better paying jobs producing higher value products, climbing the technology ladder … maybe Bangladesh could figure out that … on the one hand, there is Delhi, on the other hand, there is Beijing ... or will it say: “Uhm uh. Too big for me.”
Let’s hope it’s bolder and stays for the ride.
In the world of Reality TV
In case you are wondering, in the Director’s Cut, which we naturally don’t get to see, there are media moguls, NGOs with ambitious leaders, and an out-of-his-depth ambassador cheerleading the coup. Perhaps a General saw this flick in 2006. Maybe Moeen Ahmed with his sidekick, Fakhruddin, thought he could ride into town, chomp on his cigar, and wipe out both families. Where else did he figure out his half-baked Minus Two formula?
As it turned out, he was unceremoniously turfed out with his mule. The General hadn’t done his homework. As we now know the military-NGOisation of politics in 2007 did not last long.
The Director also heard that it is unlikely to make a comeback because those ageing NGO leaders aren’t taken seriously by the people so that formula of regime change is defunct. Hence, it’s not part of the story. In any case, The Families returned to town and got back to what they know best. Normal service resumed.
You might have noticed the movie hardly shows ordinary people. When Joe rides into town, we see the individuals closing their shutters, mothers scurrying their children into their homes, the streets rapidly emptying of life. They are in self-imposed permanent Hartal, resigned to their misery.
After the film ends, and both families have been eliminated, what would the people have done? One imagines they emerge from their homes with their arms in the air, smiles on their faces, praising God for their escape from a nightmare. We could assume that they democratically elect a local government where DNA doesn’t count. Where the new political currency is ability, honesty, and sincerity. Where a new consensus is formed, constructed with the welfare of the people as its central mission.
Government for the people by the people. Or, more depressingly, the Mexican government might have come in and stuck a typically ruthless corrupt bastard of an oligarch in charge. Misery returns. Back to square one.
A World where no one rides in to town
Imagine Joe hadn’t come to town. What then? The Rojos were always going to win against the Baxters, without the need for external intervention. Lording it over the place, without any rivals, one can imagine success might have then gone to their head. Wiser counsel would have suggested they embark on a mission to modernise the town, creating higher paid employment and allowing businesses to thrive. Thus, the Rojos would bask in everlasting gratitude. The Baxters would be quickly forgotten and erased from the history books. There would be no further challenge to the power of the Rojos and they could cement their control for eternity.
However, would the more likely scenario not have been a slide to tyranny? Given the paucity of independent counsel, the intoxicating success of the triumph over the Baxters would have led to an explosion in demands from all the gunmen in the Rojo’s pay. They would have demanded their share of the spoils for their years of loyalty to the Rojo cause. Where would this come from? The only source would be the long-suffering townspeople, forced to hand over even more of their harvests while the Rojo family and its henchmen engaged in ostentatious consumption. There would be no scope for the people to seek redress for their grievances since there no longer existed an Opposition.
The Rojos would occasionally tell their “subjects” they would lead them to a glorious future of middle income status and prosperity. All the people saw, however, was that a few grabbed the bulk of the riches, very little trickled down and where it did, it took an eternity to do so. There was little visible sign of the kind of modern economy they had heard about the rising superpower across the nearby frontier. The people would have concluded that the Rojos had forfeited their chance, they had made life intolerable and they would have to go too.
Would the people have to wait till Ramon got old and couldn’t aim straight any more? Ah, but what if he had children, who would all learn to shoot from an early age? Then what? The cycle of violence would continue from generation to generation. Waiting or playing the long game therefore would not work.
Perhaps one day the citizens would have had decided they had had enough. They might have calculated that Ramon only had six bullets in his gun. That if the people in their hundreds and thousands all rushed the square at once, that the gunmen could be overwhelmed or would be too scared to pull the trigger once they saw the masses in front of them.
Well, we are all waiting for that remake.
Nevertheless, within the reality that is Bangladesh, should the townspeople just sit at home and hold their heads in despair? There are enough intelligent, smart people around who can see they can do better. That this place can reach the level of much of the rest of Rising Asia but only if (new) leaders, on all sides, would single-mindedly focus on the modernisation of the state, rather than wallow in petty rivalries.
Two years after A Fistful of Dollars was released in the US, in the real world, the people of East Pakistan poured out onto the streets in a mass upsurge and very soon after, they earned the right to rename their land as independent Bangladesh.
As for the Western setting of the film, many might be surprised to know that A Fistful of Dollars was actually a rip-off of Kurosawa’s Japanese film called Yojimbo. It was set in the East, after all.
Let us end with this dialogue which seems to capture the essence of what is wrong with basing one’s Deshi politics on Dead Heroes:
Joe: “Sometimes the dead can be more useful than the living.”
Silvanito: “I'm alive, and I want to remain with the living, understand? And when I'm dead, I want to remain with the dead. And I would be unhappy if somebody living forces me to remain with the living.”