Menace at the mangrove

Sundarbans is the largest single block of tidal halophytic mangrove forest in the world. It covers approximately 10,000 square kilometres (3,900 sq mi) of which 60% is in Bangladesh with the remainder in India. It is a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

The mangrove forest is now facing a major environmental disaster, after a vessel, carrying over 350,000 litres of furnace oil, capsized in Shela River, as the spill particularly jeopardised a dolphin sanctuary, the local food chain and the entire local ecology. Various authorities, who neither have the experience nor capability to handle such a mishap, have been trying to pass the responsibility to each other instead of making a move. The situation is getting worse by the minute since a tanker carrying 3.58 lakh litres of furnace oil sank in the early hours of December 9, 2014. The affected areas include Joymonir Ghol, Andharmanik and Nandabala.

The Shela River is known as a sanctuary for sweet-water Irawaddy and brackish-water Ganges dolphins. So, these marine creatures are the first in the line of victims of oil spill. Rare species like lizards, otters, snakes, Black-Capped Kingfishers, Horseshoe Crabs and Endemic River Terrapins were found dead and smeared with oil along the banks of the Shela River.

As a coastal mangrove forest, the vegetation in the Sundarbans gets inundated twice a day by high tides. Now that there is oil, as water recedes with low tide, the oil will remain on the vegetation and the forest topsoil. The vegetation is the main food for various kinds of deer that live in the dense forest surrounding the river. The deer, in turn, is one of the main foods of the Bengal tigers. So, in the long run, the population of deer and tigers – the two best known animals from the Sundarbans – will be affected.

The mangrove ecosystem of Sundarbans is primarily made up of four kinds of salt-water trees: Sundari, Kewra, Goran, Poshur and Gol. These trees reproduce from the windfall seeds that fall on the ground. As oil settles on the forest topsoil, these seeds will die and in the long run, the regeneration of the Sundarbans will be badly affected. That in turn will put the deer and different types of primates in trouble who depend on these trees for living.

These windfall seeds are the staple food of Pungash fish that also inhabit the Shela waters. This fish again is one of the main foods of crocodiles – a famous reptile from these forests. If Pungash does not get anything to eat, they will die, eventually putting the lives of crocodiles at risk as well.

The government has not taken proper measures to protect the Sundarbans despite the demand of the country’s people and concern of the international organisations, including UNESCO and Ramsar Convention, since this accident had occurred. Even after this accident, the government hopelessly failed to fight against the disaster as they do not have the necessary equipment for sucking up the oil from the water. Instead, they asked local people to collect the furnace oil using fishing nets, sponges or any other manual means and sell it to the State-run Padma Oil Company putting them under health risk.

Background of the disaster

The present Bangladesh government has established a number of quick rental and cogeneration peaking power plants. 100MW Gopalganj Power Plant is one of them built by Energypac for Power Development Board (PDB). It is a cogeneration peaking power plant, operational only at peak hours, when demand is higher, and stopped when the demand is low. The generators of this plant run on heavy fuel, ie, furnace oil, which is cheaper to set up, but costly to run. Bangladesh Petroleum Corporation (BPC) supplies furnace oil for this plant. And they hired Southern Star –7 to do this job.

Southern Star –7 was not fit for oil carrying; rather, it was a sand-carrying cargo.  The tanker had no head light to move in a densely foggy night. It had no registration and insurance. It was permitted to operate without following proper procedure. Even inspection during loading and unloading of oil was not done properly. The cargo was used as an oil tanker to make profit overnight.

It is not surprising that the disaster has been reportedly linked to corruption among ruling party elites. The owner of the tanker, Amir Hossain Farid, who did not have proper documents that would certify his cargo ship as capable of transporting oil, grabbed the work through allegedly exercising his connections to a senior minister. Whether the reports are in the end confirmed or not, there can be little doubt that the relevant rules and regulations could not have been flouted with such impunity, leading to the catastrophe, had it not been for official collusion and corruption. At the end of the day, corruption is at the heart of the crisis, as always.

Shela River where the accident took place was not used as a transit route before. After the Mongla-Ghashiakhali channel outside the Sundarbans has turned unsuitable for shipping three years back because of excessive siltation in the Kumarkhali River, the channel through Shela River inside the Sundarbans was started to be used and kept open for inland water transit from India only.

The dredging on Mongla-Ghashiakhali channel was supposed to be ended and opened up the international route of shipping between India and Bangladesh by December this year after a three-year pause. But only 20% of the dredging was completed due to huge corruption and malpractices of the ruling Awami League in the tendering process.

The oil tanker was plying ignoring the objections of the Forest Department. The Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Authority (BIWTA) had allowed vessels to use the alternative route of Shela River ignoring the objections. About three years ago, the Forest Department asked the Ministry of Shipping to stop movement of vessels in the Sundarbans. The Department in 2011 wrote a letter to the BIWTA, which runs under the Ministry of Shipping, directing them to stop the movement of vessels. Asked why the vessels’ movement was continuing despite the objections, Divisional Forest Officer in the East Zone, Amir Hossain Chowdhury said that the BIWTA was allowing the movement of vessels in the Sundarbans, as they “did not care” about the mangrove forest.

Voicing concern over the oil spill following the capsize of Southern Star -7 oil tanker in the Shela River, water and environment experts have raised question as to why the vessels had been allowed to ply inside the Sundarbans even after objections by the Forest Department some years ago, that had put the world’s largest heritage and Bangladesh’s pride at great risk? The question was also raised whether it was an accident or a planned attempt to destroy the world’s largest mangrove forest and its biodiversity? They suggested the government to announce it a troubled area and employ the army and the coast guards to quickly clean up the oil and oil slick in order to protect the biodiversity of the Sundarbans.

The plying of engine-run water vessels through the rivers of the Sundarbans is an utter violation of national and international rules and standards. The authorities who gave permission to run water vessels through the forest “must take the liability” of this calamity.

The Ministry of Shipping should be held responsible for the capsize of the oil tanker. Padma Oil which is under the BPC is also responsible for the incident as it did not conduct required inspection before operating such activities.

The accident

Oil tanker Southern Star -7 was on its way to the Gopalganj power plant with 357,664 litres of furnace oil. It anchored in the Shela River due to fog as it had no head light to move in a densely foggy night. Southern Star -7 capsized as another tanker MT Total hit it at around 6am in Chadpai Dolphin Sanctuary in Mrigamari area, seven kilometres away from Joumonirgul area of Mongla in Bagerhat. Seven crew members managed to swim ashore, but its captain Mokhlesur Rahman drowned and died.

This accident caused the biggest disaster to date in the mangrove forest of the Sundarbans. About 350,000 litres of oil has already spread over an area of 10,000 square kilometers after this accident. The slick spread to a second river and a network of canals in the Sundarbans. The oil spill has blackened the shorelines.

No steps were taken to salvage the vessel or clear the oil to bring the pollution under control within 24 hours. The place where the oil has spilled is a sanctuary for dolphins. This place is declared by UNESCO as a world heritage site and by the UN to be “one of the important wetlands of the world.”

This accident is more than enough to point out just how important the Sundarbans are as a global heritage site and also how unprotected the forest actually is. It shows how dangerous it is for oil, coal or toxic products to be transported through the rivers of the forest.

Effects of oil spill on the Sundarbans

Oil spill in rivers or channels of the mangrove forest in the Sundarbans is much more damaging than any oil spill in the sea or river. Because, the spilled oil will stay in the ecosystem of the affected area up to 50 years.

The oil slick will have a severe impact on the aquatic lives and the mangrove plants grown along the shorelines where the thick layer of oil has gathered. Fish and other aquatic lives would start dying in large numbers in a day or two, while the mangroves might start dying after a month. The spill will also cause a huge problem on the shorelines of canals and rivers for the animals of the mangrove forest to drink from.

The air around the Sundarbans is thick and it smells foul. The black slick flowing down the Shela and Pashur rivers, covering grasses and plants on their banks, gives a feeling that it is not the world’s biggest mangrove forest, rather an industrial city cursed by civilisation’s waste.

Animals have begun to die. The water hyacinths on the two rivers have turned black. Some Golpata trees have gone under heavy layers of oil.

One local, Abu Jafar, spotted two animals - a monitor lizard and an otter - dead and smeared with oil along the banks of the Shela.

Unless one knows, there is no reason to believe that what is coming into the canal is water, because it is black and has a thick layer of concentrated oil on top. Even the soil on the banks of the canal has turned black. The line stretches as far as the eyes can see. Everything below that line appears pitch black.

Fishermen who depend on the forest said the amount of fishing was high in the first two days after the accident and subsequently declined significantly.

“I used to catch around 20kg a day, but I got only 8kg on Thursday. I think weak aquatic species like small fishes, shrimps, crabs and others, might have died by getting smothered in the oil spill,” said Afjal Hossain Khan who lives near the Sorki canal of the nearby Mrigamari forest beat. “Perhaps the contamination of the water by the furnace oil was a reason for  the reduction of the amount of fish in the nets,” he added.

Faruk Khan and his 10-year-old son, who trap crab in the Sundarbans, said that over the last few days, the number of crabs he has netted has dramatically decreased.

“During the last two days we have collected only 32 crabs weighing 6kg, though we usually collect at least 20kg in that time,” he added. Political ecology researcher Tanzim Uddin Khan said two or three days are not enough to measure the negative impacts of the accident on different species of flora and fauna. We have to wait for some time to know the actual range of the damage unleashed.

Health risk

The Bangladesh government launched an intensified manual campaign to clean up seepage following a huge oil spill in 34,000 hectares at the Sundarbans. Forest authorities engaged 100 hired boats (both mechanised and local) and about 200 workers to remove spilled oil from adjoining canals of two rivers - Shela and Pashur - of the reserve forest using local equipment.

While a major government-led clean-up operation is being delayed by indecision, local people in the area are manually sopping up the floating furnace oil with sponges, encouraged by a Padma Oil offer to purchase the furnace oil for Tk30 per litre.

The clean-up so far has covered an insignificant portion of the volume of the oil spill.

Rafiqul Islam Babu, a local contractor of Padma Oil Company, said he purchased only 2,200 litres of oil collected by local people in the Joymonirgol area till December 11.

“I think we will be able to purchase hardly 80-90 barrels (16,000–18,000 litres) from local people in the next few days because the spilled oil has already spread across a vast area and started to dissolve,” he told the Dhaka Tribune.

On Thursday afternoon, the authorities asked local people via loudspeakers to collect oil floating on the river.

But residents said they found it difficult to gather the oil because of its rapid and continuous spread across the river and surrounding areas.

Ismail Ali, a resident of Joymonir Ghol village said he, together with five others, collected some 350 litres of furnace oil from the water in the last two days.

“We cannot work throughout the day to collect the oil because we have to wait for high tide as the oil detaches from the trunks of trees and soil and floats on the water during the period of high tide,” he added.

Local oil collectors are taking the ultimate health risk and may cause various skin diseases including hair fall if the furnace oil mixed water came in contact with the face or hair.

Improvident government worsens situation 

The imprudent and improvident government worsened the situation further in the Sundarbans. Starting from the moments after the accident, no particularly effective step has been visible from the government side till date.

In the absence of major government push to contain the ecological damage, Shipping Minister Shajahan Khan crowd-sourced the clean-up effort, asking local residents to collect whatever spilled furnace oil they could. He said Padma Oil was willing to pay for it. 

Environmentalists blasted the government’s handling of the serious issue as a piecemeal approach. It is impractical to expect the villagers to extract spilled oil from the surface of the so many rivers and canals, they said.

Though Navy vessel “Kandari 10” was brought from Chittagong on December 11 as the lone initiative by the government, it could not begin to apply oil dispersant till date because it had not been cleared to do so by the Environment Ministry.

On the other hand, amid the grave concern from different quarters over the environmental impact of the disastrous accident, shipping minister Shajahan Khan on Saturday said the oil spill in the Shela River and its surrounding areas “will cause little” to the Sundarbans. “We have talked to foreign experts who said the oil spilled from the crashed tanker will not harm the world’s largest mangrove forest that much,” he said while talking to reporters after visiting Chandpai Range of the mangrove forest.

The minister further said, “It will not affect dolphins and other animals as the oil has not spread that much. The oil could not enter the forest as fishing nets were used on the mouths of canals to prevent its spread. Besides, local people are collecting the spilled oil.” 

Replying to a question, Shajahan Khan said the government will decide whether it will shut the naval route of Chandpai range amid such a serious disaster.

Rampal power plant: The possibility of future accidents

To make matters worse, the government is now developing a 1,320MW coal-fired power station adjacent to the World Heritage Area. The Rampal Coal Plant is a joint partnership between India’s state-owned National Thermal Power Corporation and the Bangladesh Power Development Board. Construction has started and dredging including land filling is going on.

While the coal plant is located outside of the World Heritage Area, it will require dredging of the Pashur River to facilitate the transport of coal to the plant, and coal will be shipped through the World Heritage Area, presenting a significant threat to the ecological integrity of the Sundarbans.

It is mentioned in the project proposal that 4.72 million tonnes of imported coal will be transported to the Sunderbans’ Akram Point using large ships for Rampal Power Plant. From there, lighterages will ship the coal to the plant.

According to this plan, large ships will sail to Akram Point, which is 30 kilometres deep into the Sunderbans, 59 times a year. The rest of the way to the plant, spanning 67 kilometres, will be sailed by a number of lighterages 236 times a year.

In this way, according to the found evasive EIA report, the transportation of coal will affect the environment from three aspects. First: discharge of coal, dirt, fuel and chemicals from frequently sailing large and small ships will heavily contaminate the adjacent sea, rivers and the coast. Second, at Akram Point, where transfer from large ships to small lighterages will take place, discharge of coal wastes to the river water will cause huge contamination. Third, extensively frequent maritime transportation throughout the Pashur river will damage its banks, adding to the sound and light pollutions caused by the ships, which would negatively impact the ecosystem and wildlife.

UNESCO has already expressed concern about the project, stating: The EIA for the plant does not consider the impact of dredging in the rivers adjacent to the property. Only limited consideration has been given to the transport and transfer of coal in close distance to the property and no mitigation efforts beyond already existing regulations are known.

The dredging necessary to keep the channels of the Pashur River open for navigation is likely to alter the morphology of the river channels, which, in combination with erosion and sedimentation caused by the wakes of large vessels, would be likely to affect priority habitat for freshwater dolphins and other aquatic species, such as the critically endangered Batagur turtle (Batagurbaska) and vulnerable small clawed otter (Aonyxcinerea). Coal dust released into the environment during transport and transfer is likely to have a significant direct adverse impact on mangroves, fish, and probably freshwater dolphins, amongst other endangered species.

At its last meeting in June 2014, the World Heritage Committee requested “the State Party to undertake a comprehensive Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) to ensure that cumulative impacts of developments in the Sundarbans are adequately assessed, including in relation to the Outstanding Universal Values of the property.” The Bangladesh government was further requested to provide a report to UNESCO by February 1, 2015 on the state of conservation of the property and on the urgent progress required to address the issues raised.

The devastating oil spill this week demonstrates just how vulnerable the Sundarbans is to industrial shipping accidents and how careless the concerned authorities are in maintaining this World Heritage Site.

Transparency International Bangladesh’s Executive Director, Dr Iftekharuzzaman said, “This accident gives some indication of just how risky it is to use this river route through the Sundarbans and also how dangerous it is to set up the Rampal power plant next to the forest. The government must immediately stop this river route and remove the Rampal power plant project from here, or else we will lose Sundarbans’ status as a World Heritage Site and the forest itself will eventually be destroyed.”

NGOs and community groups are calling on the Bangladeshi government to halt the Rampal Coal Plant and protect the precious Sundarbans forest. The oil spill is devastating, but let’s hope it will be a wake-up call to the government.

Conclusion

The Sundarbans is a unique habitat for a number of wildlife. Apart from the Bengal tiger, Gangetic and Irawaddy dolphin, primates, Indian fishing cat, Indian otter and spotted deer, many other prominent fauna populate the single biggest mangrove forest in the world. 

The healthy existence of the forest is absolutely crucial for Bangladesh. In 2007, the Sundarbans, acting as a natural shield, weakened down the devastating cyclonic storm Sidr, preventing it from inflicting irrevocable damage to a huge coastal populace of the country.

An oil tanker sinking and resulting in spillage of 358,000 litres of furnace oil is a major environmental disaster for the Sundarbans mangrove forest. No remedial measures have been taken to contain the spill. This is so because no effective counter measure exists as the forest department lacks just enough logistics to deal with the calamity. What is even more abhorrent is that although it is illegal to operate vessels through protected forests, in reality, hundreds of such vessels have been navigating the Shela River since 2011 when Bangladesh Inland Water Transport Agency (BIWTA) had lifted the ban.

Now that the vessel has sunk and oil has spilled across a 20km area, precisely what is to be done is the challenge. Unless measures are taken now, biodiversity in the area is set to suffer severely. The afflicted area will adversely affect marine and wildlife of the mangrove forest if not contained. We are informed that with the rise in tide, the oil will spread further into other parts of the channel. Given that the Sundarbans is a world heritage site and home to many unique species of plant and animal life, it is time to enlist the help of the Navy which is purported to have in its stock chemical agents to scoop up oil spills. In the longer run, authorities need to undertake dredging of Mongla-Ghasiakhali channel to restore its navigability and ban all heavy marine vessels from using the Sundarbans water channels