Bangladesh’s inclusive growth strategy views SMEs as crucially important drivers of sustained broad based output, employment and income generation. According to the Bangladesh Bank Governor, SMEs account for 40% of overall employment and 80% of industrial jobs in Bangladesh. 90% of total industrial units are SMEs, contributing nearly 25% of the country’s GDP.
Absence of track record in business and lack of real assets to offer as collateral make it difficult for SMEs to access debt finance on affordable terms.
Banks and financial institutions primarily geared towards serving larger urban businesses are in general neither well motivated nor well equipped to serve SMEs in dispersed locations far off from branches. Besides higher risks in SME lending, they also find SME loan administration costlier. Commercial banks are not interested to finance SMEs because of the high risk and high supervision cost. In these circumstances SMEs find it hard to get credit for inputs procurement and other expenses. SMEs often also have to sell their produces on credit, further burdening their precarious finances.
Bangladesh Bank has adopted a comprehensive approach in trying to address the multifarious SME financing impediments and disincentives, covering all areas from attitudinal orientation of the lending institutions onward, such as: mainstreaming institutionalisation of socially and environmentally responsible financing in corporate ethos and objectives of lending institutions as well as practices like credit rating supplemented by “factoring” of receivables are a few to mention.
Syed Tamzidur Rahman (STR), Moderator at the discussion, CEO and Chief Consultant of Changemaker
The government and civil society organisations are active in supporting and promoting SME initiatives, working for removal of the financial and nonfinancial impediments to their commercial sustenance in the supply chains of the goods and services they produce. What are the major impediments still remaining in the financing of SMEs?
Kamal Talukdar, DMD Eastern Bank Ltd
The NGOs that have been working towards poverty alleviation have also created numerous entrepreneurs. Unfortunately, these entrepreneurs fall in the gap of microcredit clients and lenders of commercial banks; and SME entrepreneurs are candidates of such a “gap.” This gap still exists as we (the commercial bankers) are trying to cater to their need using the conventional banking system.
The provisions that exist for the purpose of financial inclusion of SME are unfortunately quite inadequate. As a banker I can say that it is impossible to support such a vast sector utilising only the windows of a hardcore commercial banking system.
Commercial banking is simply not equipped to carry SME forward and graduate them to the next phase. Other nations which share our socio-economic structure all have adopted an SME banking system exclusively dedicated to support and facilitate SME entrepreneurs. SMEs are often known to incur loan defaults, not because they are unwilling to pay but due to unavoidable external factors.
The laws that apply to large enterprises should not be applicable for SMEs. I believe there remains more room for updating the guidelines of Bangladesh Bank to further accommodate the SME context. It is absolutely necessary for us to become more pragmatic and address the grassroots level entrepreneurs effectively and this can be achieved by creating a specialised SME banking system.
STR: SME financing has been identified as a major obstacle to SME growth. Though the majority of the issues are with the SME themselves, the banks also have major issues in designing financial products for the SMEs. SMEs have very limited bank finance and self-finance remains the major source of their fund. What are the demand side issues ie, issues with the SME themselves and what are the different strategic models which can best suit to address SMEs needs?
CM Alam, Entrepreneur and former MD IPDC
SMEs defined as Small and Medium Enterprises pose a problem for small rural businesses, so I like to define them simply as “small business.” In order to address their financial issues it needs not only a different mindset but also never-ending-passion for entrepreneurship development. It is a fact that rural entrepreneurs have keen business instincts along with being resilient and enterprising. It is prudent to mention here that in rural areas impact in terms of job/wealth creation is high and specialised knowledge in book keeping and the like are crucial to the smooth running and profitability. Something in the form of an equity fund could have solved most of their problems, and this could easily come from banks as part of their CSR allocation as well as from international organisations focusing on such needs. At the end of the day, accumulating funds is not the problem, proper distribution of the funds is.
South America does this using a scoring system through a questionnaire; we could emulate them instead of planning on and being apprehensive of conducting elaborate studies. This will be an effective approach because the entrepreneurs know their local situation best, which is all that is relevant. In terms of monitoring, nowadays we have at our disposal the cell phones which can act as trackers, providing us with the data we need.
The bottom line is, the banking system, corporate bodies, the government and a number of relevant international organisations can come together creating a fund which can be used as equity investment for rural entrepreneurs, while credit can come from the government or financial institution on a wholesale basis.
STR: What have been your experiences in finding ways to bringing down lender’s and borrower’s costs?
Syed Faridul Islam, Head of Risk Management, BRAC Bank Limited
Bangladesh Bank has created a number of policies regarding SMEs. In 2010, the SME cell was created with the sole purpose of facilitating the growth of SMEs. Banks are provided with targets and these are in turn monitored to see whether the targets are being achieved. The majority of banks emphasise on urban needs but it is imperative that we realise that a large portion of financial needs come from rural areas. We need a drastic shift in mindset if we are to address the rural needs by taking the initiative and reaching out to them.
Bank branches are not adequately equipped to effectively reach remote rural areas, which is why BRAC Bank has 458 SME units touching almost all the districts of the country. These units have autonomy to a certain extent, and beyond that threshold of decentralised work process, we have a more centralised process in place. This combination of decentralisation and centralisation appears to work best when it comes to addressing the needs of SMEs spread out all over the country, especially in terms of timeliness in a loan sanction. As far as the product is concerned, we essentially have what we need; we simply need to redesign it to fit the exact needs faced by entrepreneurs.
In terms of gaps between banks and entrepreneurs, formal financial statements often become an issue, however, banks can always take the initiative and educate these people in the ways of formal book keeping as well as take a closer look at whatever form of records they do keep which are usually authentic indicators of the enterprise’s profitability.
As you know SME loan demands high supervision which involves cost. More monitoring leads to more increase in cost. However, with adoption of modern technology this can be reduced. Mobile banking systems can not only do away with the need to physically be present while providing a loan, it can even allow the recipients to pay monthly instalments using mobile phones.
Limitations are there in that daily transactions are restricted to Tk25,000 but if such hindrances are dealt with effectively we can definitely take mobile banking to the next level, thereby exponentially assisting in rural banking needs of SME entrepreneurs.
STR: Your long experience as formerly an SME entrepreneur and now as a director of a financial institution, what do you think about the policy reforms towards more inclusiveness and what are the major challenges especially for woman entrepreneurs
Hasina Newaz, Leading Entrepreneur in Printing and Packaging, Director of a National Bank and Women Entrepreneurs’ Leader
I have had the fortune of sitting at both ends of the table; I am working in the banking sector and I have been an entrepreneur in the SME sector for a while. The policies provided by Bangladesh Bank are more than sufficient for financing SMEs, but unfortunately the implementation of such policies is far from effective. It is a common occurrence that entrepreneurs reach the gates of banks in the hopes of acquiring a loan, but the person who will sanction such a loan remains far from their reach.
It all boils down to the right mindset and I can assure you that SME entrepreneurs, especially woman entrepreneurs almost never cause a loan default; we face cases of loan defaults in amounts reaching cores of Taka and yet SMEs hardly ever ask for loans above Tk5 lakh and rarely ever fail to pay it back.
Timeliness is another major issue in case of loan sought for a particular season and it is utterly useless if not provided within the time to catch the seasonal market. To ensure that SMEs get more loans and banks also meet their SME targets, the present mindset needs to be changed. This will flourish both the enterprises and the banking sector.
STR: What are the industry/enterprise practices that can work as risk guarantee schemes for SMEs? What are your experiences?
Niaz Rahim, Managing Director Rahimafrooz Superstores, President Rotary Club of Dhaka Mahanagar
During the days when the first retail superstore Agora was being established “passion” was key since supporting and contributing factors were mostly unavailable. In terms of managing the supply chain, our suppliers were often extremely small in scale and scope. Moving forward, even though we were heavily discouraged from packaging our products in the fear of raising prices too high, we were steadfast in the idea that we as producers, need to exercise a minimum sense of quality and dignity.
Those suppliers who appeared aligned with our progressive mode of thought were the only ones brought into our fold. In my opinion, money can never be the sole driver of a successful business enterprise, it is simply an important ingredient accompanied by numerous factors among which market access is noteworthy. We facilitated access to finance of small businesses and start ups by effectively closing the gaps between the two, banks and the suppliers who were intimidated by banks. We filled their forms and guided them through every step of the way and gradually they became regular borrowers of the banks which they could not approach earlier. When we look at the same suppliers today, we see that almost all of them have grown significantly. At the end of the day, smooth functioning of a business pivots upon the partnership between financial institutions and business entities.
STR: How much access has actually been created through Bangladesh Bank policy packages? What is your view on the overall access to finance?
Arfan Ali, DMD, Bank Asia
As we know, the bank performs three functions: Efficient distribution of capital, risk management and low cost funding. In terms of acquiring financing, challenges are faced mostly by small businesses because they lack the experience and resilience required to absorb economic or environmental shocks.
Ours is a densely populated country and a large portion of its population is employed by SMEs, consequently it is crucial for banks to reach out to these SMEs and provide assistance. Bangladesh bank has created policies on SMEs in order to facilitate the growth and smooth running of such enterprises. On top of that Bangladesh Bank also encourages female entrepreneurship through such steps as reduced interest rates on loans to 10%, collateral fee up to an amount of Tk25 lakh etc. When speaking of financial inclusions, three elements are indispensable.
First, the channel of distribution needs to reach the doorstep of the customers. Second, in terms of service, banks have to be able to cater to unique needs and tailor their services to fit the requirements of the region. Third, the service that is brought can never be so costly that it ceases to be a feasible venture for the customer. SMEs are known to have poor book keeping practices and a solution as encouraged by Bangladesh Bank is Agent Banking.
The well connected NGOs that are active in nearby areas can be engaged and utilised through partnerships, thus bringing about Agent Banking. In this, Bank Asia goes a step further by managing and maintaining a booth in remote locations, through which SMEs are being provided with loans. An entrepreneur can submit the loan application to the agent who will in turn submit it to a branch office and it will then be the responsibility of the branch to process and sanction the loan applied for. Agents can even be utilised to supervise and collect instalment payments from clients.