The Finance Minister deserves thanks for highlighting the issue of bureaucratic corruption through his peculiar way of focusing on issues. He has recently said that “speed money” given to expedite official work is excusable.
While having to deflect allegations of empathy or even camaraderie for individuals considered leeches of society, his statement actually did make a valid point. “Facilitation money” or speed money, as opposed to bribery, is defined as resources spent to expedite work done by officials, the work itself being completely legal.
Bribery on the other hand is money paid to officials to do something that, in itself, is illegal. However, conceptually speaking it is easy to see how totally legal work can be rendered petrified, without “adequate” payments, thus making speed money appear to look like bribery.
This means, that, while work obtained through bribery is not legal, which may be made invalid by a court, work obtained through speed money can be perfectly legal. But extra money, whether it be speed money or bribery, can collectively be called ghoosh, in our local terminology, for the purpose of this discourse.
Ghoosh also includes all sorts of extra perks, eg. after retirement jobs, promotions, lucrative transfers, foreign travel, and a host of perks of dubious moral value.
We all agree that official corruption in the form of ghoosh in bureaucracy has reached an epidemic level in Bangladesh. The “2014 Index of Economic Freedom,” a publication of the Heritage Foundation in partnership with the Wall Street Journal states: “corruption is a serious impediment to investment and economic growth in Bangladesh. By some estimates, bribes and other off-the-record payments paid by firms related to public procurement, tax and customs collection, and other regulatory authorities may reduce annual GDP by 3%.”
The overwhelming and all-encompassing power of the government bureaucrats have ensured that no work can be done in government offices without extra money, whereas much can be accomplished through extra payments.
But where is this ghoosh culture leading us. Bureaucrats run circles of fiefdoms in their offices, where even the lower rungs are interconnected to form a single impregnable mass of corruption; where the buck passes from one table to another in a perfect environment of impunity.
As it stands
The level of ghoosh has no heads and tails, and depends on the official’s perceived notion of how much the citizen can be squeezed to pay the amounts demanded. Once the official understands the relative power position of a specific person, he may raise or lower the amount unilaterally and arbitrarily.
In business circles, it is often said that there are four kinds of bureaucrats – those who are honest and responsive about the work, those who are honest but unresponsive, those who are dishonest but responsive, and those who are both dishonest and unresponsive.
Understandably, the first and the third kinds are the most preferred by working citizens. One important scourge about ghoosh is that it is difficult for the uninitiated to know how much is the standard amount to be paid for a specific work. If the amounts for specific jobs were uniform for everyone, then the matter may not have been so grave.
But the situation is that, since the transactions regarding ghoosh are almost always done undercover, the specific amounts vary from case to case for the same kind of work. This is the cause of much distress.
Common citizens in their day to day work always lag behind and are often left to running from door to door in a labyrinthine maze of agents, officials and tables. Persons more adept at manipulating the system get more mileage for their efforts at lesser time and less money.
The culture of ghoosh has established that money, and not merit is the determinant of success. Tenders and contracts may be awarded not on the basis of economic viability and competence but on the amount of facilitation paid.
Lucrative positions in government offices can be obtained through payment of cash that gets shared by the highest authorities including political echelons. Competent and honest officers are left behind, often to become, in later years, subordinates of morally decadent manipulative colleagues.
The prospect of earning ghoosh sometimes even incents officials to invent problems relating to civic and criminal matters in the hope of extracting ghoosh money from innocent citizens. This happens regularly in law enforcement and in land matters where small changes in records can have serious implications in ownership documentation.
In some cases, the government stands to lose huge amounts of revenue in the customs and income tax departments, or municipal corporations. Companies which import raw materials legally cannot compete with companies who import goods with ghoosh. Ghoosh is all pervasive, and some would say, is even present in the defense departments.
The effect of ghoosh in the judiciary is extremely serious and therefore should be dealt with separately. The judges are burdened with 2.3 million cases and a salary structure that cannot guarantee their financial freedom to do what is just. Anyone who has traversed the realms of the judicial process knows how contorted the legal processes are.
Payments must be paid at every step to judicial employees in court cases that run for years. Delays can be manipulated through payments to officials. Everything is guided by lawyers who sometimes benefit from milking both sides.
One extremely pernicious aspect of ghoosh culture is how it affects foreign investment in the country. Foreign companies are usually guided by the laws of their lands which prevent the companies and their individual officers to engage in bribery or in payment of “facilitation expenses” in foreign lands.
The USA and the UK among other nations have specific laws to enforce these, namely the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act 1977, and the UK Bribery Act 2010. Companies belonging to these nations are reluctant to invest funds in countries where they are confronted by compliance issues relating to corruption, specially through bribery.
They can only compete in these countries through quality, service and price and therefore lose out to local competitors who can also use bribery as a comparative advantage. In fact, this debilitating aspect of ghoosh also prevents many ethical local companies from investing in enterprises which require frequent interactions with government functionaries.
The story of the moral
One very significant aspect of pervasive corruption is how it affects the socio-cultural position of individuals who mould their lives on ethical, moral or religious models.
Where society expects this group to give moral leadership to a country’s overall development, these idealistic individuals get marginalised to the side lines whereby ultimately they become the outcasts of society. It is probably the primary cause of the present day moral decadence of the country.
Children of officials flush with corruption money attend third rate universities abroad and at home in shiny cars but learn nothing, while meritorious children of idealist parents cannot even attend a government college. Morality has taken a back seat and the corrupt and the immoral elements of society are in the driving seat.
Strangely enough, Indonesia is frequently cited by detractors of the effects of corruption on developing economies as a country which has done well in spite of the rampant corruption. It is now universally agreed that even Indonesia has suffered immensely for its ubiquitous corruption, which the authorities are trying to stamp out perhaps through recognising its growth inhibiting aspects and from pressure from foreign investors.
The why and how of it
Perhaps it would be wise to try to understand first what motivates the officials to engage in corruption. Is it just an inherent urge to engage in something profitable because it can be done, or are there other factors involved ? Not only does it go against the terms of service but corruption goes against the social, moral and religious mores of the society.
One would not willingly want to be tainted as corrupt. Also, astute officials consider the consequences of times when idealism may play a role and wealth statements and bank accounts may be looked into without impunity.
Interestingly, naughty cynics have suggested that a large proportion of the gold bars being imported into the country these days is insurance for corrupt persons wanting to circumvent the banking system during uncertain times.
Right after the independence of Bangladesh it was felt that the country needed to move away from the legacy of the 22 families that was presumed to have taken a stranglehold over the economy and was blamed as the cause of the subjugation of Bangalis.
To establish the impression that the country would be run along socialist principles, it was necessary to cut down the salaries and pay-perks of government officials. In time, politicians discovered an added benefit in this policy: it provided the tool necessary to subjugate the powerful body of bureaucrats who held the actual reins of power.
This situation has remained static ever since. Pay of government officials is despicably low over their counterparts in industry. However, with all encompassing power that they wield, they have found their way around this constraint through institutionalised corruption.
Trade unions also played a vital role in the spread of corruption at all levels. Immediately after independence, the country went on a tail-spin with a failing economy and weak leadership at the top. Keeping control over trade unions became the supreme objective of the political leadership, which they did through empowering the trade unions to impose their own fiefdoms in their own organisations.
The organisation, be it a utility company or a government fuel agency, was milked by union bosses who collaborated with politicians to stay in power. Corporate profitability was replaced with corporate corruption. And the cooperation to foster corruption that started between unions and the politicians, which eventually drew the bureaucrats into its whirlpool, endure to this day.
The necessary evil
This is not to say that all bureaucrats are corrupt. There are numerous burning examples of scrupulously honest officials who braved grave personal difficulties but did not succumb to temptations. However, the question is, does the nation have the right to demand so much from so few, and does it make any sense for these individuals to make so much personal and family sacrifices, when the nation as a whole refuses to recognise their heroism in any meaningful way ?
Nobody supports corruption for its own sake including its perpetrators. It is a by-product of the system that sustains it. The political need to establish the perception of socialism does not exist anymore. Many low-level employees of private firms now earn several times the pay of senior government officers. This anomaly must be corrected.
Transparency International, Bangladesh has made great strides in recent years to highlight the damaging aspects of bureaucratic corruption. But, unfortunately they have not gone into the roots of the problem. Efforts to eradicate corruption must go hand in hand with solving the root causes of it.
If senior government officials are not given the financial independence to live by their own conscience, then it is natural that the citizens will not get a fair share of their efforts.
Perhaps, sub-consciously, the people at large have been forgiving enough to understand this. Perhaps, the public have not recoiled from their sense of empathy for these individuals who engage in something against their conscience day in and day out but have collectively held the nation together.
Perhaps the time has come to try to integrate the needs of the people, who suffer so much at the hands of these officials, with the genuine demands of the officials who are entrusted with the safe keeping of the citizens.
Everyone will agree that complete eradication of bureaucratic corruption is almost impossible. However, containment to acceptable levels must be the goal of policy makers. The fact stands today that payments are regularly made by common citizens to bureaucrats for their various government related works as payment for services delivered. Instead of salary that should be paid by the government, this money is subsidised by the people, albeit grudgingly.
If these amounts are being paid already by the people, albeit in an underhand way, is it not time that strategies be found to standardise and legitimise these in possibly quasi-legal open arrangements so citizens do not have to suffer so much uncertainty, ego-bruising, and time wastage, and at the same time bureaucrats be freed from guilt of their conscience? Bad management of a necessary evil is causing more harm than good. Almost always, acceptance of an evil is the primary step to its ultimate eradication.
Bad apples shall exist always. Efforts should be made to monitor the wealth of bureaucrats through stringent monitoring, preferably through the Bangladesh Bank or the NBR, or otherwise through private monitoring by civic bodies established specifically for this purpose. Individual cases of bribery should be pursued by groups of local citizens, one at a time.
It is highly unlikely that political support can be secured to contain corruption, because corruption is their raison d’être. Is it not strange that the present opposition political party, although caught up in the most humiliating situation has not voiced concerns about corruption which definitely would have ensured grass-root popular support for them?
Therefore, the banner must be carried by civic bodies, and the media which exists on the basis of popular support, and pressures must be mounted for the appointment of Civic Ombudsmen to oversee the activities of government officials. And if everything else fails, then one lone man with a pen, or one man in the street with a mobile phone must put in his two bits to combat this great malaise that confronts this great nation.