Before WWII, sustained GDP growth of 7% a year was virtually unheard of. However, since then, 13 economies have grown at an average rate of at least 7% for 25 years or longer: Malaysia, Singapore, Taiwan, Brazil, Hong Kong, India, Japan, China, Vietnam, Korea, Indonesia, Botswana, Oman and Malta. At that pace, an economy doubles in size every 10 years.
Interestingly, after WWII, when Japan grew at such rates, commentators considered it an exception rendered possible by post-war recovery. Next, when the “Asian Tigers” (Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore and Korea) achieved such growth rates, commentators said it was only possible because they were small.
More recently, when China surpassed 7% growth rates, they said it was because China was so big. Each time, they called it a “miracle.” But miracles they are not, because unlike miracles, they have been explained and repeated.
There is of course no one-size-fits-all strategy to growth, but it is possible to tease out policy strategies from the above 13 that merit closer attention:
Outward turn: Using the global economy as the essential resource Understanding human capital: Workforce development Orientation toward the future: Higher savings and investment rates Stable governmentsAn “outward turn” was more feasible post-World War II as the international economy became more open, allowing growing economies to import ideas, technologies and knowledge. Rarely did the fast-growing economies produce original technology and knowledge, but they absorbed it at a considerable pace, aided by prioritisation of research by policymakers. The fast learning countries became the fast growing economies.
Exports became the focal point for macroeconomic policy. While the role of exports was nowhere disputed – that of export promotion was. To prioritise exports, countries promoted specific sectors through tax breaks, subsidies, import tariff exemptions, cheap credit, dedicated infrastructure, or bundled them via dedicated export zones.
Some also actively intervened to keep the currency competitive, regulating by the amount and type of capital flowing across their borders while accumulating substantial foreign reserves in the central bank. The trade-off of keeping the currency competitive and more export-sector-friendly is that it can limit the amount of capital a country imports, and raise the cost of capital, which in turns reduces investments.
However, in the early stages of high growth, management of exchange rates can be helpful as long as it is done to slightly tip the balance in favour of exports (to overcome informational asymmetries and other potential frictions) and secondly, to prevent a sudden surge of capital inflows (which can disrupt the growth of export sectors).
Foreign education at large and foreign higher education in particular has proven to be an important channel for knowledge transfer as evidenced by almost all the 13 high-growth economies.
During the Meiji Restoration, the Japanese government pursued an active policy to attract their diaspora back to Japan. More recently, China has done the same to invite Chinese students and professionals trained in western universities to return to China and help develop market-oriented policies and institutions.
China has also actively encouraged Chinese students to continue to pursue studies overseas. The Singaporean government has scholarship schemes that send bright students to acquire learning from western universities with the condition to return and contribute. In addition to knowledge transfer, the returning diaspora bring back with them a wealth of international networks that can be beneficial.
However, is an outward turn the only road to growth? Some economists have looked inward as well towards consumption, to bolster the home work and make it more competitive for imports.
There are advantages to inward looking strategies as well: they eschew the risks and dislocations that emerge from opening up a country to foreign competition too abruptly. However, growth strategies that rely exclusively or mostly on domestic demand eventually hit a plateau: economies then lose the space to specialise in whatever it is best at producing.
At this point, it is worth considering the importance of macroeconomic stability, of which Bangladesh has been a poster child. Bangladesh has mustered around 6% growth for 11 years, and the standard deviation thereof is the least among other developing countries in Asia, Africa and Latin America.
Macroeconomic stability is the foundation for higher growth and Bangladesh deserves the attention it’s getting for sustaining its growth rate. However, having macroeconomic stability will not spur on higher growth rates unless the government invests in infrastructure and human capital, and sets policies to encourage a mindset of “saving for the future.”
Low inflation is a fantastic achievement but it does not compensate for poor education or rickety infrastructure. That will never attract or drive investment required to quickly lift masses of people out of poverty and post the high growth rates seen elsewhere in Asia.
In the more populous high-growth countries, in the beginning, jobs were hard to come by, wages were low and many people were self-employed out of necessity. The solution to this almost began with gainful employment in export industries for people otherwise underemployed in the traditional or informal sectors, until the economy creates better jobs, worthy of better educated workers.
As the export sector deepens and enriches, workers find more options and sectors to move back and forth between. Of course, workers find it easier to pick up new skills and enter new trades if they are literate and educated. This creates the scope for government and private sector interventions to expand existing educational and training opportunities and thus increase labour mobility.
In any period of fast growth, labour like other forms of capital will move rapidly from sector to sector, and governments ought not to temper the market forces that pull people into urban areas or destroy some jobs, because new ones will be created.
Yes, there will be haphazard urbanisation, but it will pave the way for greater planning and foresight. No country has achieved sustained rapid growth without initiating and maintaining high rates of public investment in education, training, and workforce development. The good news for Bangladesh is that an abundant labour supply is a boon for catch-up growth.
Now, turning to infrastructure, unlike other forms of government investment, in infrastructure in particular does not crowd out private investment, but crowds it in – it enables new industries to emerge and raises the return to private ventures that benefit from healthy, educated workers, passable roads and reliable electricity.
Unfortunately, infrastructure spending is not given its due and it’s often not measured (as tends to happen with statistics: what gets valued gets measured, and what does not get measured gets ignored). In fast-growing Asia, public investment in infrastructure accounted for 7% of GDP with higher percentages in China, Thailand and Vietnam.
Telecommunications infrastructure and the pricing of services are of particular importance as well. Eventually, telecommunications promotes widespread access to financial services and hence savings; raises productivity by disseminating price information to farmers and other producers; drives literacy and vocational learning; enables transparency initiatives; and facilitates delivery of government services. It is also the basis for globalisation of the information technology industry – a rapidly growing area of commerce for Bangladesh.
But of course, for investments in infrastructure and education to grow, there has to be a commensurate savings pool to finance the investments. Bangladesh’s savings rate is actually lower than most countries in Asia.
And there is a case for strategic policy intervention here. Perhaps we as a people have not been future-oriented enough and it is high time we understood how to create better futures for successive generations.
All the 13 economies mentioned earlier were significantly future-oriented at the beginning stages of their growth: foregoing consumption for a higher standard of living in the future. Rapid investment growth is just not possible without the availability of savings: a national saving rate of 25% is not unusual and much higher saving rates have been required to sustain high investment growth.
China’s savings rate, which was already very high, increased from an average of 36% in 1980–89 to 46% in 2000–2008. The low level of female labour force participation also contributes to low household and private saving rates. Households in which more women work tend to save beyond the additional income effect. Education levels are, not surprisingly, also closely related to savings rates.
Policy options can be grouped in two categories: demand-side policies to inform household saving decisions; and supply-side policies to improve regulatory, institutional, and other conditions in which saving decisions are made.
On the demand side, if implemented effectively, a national financial literacy strategy is likely to promote financial literacy nationwide and have a significant impact on savings rate, as was evidenced in Turkey. On the supply side, policy options included developing financial intermediation in three ways: (i) better use of existing products (such as private pensions and corporate bonds), including, but not limited to, taxation of different instruments; (ii) more investment in new products and better regulatory framework; and (iii) special saving schemes.
In Bangladesh, further developing the corporate bond market is one policy option. Nonbank financial institutions (NBFI) are widely regarded as being critical for bond market development given their long–term investment strategies. If bond markets are underdeveloped, both pension funds and insurance companies are forced to hold short-term securities, which do not correspond to the liability side of their balance sheet and therefore expose them to maturity mismatches. Therefore, developing the bond market has the impact of developing the pension funds industry and the insurance industry.
Private pension schemes have recently gotten some attention in Bangladesh but they have the potential to expand. Besides raising the awareness of households about planning for retirement, making the private pension scheme attractive could help the sector grow and generate long-term savings.
Malaysia and Thailand both have highly developed financial markets, deepening bond markets and high saving rates; their experiences may be relevant for Bangladesh. Some countries like Singapore have employed more direct measures to enforce thrift, eg, the establishment of the Central Provident Fund, a mandatory savings scheme, in 1955.
So what role is the government to play in all this? Successful growth histories have vindicated the importance of having an increasingly capable, committed and stable government. Since high growth requires high savings, it requires strong political leadership to first dedicate itself to a growth strategy, then communicate to the public that the rewards for future generations after generations are well worth the effort, thrift and near-term economic upheaval as it were.
In all examples of countries with high growth, not only were there consistent and strong political leadership but also communication with the people to ensure that they understood the value of future-orientation.
It has to be remembered that policy-making in a developing economy is not easy. Economists know how a market economy will respond to prescriptions where there are mature institutional foundations that define property rights, enforce contracts, and convey prices that bridge informational gaps between buyers and sellers.
This is harder to do for a high-growing, developing country. A high-growth economy is a moving target in that bad policies are often good policies applied for too long. But the good news is that market and regulatory institutions tend to co-evolve with the economy, as has happened elsewhere. A stable and effective government is critical in the long run that maintains price stability and fiscal responsibility.
GDP growth is of course not an end in itself. But no poor country has lifted itself out of poverty without exhibiting high rates of GDP Growth. Moreover, social welfare goals such as health care, education and the other Millennium Development Goals are not achievable without growth. Growth therefore while not sufficient, is a necessary condition to lift masses out of poverty and drudgery and enable individual, familial and national well-being.