Rousseff’s difficult second term, and her abundant promises

It took little more than four hours, but Brazil has counted the votes and elected its leader. With 51.64% of nationwide preference, Dilma Rousseff is the re-elected president.

From January 1st, she will have four more years to prove that there will be no reversals to the recent social developments, to stimulate a discouraged economy, and to appease a polarised population. It is true that neither she nor rival candidate Aécio Neves are representatives of change, but fundamental differences between the two meant she remained in power.

Looking back

Although Dilma Rousseff has reached the top of the political game without going through the usual path through state and local governments, her life story gives a more clear understanding of how she got involved with such affairs. Daughter to a Bulgarian engineer and a Brazilian schoolteacher, Rousseff grew up in Belo Horizonte – the intellectual stronghold of the region.

This was the 1960s, a dark moment for most of South America. Under a number of pseudonyms and false identities, the highly educated teenager Rousseff first became involved with clandestine reading groups and associations, developing affinities for socialism and workers’ politics.

It is between rallies and demonstrations that she met Cláudio Galeno Linhares. They joined forces with fellow companions as the founders of the National Liberation Command, an armed resistance movement.

With the introduction of the infamous Institutional Act 5, through which began the most intense period of repression, the opposition began to be seized. Fearful of the same fate, 19-year-old Rousseff fled to Rio de Janeiro. The clandestine groups begin to unite and grow in numbers.

For being at the wrong place at the wrong time, she was arrested in São Paulo in 1970. Two years and four months of prison and torture followed. She was arrested for leading strikes – illegal at the time – and bank robberies that financed armed warfare.

In a legendary debate with Senator Agripino Maia in 2008, Rousseff (by then minister of state for civil office) remembered these times in a speech that gained her broader visibility and sympathy before Brazilians: “I am proud to have lied, because it is not easy to lie under torture. But in a democracy, we must speak the truth.” 

Later, already under a democratic system, she established a branch of the Democratic Labour Party (PDT). Rousseff was appointed as secretary of energy, mining and communication in Rio Grande do Sul by the state governor.

“She always had a strong presence – that is why people are confused and think she is aggressive,” said former Governor Alceu Colares when she first stepped to power. At the end of both their terms, the country was already in a very different situation: inflation was no longer rampant, the country finally settled on a currency, though still in vogue, and Brazil was a full democracy.

Four years later, in 1999, she was summoned once again for the same position, composing staff this time led by the Labour Party.

In 2002, she became minister of mines and energy. In 2010, after corruption scandals in the Civil House, she assumed the position of chief of staff. Rousseff came to fame by obsessing with data and little appetite for politics. For this combination, she secured her space by centralising decisions and not forgiving doubts among her subordinates.

Thus, Rousseff became the natural successor of Luis Inácio “Lula” da Silva. On the one hand, the public recognised that she was a competent, technocratic manager, on the other hand, she lacked charisma to get elected.

However, the discovery of a lymphoma in 2009, in the middle of her political campaign, brought her sympathy whilst she handled the illness under the public eye. She became the first woman president of Brazil.

Skeletons in the closet – During the recently concluded elections, her greatest achievement, perhaps due to her ever-increasing experience, has been that she is finally shining with her own light.

Former president “Lula” da Silva caused a stir when he chose Rousseff as a candidate in 2010. Although Rousseff displayed competence in managing the ministries of her predecessor, she lacked the empathy required of a good politician.

At the time, Lula’s popularity, and declaration of full support was a decisive factor. Several corruption scandals later, association with his image and the Labour Party was discouraging to investors and upper-middle-class alike.

As predicted, stock markets plummeted shortly her victory.

Cases of government rigging are one of the main counterweights to Brazil’s recent social development. Supposedly, high positions in state enterprises and municipalities should be occupied by long-career professionals.

However, there is an increasing number of positions that can be filled by appointment – that is, party allotment – says Istoé Dinheiro, a weekly business magazine. “At the federal level, there are now 22.7 thousand directors of superior advisory. In 2002 there were 18.3 thousand”, says the report. Barely passed accusations regarding World Cup costs, the ongoing scandal involving Brazil’s state-owned Oil and Gas Company Petrobras should also present relevant developments soon.

 Into the future

So, what happened to the Brazil that, just a few weeks before, begged for a change to the lethargy and stagnation?

In fact, the majority of causes pressed by protesters were not targeted at the federal government – they either referred to state and municipal-level administration, or conservative lawmakers.

Overall, presidential candidates presented government plans in accordance to the claims pointed out by protesters.With the ghosts of extreme poverty rates and uncontrollable inflation asleep since just before the 2000s, Brazil has learned to prioritise social inclusion.

With economic growth and ascension of millions to the middle class, the only coherent part of the dispute was that Rousseff wished to expand income distribution programmes, and the pay additional subsidies to municipalities that opened childcare facilities for disadvantaged children. Her opponent, Neves, wanted to transform and adopt redistributing income as a permanent state policy, and expand the service.

Audacious goals made the difference

The candidate for re-election used education as banner. For the next term, the elected government aims to universalise early childhood education. Until 2016, every child between four and six years of age has to be in school. Rousseff also aims to increase full-time vacancies from 13.2% to 20% until 2018, as well as offer more openings for the National Program for Access to Technical Education and Employment (Pronatec), in a total of 12 million until the end of next year.

She also pledged to universalise high-speed Internet: the government’s proposal submitted in the campaign suggests public-private partnerships to install optical fibres in 90% of Brazilian municipalities. In the remaining, radio or satellites are the viable options because of accessibility issues. The project aims to maintain a minimum internet speed of 25 megabytes per second.

For healthcare, her goal is to bring in specialists in addition to the ongoing imports of general practitioners. In order to better train police, a National Academy of Public Safety is also to be created.

After successive evidence of popular disapproval, the government says it will abide by the political reform demanded in the demonstrations. To do so, Dilma promises to carry out a plebiscite to decide for or against a constituent assembly that will have among its obligations redefining responsibilities between the federal, state, and municipal governments, and also revise the tax structure.

However, this proposal already took a blow this Tuesday, two days after the election, as other parties from the allied base itself rebelled against the linked proposal. It is a decree issued in May, which established the national system of participation. Through it, public agencies should open instances of social participation in public policy development, in activities similar to popular councils.

Mendonça Filho, leader of the Democratic Party, unfolded in her criticism while also appealing to public fear on Brazil’s resemblance to Venezuela. “She overstepped Parliament, mirroring the likes of Hugo Chávez,” he stated.

This is not the first time the proposal has been considered “Bolivarist” by opposition and allies alike.

This sudden allegiance might have to do with other facets of the promised reform. The electoral process itself was also meant to come under discussion – with corporate campaign financing in the agenda along with the debates about whether the seat distribution remains proportional, or is it to be defined by district or party lists, and about how to maintain the provisional replacement of senators.

According to a recent survey published by the Brazilian Institute of Public Opinion and Statistics (IBGE), 29% of Brazilians consider corruption as the primary problem in the country. The new law is to punish public officials who enriched themselves without showing the origin of their equity increase, and streamline the trial of cases involving misuse of public resources.

In terms of foreign policy, Rousseff prioritises relations with Latin American and BRICS countries. She has plans to strengthen the southern common-market region Mercosur (Argentina, Brazil,Paraguay and Uruguay) and African and Asian countries. The re-elected president said little about what will be done differently in the economy, but said that she will change the finance minister, Guido Mantega.

Immigration might also be an upcoming issue. The number of requests for refugee status in Brazil sky-rocketed from 500 (in 2010) to 5,200 (2013), says National Committee for Refugees (CONARE). Numbers are due to increase after a new bill was approved on August 14.

Through the bill, Brazil has agreed to grant citizenship to stateless people – such as the Rohingyas, one of the most persecuted minorities in the world. According to personal preference, people who are not considered nationals by any country can now opt between being provided Brazilian citizenship, or keeping their status of foreigners, but with the same rights of other legal immigrants.

The decision results from an agreement during the UN Convention on the Status of Stateless Persons, 60 years ago. “We consider the country advanced. It is one of the few who signed the conventions and the fact that it incorporated it into legislation is a significant step,” said André Ramirez, country representative for the UN Refugee Agency to Estadão.

Today, another under-populated country – Uruguay – is also preparing a similar law. However, specific integration policies for legal, illegal migrants and foreign residents are still to be developed.

Quest for support

Congress, fully elected on October 5, caught attention of political scientists in the country for being the most conservative in 50 years.

Jair Messias Bolsonaro, a far-right-wing politician, was the most voted in the state of Rio de Janeiro. Among his causes were implementing the death penalty, military intervention in civil matters and setbacks in LGBT issues. Pastor Marcos Feliciano, Luis Carlos Heinze are other examples of homophobic, racist and overall prejudiced approach to politics, with wide support.

But it is misleading to think that this composition represents the majority of Brazilians. The abstention of nearly a third of the population – 38 million blank ballots – in this phase of the process, explicits discontent, a more-than-proper ending to the protests that began in 2013.

The low level of the electoral debate, especially during the second round, set aside the programmatic review of proposals for the country. In social networks and on streets alike, voters lost patience, tolerance and respect – heavily influenced by biased media coverage.

Between cursing, unproven accusations and broken personal and professional relations, the campaign brouhaha seemed more like the backstage to an amateur football match than strategically promoted discourses. It is feared, hereafter, that citizen participation has been impaired.

Many people will only discuss politics again in four years’ time. Until then, few are expected to continue watching, criticizing and demanding from the “new” leadership.