A recent editorial in the Dhaka Tribune that made a strong case for making our universities “world class,” and the continuing furore over the admission tests at Dhaka University, have raised questions about the relative standards of our secondary and tertiary institutions.
The quality and scope of primary and secondary education have in fact improved steadily in recent years, but there needs to be further improvement and standardisation in the contents and teaching of core subjects such as the languages, mathematics and sciences under a unified system of schooling.
In international rankings this year, no university in Bangladesh made it to the list of 500 best universities in Asia, let alone the world. Dhaka University, the oldest and most prestigious university in Bangladesh, has capacity for only about 6,500 of the over 70,000 HSC students who received GPA 5 this year; about half of the remaining can be absorbed by other universities and technical institutes.
This leaves tens of thousands of applicants with the highest possible grades without university placement after 12 years of very hard work. This must surely be very demoralising and demotivating for many of the brightest young people!
Bangladesh has the fourth highest number of students enrolled in tertiary institutions in the developing world, but graduate unemployment remains very high, and many find jobs where their degrees are either superfluous or irrelevant. Even with so many unemployed graduates around, industries in Bangladesh can’t find suitably qualified middle level managers and technicians locally and have to hire them from neighbouring countries.
There certainly is a schism between what job skills are required and what is being produced by our universities. The seemingly large number of tertiary students and the 100 or so universities is certainly not large for a country of over 160 million, and the available tertiary positions are not sufficient to accommodate all deserving candidates.
Neither the extent nor the quality of higher education are sufficient to meet the socio-economic and development objectives of Bangladesh that, because of dearth of resources and available funds, has no option but to make the best use of its intellectual capital and develop a knowledge-based economy.
These objectives can’t be met simply by building even more conventional universities when the degrees conferred by current ones don’t match job demands. Attempts to enhance the quality of existing universities will fail if the relevance and utility of their degrees do not lead to full and productive employment.
Bangladesh’s aspiration to become a middle income country by 2021, and then an advanced economy by 2041, can’t be fulfilled without developing excellence in higher education underpinned by a very strong science and technology foundation. A need-based skilled workforce has to be developed rationally from a firm knowledge of the number and types of science and technology graduates and professional diploma holders required over time to meet the current, mid and long term socio-economic goals of Bangladesh.
Informed knowledge of actual requirements can guide and facilitate the establishment of the required institutions with pertinent development-focused curricula. In addition to conventional universities, large numbers of post-secondary technical institutions need to be established to produce sufficient numbers of health, agriculture and technology professionals required all over the country, and especially in the non-metropolitan areas.
Their salaries and benefits should be commensurate with their professional qualifications. More technical and professional institutions will ease the inordinate pressure on university places.
Quality and need-based post-secondary education is dependent on very good primary and secondary schooling in core subjects such as mathematics, science and languages. Large numbers of highly trained teachers are required for all level of schooling, and in vocational and technical institutes all over the country.
To retain their services in non-metropolitan areas, teachers have to be adequately remunerated and shown proper respect in society. Who will teach and train these teachers?
Many public universities, including the constituent colleges of the National University, and most of the private universities are neither interested in nor involved in research. Academics from universities not involved in research could be suitably deployed to teach high quality mathematics, science and technology subjects, and languages to those who will teach in primary, secondary, vocational and technical institutions.
While the international rankings paint a dismal picture of the status of our universities, some senior academics and policy makers contend that the criteria used for ranking are not totally relevant to Bangladesh, and that the standards of our top universities has not actually fallen but those in other developing countries have progressed faster.
This then begs the question: are our universities internationally competitive in this globalised world? The intellectual quality of our students and teachers, at least in our top universities, is second to none. So why have we failed to keep pace with leading universities in Asia and in our neighbourhood?
The best universities in the world also happen to be the leading research universities in the advanced countries of the West. In these countries, and in the rapidly advancing developing countries (China, India, Brazil), research students and post-doctoral fellows form the bulk of scientific workers who run the research engines that drive their economies.
The most spectacular example is South Korea which has utilised postgraduate research and university-industry partnerships to become an industrial power and progress to the status of an advanced economy ahead of Asian giants China and India.
A recent study, based on intellectual output and research capacity, identified just over 3000 institutions worldwide that would qualify as being research-competent. Only four institutions in Bangladesh – Dhaka University, Buet, ICDDRB and Rajshahi University – made this list.
Lack of research capacity significantly impedes the progression of our universities to international competitiveness. It is impractical to expect that all Bangladeshi universities could become “world class” overnight. It will be prudent to focus initially on a handful of universities with the strongest credentials and build them up as “research universities.”
No university or research centre in Bangladesh is likely to possess all the human and physical resources required for optimum research outcomes, so it is important to encourage and support multidisciplinary and multi-institutional research between research groups with complementary expertise and facilities.
International competitiveness also requires the establishment of national technology platform(s) to make expensive cutting edge technologies accessible to the entire research community. With very limited resources, Bangladesh can’t successfully compete in all areas of research simultaneously. So, it needs to focus its meagre research funds in areas of national priority such as health equity; food, energy and environmental security; climate change-induced challenges; and judicious exploitation of maritime resources and rich biodiversity.
National priority research would benefit from coordinated support and special funding from a National Research Council (independent or within Higher Education Commission) for focused collaborations between universities, government research organisations and industry.
Quality education and S&T-proficiency do not come cheap! However, investment in quality and need-based education, and in postgraduate research and innovation, is the most important investment that Bangladesh could make in its own future.
There is much to learn from the example of Malaysia which has allocated 25 % of its annual budget to education and training over the last 20 years. The difference this has made to the country’s economy and quality of life is for everyone to see. Education in Bangladesh also needs this level of support.
A minimum of 2 % of GDP needs to be spent on R&D over a sustained period for Bangladesh to narrow the S&T gap with rapidly advancing countries, but reportedly spends only 0.4 %, of which 90% is expended on salaries and institutional overheads.
Many Bangladeshi expatriate academics and scientists, in appreciation of their free university education in Bangladesh, would be happy to provide pro bono time and expertise to the national R&D effort, but unfortunately foreign consultants seem to be more acceptable to our senior policy makers.
Higher education in Bangladesh receives a ridiculously low allocation from the annual budget. Postgraduate research is virtually non-existent and a research career has little appeal for talented youth.
To reverse this trend there has to be increased public sector funding for education and research, encouragement of private sector investment in national R&D activities through targeted tax concessions, and generous financial rewards for good research and researchers based on impact factor of research publications and utilisation of research-generated intellectual property (patents).
The prime minister has publicly stated on more than one occasion that funds and higher salaries can be found for worthwhile and productive research. Why have the scientific community and the Bangladesh Academy of Sciences not taken her up on her words and demanded that the government make necessary allocations to education, research and innovation?
To become technologically proficient Bangladesh not only needs to build internationally competitive higher education and R&D capacity, but also develop a research culture that stems the highly debilitating brain drain and helps to reverse it.