It is the ambition of every scientist and logical thinker to identify the single formula, or leverage point that controls the observed condition or system. In our national politics today, something is very strange. Everything is in place – parliament sessions, talk shows, civic body discourses, street protests, and yet there is an irritating undertone of discord everywhere.
This article theorises that this discord springs from the Constitution itself – in fact, from just one Article of the Constitution.
Our national politics is such that, the ruling and opposition parties, although not much different from each other, are always at loggerheads. Why is it that the main driving force in the country is slowly gravitating towards the bureaucracy and the business class instead of responding to the needs of grass roots political leadership? Why is the people becoming slowly alienated from government and politics despite having sacrificed much for the golden goose called democracy?
The law of causation says that a problem must be dealt with at the
correct level. Superficial cosmetic treatments do not fix problems permanently. Faults or problems not identified at the proper depth cannot be fixed with finality and continue to persist.
Forty-three years after independence, no one doubts that this nation is still firmly committed to democracy no matter how fragile it may seem at times. Unlike Pakistan with a parallel history, where only one democratically elected government has been able to complete its term so far in its entire history, in Bangladesh, there have been four democratically elected successive governments in the last 23 years with a brief interregnum of two years of semi-military rule.
Although that streak of “fair elections” have been broken in the last election, the constitutional process is still intact. This poverty stricken nation has given to the world several stellar gifts – the International Mother Language Day, the novel concept of microcredit recognised by the world through the Nobel Laureate, Dr Yunus, and yes, the concept of a caretaker government – responsible for conducting four fair elections in this troubled land.
Although unfairly and untimely discredited in the country of its own birth, the CG system, through duplication, still stands the promise of presenting credible elections in other third-world countries where free and fair elections form the only stumbling block to real democracy.
Among other major achievements of this country are a growth rate of over 5% for the last 12 years, increasing literacy and life expectancy rates, and a steady rise in foreign exchange reserves. So it can be said that not everything is wrong with this nation. One might even say that this nation has already produced the sparks of genius that may eventually start the huge bonfire of progress one day.
So, what is the cause of today’s political stagnation ?
Many today doubt the sagacity of having implanted democracy in our country in its pure western form through the framing of a Constitution that did not relate properly to the socio-political make-up of its people and its time in history. Accepting this totally does not do justice to the great strides the nation has made as mentioned above. However, it seems that something fundamental is really wrong with the political system.
The nation has seen an unending parade of below average, in some cases, outright criminal elements holding the helms of power. In the absence of a robust socio-political system which brings gifted individuals to the forefront of national life, the politics of today depends solely on glorifying a few political lineages which holds glossy Bollywood-esque appeal with the masses, reminding us of Moghul times.
Why is it that this nation is still unsure about its foothold on democracy even though almost all the basic instruments of democracy are there? Why cannot political parties deliver to the people in a responsible and orderly manner?
Why is it that the system has bred so much corruption even though the people and the ruling middle class are basically law abiding, compassionate, honest, and God-fearing conscientious citizens? Why is it that the political parties cannot evolve from within to produce a hierarchy of responsible leaders that can give direction to the nation?
Why is it that the government machinery consisting of essentially capable and knowledgeable individuals carries the unenviable stigma of inefficiency and lethargy? Can the answer to all this be found in one simple formula or answer?
The answer may be a resounding yes.
Abraham Lincoln’s famous phrase, “Government of the people, by the people, for the people” hallows the dignity of the “person” acting collectively as the “people.” The democratic set up has directly evolved from the person-to-person relationship that exists between leaders and the individual citizens.
To allow this direct relationship between the person and the person’s representative to become vague and feeble, is to allow autocracy or dictatorship to creep in. This is exactly what has been allowed to happen in Bangladesh, time and again, for the last 43 years, and will continue to do so in the future no matter how many “anti-autocratic” Constitutional Amendments are brought in.
The concept of the “party” is a later construct to facilitate, and not to usurp the dignity of the “person.” The operating word in democracy is “people,” not the “party.” If this was not so, then the need to vote for persons could be written off entirely, and replaced with voting for political parties only.
But, today, the “party” reigns supreme, trampling the dignity of the “person.” This has been done through Article 70 of the Bangladesh Constitution, also known as the “Anti Defection Rule” or the “Anti Floor Crossing Rule.”
The party has been made absolute, the person dispensable. This has slowly but surely created a divide between the leaders and the people which today seems irreconcilable. The public endemically treat politicians with apathy and disrespect. Conversely, politicians treat the public with disdain and disparagement. Only the selfish, self-serving few of the public gravitate towards them.
Article 70 of the Bangladesh Constitution forbids the MPs, under the threat of expulsion from parliament, to vote against the party line as delineated by the party “high command” and ultimately the party chief. In other words the elected representatives or MPs must vote in favour of the party chief and not in favour of their constituent voters, or the public.
The loyalty must be to the party and not to the people. The loyalty must be to the party chief overriding even other party members. In a nutshell, if the MPs want to support the interests of their constituents, and if this differs from the view of the party chief, then they must vote against the interests of their own constituents.
This aspect of the Bangladesh Constitution directly contradicts the fundamental basis of democracy as is practised in all tested democracies like the UK, USA, France, Canada, Australia, etc. Article 70 ensures that the party prevails, and the person is gagged.
By its very nature, the Anti Defection Rule discourages democratic practices within the political parties and encourages blind sycophancy. Top leaders do not heed the views of the general membership of the party, and behave with them with condescending disdain.
The general public is held hostage by the political class. It replaces democracy with “democratic autocracy” or “autocratic democracy” neither of which is democracy. It fosters dynastic rule, hypocrisy, and the rule of money. It discourages the arrival of new leaders in the party causing stagnation in party leadership, something that has plagued both major parties in the country.
A very important aspect of democratic government is its ability to propel forward, the gifted and talented ones in positions of leadership. If MPs are not allowed to demonstrate their own personal qualities and talents in a truly positive way, then one of the main purposes of democracy is defeated.
Exposition of differing viewpoints on the floor of the parliament is essential to the flowering of talent and character. Article 70 which chokes off dissent, only promotes spineless, obsequious utterances in the house of parliament which recently has become the butt of comical entertainment emanating from television and the internet.
No government or society can exist for long, if the interests of the minority or special interest groups are not respected and protected. A crucially important aspect of democracy is its ability to protect the interests of these groups.
Without any practical means available in the practice of democracy that protects the rights of those not in the majority, this vital need is achieved in democracy, in special situations from time to time, when the majority cannot form a viable government without the help of the minority parties.
Unfortunately this has not happened in this country. Governments are elected with overwhelming majority, and governments so formed start to act dictatorially. MPs elected in this way find it all too convenient to act imperiously and arrogate to themselves tax free cars, “development spending money” and a variety of other undue privileges, without giving two hoots to the public except come election time.
In this situation, the best way to have minorities and special interest groups heard at the national level would be by empowering individual MPs, who although elected on a party basis, would take their stand individually in parliament, and this can only be achieved by abrogating Article 70.
If the reader can so far understand this simple stratagem of clinically emasculating the general body of MPs in a democratic set-up through the Anti Floor Crossing Rule, then through a little more introspection, he can comprehend the colossal wrong that this tiny but pernicious clause has heaped upon this nation over the last 43 years.
The very concept of a viable opposition in parliament has been negated in every elected government of the past because of the inability of the opposition party to woo over MPs from the ruling party on controversial and important issues which could demonstrate to the nation the political power of the opposition as well.
It is the duty of the party in opposition to demonstrate the alternative solution and to positively influence the party in power on matters of national interest. The opposition cannot be expected to sit indolently in parliament for five years all the time trying to get the speaker’s attention to speak for a few minutes on the floor.
Not guaranteeing the right of the minority opposition to make a genuine political point in parliament, propels the opposition MPs on to the streets where they are sure to be given a proper hearing. This is exactly why in all the governments this country has had so far, the opposition has resorted to street protests rather than participating in parliament.
Even if a solitary opposition MP decided to participate in the House, he could not do that, on the threat of expulsion from the party and the seat in parliament. The “winner takes all” philosophy fostered by Article 70 goes diametrically against the spirit of democracy. Unfortunately, until the time that Article 70 is made ineffective, this political phenomenon of the opposition not willing to participate in parliament will continue to confine us.
The argument has been made that abrogating Article 70 will fill the country with horse trading and unsurpassed corruption. Although it is difficult to imagine how corruption of the scale seen in the last 43 years can be surpassed by any government entity anywhere in the world, it is very much conceivable that with the annulment of Article 70, initially corruption in the corridors of parliament shall prevail for some time and might even blossom.
However, in this situation, corruption shall become visible especially in front of the electorate and ultimately capable of being eradicated by the electorate in general. What cannot be seen cannot be eradicated. Corruption, as has been seen in the last 43 years is an invisible phenomenon which benefits only the select few in the realms of power.
It is entirely conceivable that if the public identifies corruption as something that only benefits the select few they may choose to exorcise corruption through selecting honest politicians in future elections.
The right of an elected representative or MP to vote according to his own conviction and conscience is unassailable in developed democracies of the UK, USA, Canada, Australia, etc. One important exception is India. Although not included in India’s original Constitution an “anti-defection rule” was introduced in 1985 as the 52nd amendment to the Indian Constitution. This became necessary to prevent MPs from switching sides in return for money, power, office or selfish interests in abeyance to the needs of the constituents and the national interest.
It should be noted that this was done 38 years after independence and even then the 52nd amendment incorporated clauses which did not give total power to the party high command over legislators. For example, the 52nd amendment allows the MPs to vote against the party line if they vote “en bloc” with one third or more members of their own party. The party leaders therefore, must always keep in mind the views of dissenting MPs in the lower rungs. Another important example is South Africa where the original Constitution of 1996 incorporated the anti-defection rule. However, very soon in 2002 the evil of this rule was realised and floor crossing was allowed.
Considering the above, it appears that allowing floor crossing in parliament, thereby allowing the views of the people to be heard through the MPs, is possibly the single easy stroke that can radically and positively change the moribund political scenario in this country. Even if full autonomy to vote independently cannot be given right away, considering the Indian example, the same Indian example should be examined to give limited powers to the MPs to vote independently.
Yes, there would be a few vicious verbal exchanges turning into fist fights that we often see in the parliaments of Taiwan, Korea, India and other states. Yes, there would be some price bargaining and power-mongering. Yes, there would be some betrayals and infidelities. However, through all this the people would be able to see the true character, and the ability of the individual MPs.
In the end, the people would finally matter in policy making, and democracy would be made more meaningful. In the end, good and talented people in all spheres of life would be propelled to the forefront. If the genius of this nation could give the world the International Mother Language Day and the Micro-Credit system in its short history of only 43 years, it surely has the courage to make democracy more productive by making Article 70 less asphyxiating.