Money in the ether

“Mobile technology on its own, can’t cure social ills.  But people who find new ways of putting mobile technology to work can make a difference.” 

                                                                 -- Alan Knott Craig

Bangladesh entered into the era of technology empowered economy in the nineties. During the mid-nineties we witnessed the end of monopolistic mobile network operation and the introduction of new licenses to bring competition and efficiency in the telecom industry.

Effective policy decision impacted mobile phones reaching the poor relatively fast. Utilising mobile network infrastructure and ubiquitous presence of handsets with millions of people, the Mobile Financial Services (MFS) or mobile banking started its journey in 2011.

It should be mentioned that mobile phone technology has been recognised as a powerful tool to facilitate building inclusive financial systems. An evidence of such hypothesis is that within three years of launching, the MFS sector has achieved meaningful success by reaching over 16 million users and built roads towards financial inclusivity.

This achievement should serve as the foundation for moving towards the future of mobile banking which would further impact the financial inclusive objectives of a developing country like Bangladesh.

As the regulator of the financial system, Bangladesh Bank has given paramount importance to the safety of the depositors and of financial flows, and made sure that licenses are given to financial institutions that are accountable to Central Bank.

So far the Bank has granted license to 27 banks and to “bKash,” a subsidiary of a bank dedicated for MFS.  Out of the 28 mobile banking service providers, 20 are in operation (April 2014).

The mobile banking service providers who are in operation can be divided into four categories:  First, MFS providers with significant investment, robust technology and efficient management who are focusing solely on mobile financial services.

Second, providers with resources in places such as investment, technology and management, but their focus is not on mobile banking. Third, providers who have started operation but are yet to expand the business. Fourth, providers who got the license but are yet to start the operation.

The primary objective of Bangladesh Bank regarding MFS is to bring financial inclusivity in the economy, so that the unbanked and the people from the bottom of the pyramid can come under the umbrella of the formal banking channel.

It is particularly effective for the poor and marginalised people who are living in urban and rural areas, since it is quite impossible to reach out to the 64,000 villages across the country through traditional banking infrastructure.

These initiatives are giving birth to new aspirations and possibilities for rural Bangladesh as it helps the unbanked population to come under the net of the formal banking channel which is likely to make a major contribution to the economy. 

Among the stakeholders, mobile network operators are one of the most important partners of the mobile banking industry. Since the introduction of mobile technology to the mainstream socioeconomic activities of Bangladesh in the nineties, there has been sustainable growth in this sector.

Today the number of mobile phone users in Bangladesh is over 100 million. While the mobile operators have been essential in supporting with network connectivity, the other four stakeholders are critical in delivering the service – Bangladesh Bank, as the regulator; banks or banks’ subsidiaries, as the service providers; agents, who serve the end users following the agreement with the service providers; and customers, the end users of the mobile banking services.

Bringing all these stakeholders together, Bangladesh has successfully given birth to a sustainable mobile banking model that other countries may consider replicating.

The “Guidelines for Mobile Financial Services for Banks” was issued in September 2011, which became a milestone for inclusive financial services in the country and would continue defining the industry in the future.

The discussion on various innovative usages of the mobile phone in service sectors started in early 2000. The discussion particularly centred on using the mobile phone for providing information on agriculture, education, empowerment, social campaign and healthcare.

While the mobile network operators had fast expansion of their businesses during these years, illegal business activities such as VoIP created negative impact on the sector.  The sector once again started receiving special attention as the use of information technology was prioritised in the strategy for economic development.

Meanwhile, Bangladesh Bank had been exploring ways to implement its inclusive banking agenda from 2009 and mobile banking emerged as the leading service with the potential of various inclusive possibilities using network connectivity. 

At present, the size of such financial activities is Tk100 crore per day and it is growing.  We have two national achievements in the process: first, it is the first large-scale bank-led mobile financial service model in the world which is regulated by a Central Bank; second, Bangladesh provides mobile banking services to the customer at the lowest cost in the world. 

The second success came through bKash, a subsidiary of BRAC Bank. Our future aspirations should be determined on the basis of these worthy achievements.

There are economic and cultural barriers for the poor in Bangladesh to open bank accounts. A recent research by IMF (2012) showed the reasons why poor people’s money could not reach the banks.

The research report said that 64% of the workers in the ready-made garment industry do not have a clear idea about bank services while 50% think that opening and operating a bank account would be a difficult process and 20% of the workers do not feel comfortable visiting banks.

Mobile banking has created a huge opportunity for the large number of workers in the apparel sector as well as the poor working class population. The following segments of population may generate exemplary beneficiaries of mobile banking in terms of socioeconomic impact:

First, the salary of the primary school teacher and stipend of students could be disbursed through mobile banking. Such initiative would improve the efficiency, time management and good governance in this sector. 

Currently, school teachers need to visit government banks in Upazilla Sadar to collect salaries at least once in a month. The teacher has to skip at least half a day’s school duty as well as spend around TK100 as travel cost to collect the salary. 

Similarly, a student has to collect his stipend every three months.  In another research conducted in 2012, it was found that either father or mother of a student has to sacrifice one whole working day to collect the stipend money in addition to spending on travel and food.

On the other hand, a student gets only TK300 as stipend. If the number of the students is two in the same family, the stipend amount is around TK325 only. 

Second, it is possible to disburse the remuneration of the Union Parisad chairman, member and security staff through mobile banking.  Dutch Bangla Bank has already started taking initiatives in certain districts under Sylhet Division. 

Third, the government pays cash support through several Social Safety Net programmes. The cash support is currently disbursed through nationalised banks.

If such support fund is disbursed through mobile banking channels, it would have several positive impacts on the programme since digital payment would save time and money for the poor to collect the fund, would ensure accountability and reduce misuse of the fund, and enhance capacity building of the Social Safety Net programme.

It is crucial that various institutions, be they government organisations, NGOs or private businesses, start adopting digital finances not only to bring efficiency to their organisations but also to initiate digital money flow which will generate user confidence and behavioural change whose by-product would be a transparent and inclusive financial system.

As the above activities, along with disbursement of primary school teachers’ salaries, Union Parisad officials’ remunerations and social safety net payments pass through mobile banking, they will boost customer confidence as well as contribute in building an ecosystem of digital economy. Bangladesh can set the global standard in this field as we had done so in the space of microfinance in the eighties and nineties. 

While the Bangladesh Bank prescribed bank-led model has given the mobile financial services a strong foothold and it has emerged as a service focused industry, I would like to mention six challenges of mobile banking briefly which I find is closely related to the market expansion and overall development of the sector:

First, a fair competitive environment should be created for the sector while there should be a positive attitude for the MFS providers who are doing well. Initiatives should be taken to explore new markets so there are scopes for growth and innovation.

If the space for innovation is limited then the parties who are currently doing well will sooner or later face stagnation. As I have shared my observation earlier in this article, several performance trends are currently visible in this sector:

(a) Service providers with loads of initiatives (investment, sound management, robust technology and entrepreneurial character) that have also developed products in line with the market demand.

(b) Providers who are lagging behind and having certain ambiguity regarding the understanding of mobile banking. It is quite natural to have such a situation in the preliminary phase of industry development.

There is no need to regulate the market artificially. The service providers who are lagging behind can learn from the successful ones. Bangladesh Bank may create an environment for knowledge sharing among the MFS providers.

At the same time, Bangladesh bank as a regulator has to maintain a keen focus on the whole sector so that the MFS stakeholders follow the guideline while providing services to customers at an affordable price and ensuring access to all.  These two things have to be achieved by policy support and competition.

Second, the base of mobile banking is its agent network. The agent is the new face for the social power of mobile banking. They are playing the role of a catalyst in bringing the unbanked population into the banking network.

It has also created a large number of employment opportunities. Agents are directly working with financial institutions. However, the agent who initially joined the MFS industry lacked knowledge on basic banking, educational qualification and skills. Continuous attention should be given to agents so that they can bring more unbanked people to the banking network and create customer confidence through their services.

Third, all MFS providers are not in the same league of investment capacity and understanding of the business.  So if one MFS provider does well, it should not be seen as a concern, rather it should be recognised positively.

The MFS providers who lag behind should be encouraged to learn from the successful ones or to join their resources together rather than reinventing the wheel. There is a pressing need for creating an effective working environment among the banks to work together through innovative partnership and cooperative attitude. Bangladesh Bank can play the role of a catalyst and provide policy support in this regard.

Fourth, the way the customers of the cellphone operators can talk to those of another network operator, MFS providers should also develop interoperability among each other. bKash has already ensured interoperability among the customers of various mobile phone operators.

We should aim at the next step of the interoperability features; in the future, money should be transferred from one MFS provider’s account to another MFS provider’s account like we do presently transact from one bank’s account to another bank’s account. 

Fifth, one of the strengths of our mobile banking system is that there is a guideline for it. In this case, one of the challenges is to monitor if the service providers or relevant stakeholders are following the guidelines with adequate depth of understanding in the field. It is necessary to form a separate, dedicated and skilled division in Bangladesh Bank to monitor this technology dependent evolving banking system.

Sixth, the success of mobile banking has been achieved through innovative partnership among banks, foreign direct investors, mobile network operators and agents under the prescribed model of Bangladesh Bank with the objective of achieving financial inclusion.  Bangladesh Bank has to play strong roles to protect the interest of customers and assure that the focus of stakeholders is not diverted from that objective.

In conclusion, there is a lot to recognise in what has been achieved through mobile banking in the past three years. In turn it has also given birth to certain challenges and finding solutions for those challenges are crucial.

The good thing is that we have gathered experience, thus, we can assess those challenges with good understanding and leverage on the possible solutions to focus on the institutionalisation of the sector.

Mobile banking has already established its position as the second generation of financial inclusivity after microfinance. In order to achieve long-term sustainability of this sector, stakeholders should act responsibly which would ensure overall benefit to all of them.

The policymaker should realise that this technology dependent mobile banking service is a different, dynamic, and innovative banking system that should not be measured by conventional scale of mainstream banking.

Bangladesh Bank may need to continue playing its engaging and open-minded role in leading the institutionalisation process of mobile banking to ensure financial security of the end users and the long-term integrity of this new financial system of Bangladesh.