The audacity of hope

Continued from Part 1

Amongst other Arab-Muslim nations, Egypt, Iraq, Libya and Syria continue to struggle in the post-Arab Spring world. It is a tragedy tearing the legacies of historical cities like Damascus, Aleppo, Cairo and Baghdad to tatters.

In Syria, Bashar Assad starting his third term means the conflict would continue until a ceasefire is announced or till the rebels (and their foreign backers) drop their guns. Foreign aid is the only way for any normalcy ahead, given the abject destruction to homes, basic facilities and normal economic life.

In Libya, opposing forces across Tripoli, Sirte and Benghazi continue to battle. Weapons have found their way to the hands of civilians, creating continued lawlessness. Some years back, Lebanon addressed its issue of civilian weapons with a scheme to replace them with free mobile phones.

But mobiles were a novelty then, not so much now. Libya needs to take weapons out of civilian hands and take the people out of its cities’ battlefields by employing them, maybe in oil or infrastructure projects. Till then, Libya would burn.

In Iraq, while Shia-Sunni sectarianism was always a thorn for Nouri Maliki, recent weeks saw it worsen. ISIS, the Salafi/Sunni group, increased its hold across areas of Nineveh and Anbar, including key towns like Mosul and Fallujah.

Anbar has strategic importance, as the province borders Jordan and a vital access route. The future holds a long-drawn-out offensive. But with western armies weakened by years of fighting, mediation by regional Middle East biggies might hold some weight instead for Iraq’s future – especially those who have sway over Salafi/Wahabbi entities.

Egypt might be the only one out of these four which can hope for a better Ramadan next time. After tumultuous years of civil disturbance as Hosni Mubarak’s regime and Muslim Brotherhood’s Islamist government were ousted, Abdel Fattah might provide some stability.

Tensions remain, given the depth of Muslim Brotherhood’s penetration into villages through its network of social services built over a few decades. With an over-80-million population, Egypt is a sizable middle-income consumer market.

A stable government would put Egypt back on the road to development (albeit with some foreign assistance into projects). It was seeing economic and income opportunities for its youth, if commercial developments like Smart Village near October 6 City/Giza are any indication. Economic revival from here on should spell a better Ramadan for Egypt next time.

Amongst non-Arab Muslim nations, Pakistan, Iran, Indonesia and Malaysia need a mention. Malaysia’s case is truly saddening. Many of its citizens lost their lives in two plane crashes, for no fault of their own.

The first crash remains a mystery. In the second, Malaysians still ask why they got caught in the Ukraine situation. Given the nature of the incidents, its citizens did not even get a dignified death.

While the memories of the lost ones would plague its next Ramadan, one hopes a swift conclusion to the investigations and apprehending of the actual culprits might offer some justice. Iran and Indonesia can look forward to some positivity.

A furniture exporter turned city-mayor, Joko Widodo just became Indonesia’s President. It is the first time that someone outside the military or elite won the top office. His grassroots style of functioning by going within the people endeared him to the population.

The result remains a debate due to the legal challenge filed by the opposing contender, former army-man Subianto, on the election commission. Nevertheless, the world’s largest Muslim nation, and world’s fourth most populous at about 250 million, can look at its future with optimism after a lackluster second term under President Susilo.

Indonesia’s economic potential is enormous, given its young population and vast natural resources. It has to play a bigger role among emerging economies, and in ASEAN and G-20. Countries seeking to invest in projects in Indonesia or market their products to its growing workforce will keep a watch now on Widodo’s upcoming policies and reforms.

Overall, Indonesia spells good news. Iran saw some good news under Hassan Rouhani’s leadership. After undergoing years of harsh sanctions, 2013-end saw Iran reach an interim deal with six super powers to reduce some of those sanctions in return for a short-term freeze on some of its nuclear programmes.

The deal unlocked a few billions of relief from sanctions for Iran, an economy that was in dire straits indeed. Though the six-month deadline for the final deal had to be extended by another four months since the two sides could not agree on certain aspects despite negotiations ongoing through Ramadan, one hopes that some concessions would be agreed upon eventually before the November deadline. That may bode better news for Iran in the months ahead.

For Pakistan, its armed operation in North Waziristan could not have come at a worse time. There was criticism that the government delayed the offensive, but giving peace talks a chance first was also needed.

While it aims to put legislations in place to address the Internally Displaced People (IDP) issue, it should look to build formal settlement colonies for them. Informal refugee camps are prone to crime and health risks.

Formal colonies might be a durable long-term solution. Such colonies would ensure basic standards of living, housing and essential services to the IDPs. Of course, it presupposes that they may not want to return to the conflict areas in the near future, as only then would the government’s investment be worth it.

If the government’s resources are inadequate to fund such colony projects, it may use external assistance. Apart from the $6bn IMF loan, $12bn World Bank funding, $2bn of Eurobonds, China has also agreed to invest $32bn over the next five years in energy, transport and infrastructure through its EXIM Bank.

This additional $52bn is estimated to double its existing level of external debt – a worry for repayment. A portion of China’s infrastructure assistance could be utilised to develop settlement colony projects.

South Asian political expert Christine Fair suggested in an interview related to her book “Fighting to the End, Pakistan Army’s Way of War” that this offensive was done simply for the country to make a case to continue receiving military assistance and support cheques from the US.

This was based on US Senator Carl Levin’s proviso in the National Defense Authorization Act for FY2015 that suggested making further assistance contingent to an operation in TTP areas.

Pakistan might try allocating some of these US cheques to fund IDP settlement projects. In any case, the time period of displacement that the IDPs are staring at is questionable.

There is criticism that many insurgents might already have crossed into the Afghan province of Khost before the offensive started, given the governments’ prior warnings. Those extremists might return to haunt Waziristan.

Or else they might head for other restive regions like Xinjiang, Kashmir, Nuristan or Paktika, in which case Pakistan’s neighbours should beware. Another aspect is easing IDPs’ movements between provinces.

There were allegations of Sindh restricting entry for IDPs, although it maintained its objective was to scrutinise militants passing off as IDPs. Another is of assistance to the host communities.

These are the families who play host to the displaced people. They have to share their resources, often meagre, with many more mouths. At such times, the government should subsidise some essential resources for the hosts.

A challenge is to track the households as they are scattered, unlike in refugee camps. Another is checking if they are genuine IDPs. Full coverage of IDP registration cards would help, as well as centres in towns where IDPs are headed.

Subsidising resources for host communities might help settle the lives of the IDPs and hosts, and minimise the added burden. It is essential that Pakistan settles its conflicts in FATA. Much-needed foreign/private investment will flow in only when its issue of internal security is adequately addressed.

The country has a sizable workforce, intelligent graduates and natural resources, and can achieve much more than its current track record. Its local industries will have to compete with cheap Chinese imports, as China might want access to Pakistan’s consumer base in return for its generous assistance.

This might limit opportunities for local Pakistani industries and job creation. Nevertheless, even some addition to economic activity would be useful, given the gap between its supply of graduates and demand from companies.

Currently, some Pakistani youth seem to find employment in aid agencies or as self-employed contractors. As the US exits Afghanistan, some aid agencies might opt to shift base to worse hit regions like Ukraine, Syria, etc, thus impacting local jobs.

In short, Pakistan has no choice but to create more jobs, entrepreneurship and revitalise its local industries. Dependence on US support cheques might keep the government solvent, but it will not create adequate economic opportunities for all its educated youth, who will continue to struggle to find enough well paying jobs unless economic activity picks up. For this, achieving sustained internal security would give a definite hope for the future.

In conclusion, the recent experiences of these nine Muslim countries discussed have been a mixed bag during this recent holy month. Some seem to be on the road for a better tomorrow, while some seem quite far from it.

How the next few months actually turn out is anybody’s guess. The attempt in this article was to list some of those guesses. Irrespective, the hope remains that the next holy month would be memorable for all the right reasons, and would spell a better future for “all” the nations even though such a hope might seem audacious now for “some” of these countries.