Terrorism, not legitimate resistance

Just after the IDF killed the four Palestinian children on the beach near Gaza city, Israeli officials declared that they were temporarily suspending strikes in Gaza for a five hour “humanitarian window.” The IDF, too, took to social media to ameliorate the backlash an ostensible war crime (terminology wholly absent from the discourse) would have; listing a variety of methods employed by them to minimise civilian casualties as far as possible, from the age old dropping of leaflets to phone calls and text messages sent to Gaza residents, to the new “roof knocking” procedure of sending non-lethal bombs to warn civilians to leave the vicinity of the attack radius.

Even with the sophistications the IDF bombed those children with, and continues to bomb innocent civilians who, according to UN estimates, account for 77% of the victims.

All this comes after the failure of the Egyptian brokered ceasefire on July 15. Approved by the Israeli cabinet, Hamas rejected the offer, in the process turning some heads in the international community.

Why did Hamas say no?

What is Perplexing is that Hamas said that Egypt had never consulted it on the issue. The relationship between the Sisi government in Egypt and Hamas was never going to be genial. Morsi had been one of Hamas’s greatest allies in the Middle East; and when the Muslim Brotherhood were in power, Hamas had unfettered access to the 650-800 tunnels linking the Gaza Strip to Egypt – an indispensable life source not only for Gaza’s economy, but also for the illicit arms trade.

After Morsi was deposed, the military government took no prisoners in dismantling the tunnel trade. The Rafah bordering-crossing with Egypt was also closed, shutting off the much needed Qatari funding for Hamas. Although the text of the ceasefire agreement mentions that “crossings shall be opened,” it does not give a definite time frame for such an opening other than to say “once the security situation becomes stable on the ground.”

When Egypt obviously has a shared interest with Israel in combating the Palestinian Islamist group, with close links to the Muslim Brotherhood, it is not hard to entertain the idea that Hamas was not kept in complete correspondence in the stages of developing the ceasefire plan. Several news sources also reported a schism between Hamas and it’s military wing, The Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades.

The military wing was hell bent on continuing the missile attacks, while the political wing was considering a ceasefire deal. The political wing has recently showed signs of joining the peace process by forming a National Unity Government with Fatah and other Palestinian parties.

Terror

Israel has attempted to portray a people occupied for over a century by one force or another as terrorists for resisting the occupation. There is no doubt in any rational mind of the suffering endured by the Jews under the hands of the Third Reich, nor any mis-comprehension of the scale at which it was endured.

Anti-Semitism still exists whether as a backlash against Israel in Muslim-majority countries, or in the form of the general economic anti-Semitism that props up every now and then during economic downturns propelled by the view that the Jews control the world – an idea of which I can find no root.

But there is no justification granted in that same rational mind for a massacred people to occupy and oppress another group. Israel has the right to defend itself against attacks, but when those attacks are provoked by the policies of the Israeli government itself à la criminal detainment, blockades, settlement expansions into Palestinian territory, kangaroo courts, an apartheid population registry law and the seizing of Palestinian property, one must wonder what Israel really wants.

In 1945, riots erupted in French Algeria in the market town of Sétif when French police fired on a local demonstration. The riotous mob went on to kill 103 French settlers:

“Many of the corpses were appallingly mutilated: women with their breasts slashed off, men with their severed sexual organs stuffed into their mouths.”

What was shocking, though, was the response of the French military after the riots. An estimated 1,300 to a stunning 45,000 of the local Muslim population were massacred by the French military. It is easy to see how these circumstances could have nurtured the young population into increasingly radical and militant methods at resisting French occupation.

And it did. By September 1956, it became the official diktat of the FLN to attack civilians. One of their leaders, Ramdane Abane, saying that “one corpse in a jacket is always worth more than twenty in uniform.”

These circumstances are repeated time and time again in instances of state terrorism. Whether after the Abu Ghraib torture scandal, or after the Bloody Sunday massacre in Derry, after which IRA membership skyrocketed.

In August 2003, six months into the US invasion of Iraq, the Pentagon screened “The Battle of Algiers,” Gillo Pontecorvo’s famous film on the conflict, with the tagline: “How to win a battle against terrorism and lose the war of ideas.”

The French did lose the war of ideas in Algeria; with its military might it attempted to decimate the native Arab population into submission, but could never bring the Algerians to their knees.

The FLN sustained it’s resistance against colonialism through the revolutionary tactics of urban guerrilla warfare, and with popular support, eventually gained independence. The US in Iraq, too, apparently did not heed the concerns of the Pentagon screening; crushing Saddam and the Baathists in 2003, it nevertheless failed in its 8 year stay to stabilise the country; which now is teetering on the brink of collapse.

Many forget that Hamas enjoys popular support, and that in 2006, it won the elections for the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC). Who in their right mind would blame Palestinians facing daily horrors for electing into power a militant Islamist organisation, whose means are not to be sympathised with, but who nonetheless the population felt could get the job done.

However, electing Hamas meant that Palestinians had voted the wrong way (at least according to the US and Israel) and needed to be punished. This meant sanctions from the Middle East Quartet: the cutting off of international aid, restricting the movement of goods into Palestine and the withholding of tax revenue collected by Israel for the Palestinian Authority.

The sanctions destabilised the Hamas government, eventually culminating in Hamas’s takeover of the Gaza Strip, while Fatah held on to what was left of The West Bank.

All this was a brutal and overt subversion of democracy by two nations who claim to be the ideological defenders of it. Once again proving that internal “democracy” does not in any way upend a foreign policy of mass murder.

The offensive and resistance

These recent attacks which have killed by latest estimates 512  people will undoubtedly aide the extremist factions in Palestine. On Sunday, the 13th day of Israel’s Operation Protective Edge, the IDF assaulted the Shujaiyeh neighborhood in Gaza, killing at least 75 Palestinians. Also killed in the assault were 13 Israeli soldiers. A Norwegian doctor at the scene of the killings, Mads Gilbert, described the situation:

“This is 100% man-made massacre, supported by the United States and Mr Obama.”

The al-Qassam brigades, Hamas’ armed wing, also claimed to have captured an IDF soldier. These allegations, although denied by Israel, if proven true, could give Hamas significant leverage at the negotiation table. Israel is known for not leaving a man behind. In 2011, it released more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners  in exchange for an IDF soldier captured by militants in a 2006 cross-border raid.

This is not the first time Israel has bombarded Gaza, nor have the recent attacks inflicted the most damage. As the world heralded the new year of 2009, Israel launched Operation Cast Lead, managing to kill 1,417 Palestinians within the space of 3 weeks.

A humanitarian crisis ensued, Gaza’s infrastructure was pulverised and Hamas was considered to be in its death throes. But, what Israel did not perceive was that the estimated 1.8 million Palestinians living in the densely populated Gaza Strip would re-spawn time and time again, more radicalised and militant than the last time.

The lack of distinction between legitimate forms of resistance and terrorism on the part of Israel has the effect of blending these two methods beyond recognition. A suicide bombing in a busy market place is no doubt a crime against humanity, but an attack at an occupying military check post is a legitimate form of resistance, protected under international law, against an occupying regime.

In 1960, The UN General Assembly passed the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples declaring that:

“All peoples have the right to self-determination; by virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social, and cultural development.”

Furthermore, UNSC resolution 242 declares the “inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war and the need to work for a just and lasting peace in the Middle East.”

One must resist the compulsion to identify all Palestinians as a monolith, and recognise that there is a deeper trend that runs within the population of resisting Israeli occupation. The systematic murder of civilians is prone to turn even the most apathetic Hamas-loathing Gazan to be compelled to take up arms.

One cannot muse about disproportionality when a nuclear-armed, US sponsored juggernaut starts bombing what is an al-fresco concentration camp; the Palestinians are denied even the basic necessities for sustaining themselves in their chains due to Israel’s blockade of the Strip.

“The both sides are wrong” discourse misses a very crucial fact. As the Jacobin correctly points out:

“ … only one side has bombed a hospital for the disabled and destroyed a place of worship. It was that same side who, on July 9, killed a pregnant woman and her one-year-old daughter and then, on July 11, killed two civilian municipal workers in a refugee camp, killed nine civilians watching a soccer game, and “fired four missiles targeting the fifth and sixth floors of a hospital.”

Burden of responsibility

In every instance of conflict, the burden of responsibility falls upon the powerful, in this case Israel, to de-escalate the conflict. At this point in time, though, when we consider that Israel is pursuing its infamous Dahiya doctrine of intensifying attacks on the civilian population as a means of deterring further resistance, it would seem that Netanyahu is using Hamas’s rejection of the ceasefire agreement (a deal to which Hamas never agreed to) as a justification for its  ground invasion and any further civilian casualties.

This is a gross distortion and averts attention from the true motives behind the invasion; motives which go beyond simple “Zionist” expansion, and into the economics of the looming energy challenges Israel is facing. 

Israel’s recent rejection of the Palestinian Unity Government because it considered Hamas a terrorist organisation, and the recent ground offensive proves that the Netanyahu government is unwilling to put diplomacy before the military option.

Israel may as well continue to breach international law and commit war crimes in its quest to quell the “terrorists,” but as history shows: Terror will inevitably breed terror. And terror riding the crest of popular support is a force tyrants dream of.