Winston Churchill once said that the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter, and I often wonder if this will ever cease to be the case. Hence, the importance as well as logical expectation from the learned, knowledgeable, educated scholars/experts is to be the “guardian” against political proselytisation.
In “Freedom and the Colleges,” Bertrand Russell said: “Against the danger of democratic abuse of power, the chief protection is a sound education designed to combat the tendency to irrational eruptions of collective hate.” We need our intellectuals and civil society to contribute in a manner that encourages population that is rational enough and critical enough and well-enough informed, so that politicians will leave a five-minute conversation with the average voter feeling neither complacent nor depressed, but challenged.
As literacy, education, and the intensity of public discourse increase, people are encouraged to think more abstractly and more universally, and that will inevitably push in the direction of a reduction of political rhetoric. People will be tempted to rise above their parochial vantage point, making it harder to privilege their own interests over others.
Reason leads to the replacement of authoritative rules with fair and universal rules. And it encourages people to recognise the futility of political agendas, and to see politicians as a problem to be solved rather than as a contest to be won. I think the final and perhaps the most profound pacifying force is an “escalator of reason” that will not only demand “fairness” but mandate in all spheres of our lives. Rational thinking allows progressive minds to combat centuries-long erosion of family, tribe, tradition and religion by the forces of individualism, cosmopolitanism, reason and science as well as less ignorance and superstition.
But there is a widespread idealistic movement that questions the price, particularly when giving a voice to your fierce opponent. By muting your adversary, current government can secure absolute monopoly of its propaganda. Is it really worth having a few years of “renaissance of reason” if the price is muggings, terrorism, goom (abduction), extra judicial killing, insecurity? I argue that despite impressions, the long-term trend, though certainly halting and incomplete, is that violence of all kinds will decrease. This calls for a rehabilitation of a concept of modernity and progress, and for a sense of gratitude for the institutions of civilisation and enlightenment that have made it possible.
As we continue to see suffocation of impartial information in public domain, we rely heavily upon our TV talk shows as an outlet of evidence. But regretfully, the TV channel owners (as well as other media outlets) often serve political agendas and are reluctant to deviate from their allegiance to the political parties for mutual benefit.
Our talk shows are infested with blatant and deliberate fabrication of facts by both the guests and the hosts. And more chillingly, there is no “check and balance” or “fact finder” of these “invention.” Anybody can get away by saying anything at his or her discretion. There are abundant examples of distortions from both sides of political clusters and the degree of falsehood has no limit.
A case study for the new generation would be “fact check” in Talk shows in Bangladesh. In a recent TV talk show Tritiomatra, Channel I, episode 3931 and 3932 dated May 11 and 12, 2014, an academic (Dr Muhammad A Arafat) stated that in 1997 New York city had 9000 murders (correct number is # 787), while Subas Singho Roy, chief editor, ABNews24.com, stated that Bangladesh is the 2nd largest wheat (bhutta) producing country (correct ranking is #54) followed by a statement saying there are 2300 murders every day in New York city (correct number is little over 1.1 homicide/day; 417 murder in 365 days in 2013). Sometimes, even if the information is correct but if the source is biased, that data also becomes null and void.
Recently, in Independent TV talk show, Ajker Bangladesh, as an executive president of Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee, Shahriar Kabir, claimed that their inquiry commission investigated the number, 39, dead during May 5, 2013 protest by Hefazatul Islam at Shapla Chottor is correct, and others Odhikar (61) are not. But simply because he (Mr Kabir), vis-a-vis Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee, in the past as well in that show, took a personal position against the activities of Hefazat-e-Islam as a political group, even if his number is absolutely correct, it still cannot be “statistically significant,” therefore not acceptable, only because of his personal standing against the group he was investigating.
He should have been excused from this inquiry commission. It is alarming to see an academic with higher moral and ethical values misrepresent numbers with such magnitude. Similarly, an editor with tremendous responsibility to be fair and just would give false data. This trend of engineering numbers/data by responsible individuals of our society must be rectified by civil society.
Why scientific evidence is important
Is it impossible to obtain reliable information about the socio-political dispersion of Bangladesh?
I’ll begin the first part of the topic with the fallacy of appealing to authority: “Einstein was a genius, so whatever he said must be so;” “Democracy is the best form of government, because that’s what they taught us in school.” The truth or falsity of a claim is not affected by the authority of the claimant; even Einstein made mistakes.
So far, then, we’ve seen that our senses can deceive us; our intuitions are often wrong; we are prone to logical fallacies and cognitive biases; it’s difficult for us to be objective; and even smart people can be mistaken.
Enter the scientific method. I’ll present the basic model of gathering evidence, offering a hypothesis to explain the observed phenomenon, making predictions based on the hypothesis, testing those predictions, and revising the hypothesis based on new data.
This method is not infallible, of course, but science makes use of many mechanisms for minimising errors and correcting them: transparency, documentation, reproducibility, peer review, etc. So the point is we need to be extremely judgemental and critical about the methods employed for conclusion or even a statement that may have long lasting implication in our social-political metamorphosis.
One example of such is the controversy with the number of people died during our liberation war. The numerical values of 300,000 or 3 million will not change the heinous atrocity and brutality of the Pakistan army in 1971. And irrespective of its numerical value, it will always remain as a major “genocide” of the last century.
There is no statistically significant research data in support of that “constant” number of 3 million. Most studies, although in limited capacity, apparently dispute that number. Despite having the best-kept tally of Holocaust, historians are continually assessing and reassessing numbers relating to those who were killed in World War II and still have low/high estimate numbers. As I said accuracy in number is irrelevant, it will not heal the laceration and wound inflicted by the Pakistani butchers. However, seeking accuracy based on scientific evidence should be encouraged and refer the number of death as an “estimated,” not a decree from God.
More practical importance of making a “wrong” right is its consequence in future references, allowing a fallacy or even a controversial fact to have any footing in “reference” has extremely disturbing connotation as a historical fact.
Why sources are important?
Having previously rejected appeals to authority, it’s important to point out the difference between authority and expertise.
While the statement “90% of mathematicians recommend Pepsodent toothpaste” does not carry any special weight, the statement “90% of dentists recommend Pepsodent toothpaste” does. When we, provisionally, accept the consensus of experts on matters of fact in their field of expertise, we are not doing so merely on the basis of their authority: we are relying on the scientific method itself, which includes all the self-correcting and error-minimising mechanisms mentioned above.
The strongest argument in favour of the scientific method is that it gets amazing results. Despite employing scientific data with sound statistics can potential generate a proposition, but it is also important evaluate the process data is generated. Sample size, variability, proper control and diversity – all are important benchmark for a definite conclusion.
A research data from 10 patients showing smoking causes lung cancer carries lesser authority when compared to 1000 patients with multiple variable (age, sex, dose etc.), but both are scientifically proven data. We, therefore, need to search for high impact journals (like Nature, Science, Cell, and PNAS) which have internal “check and balance” to validate strongest data that represent a “fact” with certainty. If one studies the number of people shops at the Bashundhara mall and collects data only the day before the Eid day, that will surely give bias in sampling process, therefore not acceptable.
This is a good place to give our future generation a chance to practice their own critical thinking skills on real-world examples, like the assertions of faith-healers, voodoos or astrologers.
What questions should we ask before accepting such claims? Are there any fallacies or biases that may be getting in the way? What data support these hypotheses, and are there more parsimonious ways of explaining them? What experiments could we perform to help us decide?
It’s essential to evaluate all ideas critically. The smartest people we know could be wrong; we should never accept something just because someone said so, or because it’s tradition, or because it feels right intuitively. Our level of confidence in a proposition ought to scale with the level of available evidence in its support. Being skeptical of extraordinary claims is a good default position — but we must also make sure to keep an open mind and be willing to consider strange and unintuitive ideas.
We must recognise that there are many things we do not know, and that some of what we think we know may be mistaken. It is possible, however, to expand our knowledge of the world, and to correct previous mistakes, using the scientific method.
We all, particularly our young generation, should be natural-born scientists – curious, intellectually vigorous, although heavy on the wonder side and light on skepticism. We should exhibit enormous enthusiasm so that provocative questions bubble out of us. There are naive questions, tedious questions, ill-phrased questions, questions put after inadequate self-criticism. But every question is a cry to understand the world. And there never is notion of a “dumb question.”
Curious minds are a national and world resource. They need to be cared for, cherished, and encouraged. But mere encouragement isn’t enough. We must also give them the essential tools to think with. Otherwise, for a young mind that cannot judge what is allegorical and what is literal; anything that he/she receives into his/her mind at that age is likely to become indelible and unalterable; and therefore it is most important that the information that the young first hear should be models of virtuous thoughts through scientific evidence. Primary among those failed alternatives are foolish thinking and dogmatic adherence to political ritual that encourage people to accept bad arguments.
In his 1962 Yale University Commencement address, former US President Kennedy discussed how myths distract us from reality, how our dialog is “clogged by illusion and platitude:” “As every past generation has had to disenthrall itself from an inheritance of truisms and stereotypes, so in our own time we must move on from the reassuring repetition of stale phrases to a new, difficult, but essential confrontation with reality. For the great enemy of truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive, and unrealistic. Too often we hold fast to the clichés of our forebears. We subject all facts to a prefabricated set of interpretations. We enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought.”
In other words he advocated that we must take gratifications of complete intellectual freedom. Being able to discuss without any repercussion the most pungent and controversial topic freely is not only appropriate but also laudable.
The role of our civil society
“In chess, it’s generally a good idea to sacrifice a knight in order to capture an opposing rook, or to sacrifice a rook in order to capture the opponent’s queen. The pieces’ standard valuations are useful for guiding basic strategic decisions – but there are exceptions. Sometimes, sacrificing your queen for a lesser piece is actually your best option, and will save you from defeat or even lead you to victory.
The relative valuation of the pieces is just a heuristic – a “rule of thumb” – providing a useful simplification that often leads to good results. But in the end, all that matters is winning the game. A smart player knows to disregard a heuristic in situations where it would not actually further the ultimate goal” as quoted by Ezra Resnick. Here I am referring to “Intellectual integrity and honesty,” as lesser pieces, which ultimately wins the game, even if we lose the queen.
Intellectual ideas and scholarly mindset depend on our academics, judges, civil society, journalists and all inquisitive minds. In “The Treason of the Intellectuals” translated from the original “La trahison des clercs” by French philosopher and novelistJulien Benda, describes eloquently what happens when the intelligentsias compromise their intellectual honesty for political reasons.
Benda argues, “It is only when we are not in pursuit of practical aims or material advantages that we can serve as a conscience and a corrective. Those who transfer their allegiance to the practical aims of power and material advantage emasculate themselves intellectually and morally.” In short, Benda asserted that once the intellectuals began to “play the game of political passions,” those who had “acted as a check on the realism of the people began to act as its simulators.”
But systematic suffocation and erosion of their moral and ethical values that shield scholarly aptitude derail creativity and promote mediocrity. And that is bound to thrust us into a cataclysmic future, a dark age from which there will be no light in the horizon. We have irreversibly contaminated our academic institutions, and by doing so, have handicapped not only progressive minds but also the immune next generation. And that alone qualifies “treason” with our future generations, who are rightfully entitled for a better future.
Remorsefully, today, our academicians – the trusty of morality – under the blanket of political protections, have abused and misused academic freedom. But academic freedom is tied with “responsibility” that sprouts out of loyalty to moral and ethical standards. As a responsible faculty of the civil society, academicians are compelled to go by “evidences and facts” alone, based on scientifically gathered statistically significant data and substance, not rhetoric, speculative opinion or vociferous oratory.
It is essential to evaluate all ideas critically. Ezra Resnick also stated that: “Our level of confidence in a proposition ought to scale with the level of available evidence in its support. Being sceptical of extraordinary claims is a good default position and we must be wary of turning faux-scholarly opinions, and their useful heuristics into infallible dogmas to be followed blindly regardless of the actual consequences on mass population.
As literacy, education, and the intensity of public discourse increase, people are encouraged to think more abstractly and more universally, and that will inevitably push in the direction of a reduction of political rhetoric. People will be tempted to rise above their parochial vantage point, making it harder to privilege their own interests over others. Reason leads to the replacement of authoritative rules with fair and universal rules. And it encourages people to recognise the futility of political agendas, and to see politicians as a problem to be solved rather than as a contest to be won.”
Final thoughts
The “true” intellectuals with traditional panoply of enlightened scholarly ideals of collective magnanimity should stand up in crisis moment to tell the truth no matter how unpopular it is. Otherwise, only the most vociferous self-proclaimed intellectuals or the judges/journalists with price tags or the imprudent community those have abandoned their attachment to fairness will fill the vacancy with deliberate fabrications and deceptions that will remain permanently imprinted on our social drapery! And “Truth” will always remain forever hidden if we let these “faux” intellectuals and their symbiotic cronies any importance.
We need to mute them all and challenge them with argument based on facts. Regretfully, our future generations will not hold the “Politicians and Co. Inc.” responsible but the “intellectuals” who hold the “custody” of social justice, moral and virtuous values. If slightest conscious is still left in their ethical landscape they should remember a pertinent poem, “Apolitical intellectuals” by famous Guatemalan poet Otto René Castillo:
“One day the apolitical intellectuals of my country will be interrogated by the simplest of our people. A vulture of silence, will eat your gut, your own misery will pick at your soul. And you will be mute in your shame.” And if the civil society do not stance against lies and deceptions, the “hatred of culture becomes itself a part of culture, the life of the mind loses all meaning,” as articulated by French essayist Alain Finkielkraut.
While democracy depends on an informed citizenry, political indoctrination depends on ignorance. Therefore, we must encourage our next generation to have opinions on logical thinking, honest evaluation and the best evidence in reasonable and rationale way; “emotion” should play almost no role.
But I don’t insist that everything in life ought to be approached in a reasonable manner, as it’s impossible to be “too reasonable.” What kind of country would we live in, if everyone were constantly expected to provide good reasons for their beliefs and reasonable justification for their actions? If everything were open for discussion and reevaluation based on evidence and argument?
Our future generation ought to be “respectable reasonablists” and need to understand that some people are deeply attached to so-called “non-reasonable” doctrines. But future generation ought to proclaim the value of logical consistency and intellectual honesty, although others are free to define “reasonable” however they want: following ancestral tradition, religious belief, as long as such “practice” does not promote hatred, bigotry, prejudice and injustice - who are we to judge?
As insistence on being undogmatic is just another dogma; and rejection of blind faith is itself a form of blind faith. As famous French author Aime Cesaire implied that “No single opinion possesses the monopoly and is, therefore, absolute; there is a place for all opinions at the rendezvous of victory!”