‘Politics everywhere is centered on personalities’

In your professional journey, did you find anything that is unique to Bangladesh’s social context only?

The public opinion in Bangladesh can change quite dramatically within a very short period of time. We have done surveys that have been separated by perhaps as few as 90 days, and within that 90 day period, we found that the most important issue to a majority of the respondents had changed. In one period it was the economy, and by the next period it was education.

This happened with such regularity that on one or two occasions we assumed that there may have been some errors in the way we conducted the surveys, and we had to go back and recheck the procedure.

We discovered that events affect the public perception directly, and people are paying keen attention. For example, in one of the surveys when all of a sudden education was the most important topic, we realised that the timing of school exams happened to occur just as we were doing the survey, hence the exam was in the forefront of the public conscience, and the surveys reflected that. This is also true for politics in the sense that the people don’t have a fixed view on who they support, and for what reason they support them for; but that events in the economy, and the environment absolutely affects how they think about politics.

What in your opinion are the impacts of surveys? Do, and can they affect election results?

Opinion surveys can affect the various ways different people think in. For example, it is a general pattern that people like to take sides with the winners. This is true globally. If a survey shows that a certain politician or political party is doing well, then there may be a tendency that people may vote for that certain individual or group.

However, this is less effective for parliamentary systems compared to the presidential system. In the parliamentary system, people vote in separate constituencies, and the surveys usually do not show which parliamentary candidates are doing well in a certain district. So, these surveys don’t affect specific voting behaviour in that respect, but they may affect general public opinion to a degree.

In the cases of a United States or Mexico, where there are strong presidential systems, a survey may influence how people look upon singular candidates or political parties.

What is your view of the situation in Bangladesh after the January 5 poll?

We did a survey on it, you know. The most important thing it showed is: had that been a participatory election, it would have been competitive. Whether or not one party or the other would have won is impossible to gauge from a post election survey – even though the survey happened right after the actual elections.

People are affected by what happened. What they told us in the survey perhaps had more to do with the political events in comparison to what people may have been thinking at the actual date of the election. Nevertheless, it still showed that there is a great deal of support for a competitive process, and had the opposition chosen to run, they certainly would have captured many seats. Whether they would have captured the majority – we do not know.

Do you think the current political situation is stable?

The current political situation is as stable as the political players permit it to be. At the moment it appears so. But, both major political parties in the past have used instability as a weapon.

I think it is generally agreed that it is an unfortunate political choice, and that the right way to participate in politics is to compete at the polls – not on the streets.

What do you think are the problems with democracy in Bangladesh?

It has been argued that politics here is too centred on personalities. However, politics everywhere is centred on personalities. It can be argued that the problem with politics in Bangladesh is actually the personalities of the two leaders. The parties have political structures that go beyond the leaders, and those political structures have the ability to make political judgments about how they want to participate.

If you look at the history, until the most recent elections, the leadership has switched back and forth between the two political parties – this is a general sign of a very active and vibrant political scenario. So I don’t think there is reason now to feel that the competition between these parties has, or may come to an end; I think it will continue.

How can the DI impact the seemingly perpetual competition between the two major political parties?

At the end of the day political parties receive votes for two reasons: because of the candidates that they put in front of the people, and because of the issues that they support. Both of those can be determined to some degree through public opinion research.

It is harder to use survey research to determine which candidates to put up for the parliamentary elections. Issues, on the other hand, can be determined through surveys, and the political parties can listen to what people are telling them – in terms of what issues the parties should address. The parties can adopt policies that addresses the issues of public concern, and can run campaigns so that the population understands who approaches these issues in what way.

We will work on these sectors – try and determine what people think, what policies they support, what mechanisms they want, how parties can reach voters and engage them – all of these are not as much about elections as they are about establishing party platforms, party manifestos that get voters to think that this a party to support.

Does DI conduct purposive surveys?

Well, we could do that – you are right. It is possible to manipulate questions, to manipulate the order in which the questions are asked. We can also manipulate the people the questions are asked to.

But, we do not have a political agenda, nor do we favour one political party over another. The only issue we support is democratic practice over non–democratic practice. So, we do not have a position on education or agriculture or industrial development. We support only democratic progress. So, it would not serve us, at all, to try and manipulate the integrity of the survey.

One of the questions in one of your surveys was: ‘Is the country heading towards the right direction?’ How does anyone answer that question?

This is a question asked everywhere in the world. It has a very particular meaning based on the political context in which the question is asked. You would need to know about what right or wrong is for the people of that certain locale.

I am not entirely convinced that that question, here, had very much to do with the recent election; it had more to do with the state of the economy at that moment as well as other social factors. It is a very generalised question that is very easy to answer for the respondent – it does not require any forethought. It is basically like saying: “Hello, how are you?” It is just a nice and easy question.

There are allegations that not only the common people but also the civil society here in this country is politically divided. Do you have any plans to conduct a survey for unearthing people’s perception about the civil society groups?

Civil society can certainly act politically, but I think that they tend to act politically based on the particular issue they are organised around. For example, organised labour is a civil society organisation, and their political orientation hinges on how the political establishment affects the labour–force as a singular being, and what expectations the labour organisations have from the politicians.

Our work is much more politics–oriented. We look at democratic practice of political organisations – not of civil society organisations. Our concern is how the political organisations construct their own organogram, and how they implement it. Even then, we have no ability what–so–ever to insist that the political parties do anything in a certain way, what we can do is research how reinforced internal democracy might make them stronger political forces. Whether they take heed of our findings and suggestions is up to them.

We believe that the process through which political parties determine their policies ought to be an open process. But the parties have to be convinced that an open process is more likely to result in political success. We use our surveys to show that.

How would you evaluate our political parties as organisations?

There is no question that the political parties had a highly centralised decision making processes in the past. However, in the last four or five years they have decentralised that process. We have witnessed hundreds of district–level party conventions where literally tens of thousands of people have come from all over the country to speak with their party leaders about issues that are of concern to them.

We have found the parties to be very open to the idea of new membership, and younger people are getting engaged in politics. It is our continuous goal to increase the openness with which their parties determine their policies and pick their leaders.

What are your views about religion–based politics in Bangladesh?

The issue of religion–based politics is difficult to deal with not just here, or in Muslim majority countries, but everywhere where religion plays a significant role in the civic life. There can be a conflict between civic and religious experiences and civic and religious authorities. We do not have any opinion as to what the role of religion in politics ought to be. We think that these decisions should be reached democratically, by open, free discussion and voting, and should not be determined by religious organisations.

We are observing that same kind of conflict throughout the Middle East right now. As the Arab–spring–countries begin to grapple with exactly what it means to have a free and fair vote, what the countries want to try and avoid is what happened in Algeria a few decades ago where a religion–based party was able to prevail through the ballot boxes, but the Army decided and acted otherwise – 100,000 people died as a result of that conflict.

It is the conflict between civil and religious rule that we want to avoid at all costs. I think Bangladesh is a country where this is not a principal problem. To a degree, it is an underlying problem in the social context, but it is much less of a problem here than in many other countries.