Might of pen

Sex-work, despite being the oldest profession in the world, has carried into the 21st century the crippling stigma that embodies it. The stigma is not the only thing that makes it so difficult for the sex-workers, especially in Bangladesh: they are also repeatedly abused and ignored in many social platforms.

“We the sex workers have been subjected to torture at different points of our lives but there is no space for us to share our stories. When someone is raped, they can lodge a case at the jail but I cannot even do that when I am raped because I am a sex worker,” Henna Akhter, president of Sex Workers’ Network (SWN) shared at the roundtable organised by the Dhaka Tribune on November 30 last year.

Representatives from the media, SWN, the UN and other activists participated in the roundtable discussion that focused on the role of media in raising awareness about the plights and rights of sex-workers in Bangladesh.

UN representative Nahiyan addressed the participants saying, “A sex worker is weaker than her client politically, socially, economically and culturally so it’s impossible for them to raise these issues. As citizens, with the social, legal and health rights they have, they should be able to access the law and media should help in this regard.”

While activists and researchers who have worked closely with sex-workers agree that the media has done its part, many sex-workers feel that the media needs to do more.

Safia from SWN discussed the abuse that children living in sex workers’ community go through.

“They are abused and tortured physically and mentally. And to put them in a safe environment is not the duty of NGOs alone, but the media can help us reach a big step in this regard.”

She said, “We can’t continue leaving this population in this position. They have said they will pay taxes if thats what takes the government  to acknowledge this profession. Even the sex workers don’t come to this field because they want to. Many come through trafficking and government needs to take care of those.”

“This is where we need media’s assistance.”

Henna addressed a question that often arises from this issue: if the profession is given recognition, then there will be a drastic rise in people choosing this profession.

“This won’t happen. There will be choices,” she said. “Those who want to be journalists will be journalists, sex workers will be sex workers, doctors will be doctors. I myself am not educated, it’s by working with the media that I am being able to speak up for my rights, and say these things today.”

Nahiyan spoke of the importance of addressing the demand-side of this profession. “We always talk about the supply side: evict brothels, rehabilitate the sex workers. You can see that the girls who work in these brothels come from impoverished backgrounds or are trafficked into it. But there is a huge business involved here: no one addresses this issue.  If a client reaches a girl by paying Tk100 then the girl gets only Tk10, the rest is given to others in the transaction.”

He continued, “A girl who entered the profession five years ago still earns as much as she used to back then. She remains in that same position, whereas the money is going through different channels. If she had gotten the whole sum from the very beginning, in five years she could’ve even escaped from this profession.

“But now she doesn’t have that scope because the ability of her earning is so hand-to-mouth that she has no other way out. She doesn’t have any skill as such, there is lack of jobs in the country, so she doesn’t have a way out.”

Nahian suggested the media address these financial aspects of sex-workers, focusing on the fact that the workers contribute, with their meager earning,  to elections, mosques and other social projects.

There are of course many loopholes that remain to be addressed in this matter: legal loopholes, the economic and social aspects of it and so on. However, there has been a revolution in the past few decades. Sex workers have united and created a platform for themselves. They have made themselves heard. This has helped them reach many people – both home and abroad. And at this point, the contribution of media is crucial as it can enhance the voice of the sex-workers.

Perhaps the president of SWN put it most accurately: “If the media helps us, if they consider us to be regular humans, then they must continue to write for us. 

“For however long their pens will fight, our revolution will continue and we will get our rights. But if their pens stop, then no matter how much we scream and ask for our rights, we won’t get them.”

Indeed, the media can – and should – use the space it has in the society to right the wrong beliefs, fight for the basic rights of the workers, and help them write revolutions.

  

Media’s role has had both positive and negative effects: Dr Arefeen 

Media has cast an important influence – which has had both positive and negative outcomes – on the status and conditions of sex-workers, since as early as the mid-1980s, retired Professor Dr HKS Arefeen has told the Dhaka Tribune in an exclusive interview.

Dr Arefeen, who was with the department of anthropology at Dhaka University, has worked with sex-workers since about 1985 when a child sex-worker named Shab Meher was raped and murdered, an issue that the media covered extensively. Along with feminist movements, the media contributed to the widespread coverage, and in turn conveyed the message to the people.

Legal loopholes

According to Dr Arefeen, although prostitution in Bangladesh is illegal, it is permitted. The government provides permit to the sex workers. If a woman goes to the magistrate and claims that they do not have any other choice and is bound to go into prostitution, an affidavit can be published and the woman is granted license. This is a typical issue where there is a permit present but on the whole it is considered an illegal business.

Historically…

Despite the stigma that encapsulates the profession of sex-workers, brothels have historically been supported by the state – explicitly or discreetly, says Dr Arefeen.

The Prostituion Act 1861 was brought in by the British rulers, who in fact introduced the concept of brothels to the sub-continent. This is how the state became involved with the profession.

These brothels had also been a hideout for politicians and criminals during the British and Pakistan-era.

According to Dr Arefeen, such support for the brothels had been present all over Bangladesh: in English road, Old Dhaka (Kandupotti), in Narayaganj and in some places in Jessore. These brothels are situated beside the police stations and are under the surveillance of TSI, the town sub-inspector.

Following the murder of Shab Meher, Dr Arefeen and his colleague Dr Zarina Rahman Khan were approached by the Norwegian Embassy feasibility study regarding the removal of brothels and rehabilitation for the sex workers because of what had happened then.

“At those times it wasn’t easy to investigate into such sensitive subjects without a few obstacles from society. The female investigators were not inclined to participate and even for the male investigators it was an uncomfortable task. One cannot remove the social stigma that easily.”

Despite these social barriers, the study was conducted and Dr Arefeen and his colleague discovered that sex workers could not be rehabilitated and neither could brothels be removed as the highly-demanded profession benefitted the sex workers with an income.

Contradictory role of media

Dr Arefeen says the media had played a big role in covering the murder of Shab Meher, and raising awareness about the plight of sex-workers.

However, he pointed out, although the media may do it in order to raise awareness, often it backfires and the exposure actually causes many attacks and/or eviction of brothels. Sometimes, media’s role inadvertently redirects from “raising awareness” to “exposing the sex-workers’ locations, and other sensitive information” – and this makes it difficult for sex-workers to remain where they are.

The “exposure” also makes it difficult for other social workers to approach the sex-workers. For instance, the study Dr Arefeen and his colleague conducted was difficult to carry out for another reason, the media.

“When we conducted the studies the prostitutes would refuse to talk because the exposure that the media had given them resulted in raids on these brothels and affected their business,” says Dr Arefeen.

Furthermore, media reports sometimes cause conflicts between brothels and fundamentalist groups in the society.

However, on the more positive aspect it appears that  the brutal killing of Shab Meher triggered an uproar which the media and rights activist had a large role in giving spark to and continuing till today.

Dr Arefeen says since media has raised this issue so much, it is at least a discourse – which was unthinkable back in the 80s.

“Today, you can at least talk about sex workers. Back then, even talking about it was a stigma.”

  

Prostitution a demand driven work: Farah Kabir 

“Media has played a key role in raising awareness about the status of sex workers in the society, but minor setbacks have at times put media’s role under a negative light,” Action Aid country director Farah Kabir said in an exclusive interview with the Dhaka Tribune.

Action Aid has worked with sex workers for over ten years and have addressed issues including right to proper burial, raising awareness about steroids that many sex-workers were forced to take, and the status of the children of sex-workers.

“Our work aims to recognise that this is a community in the society and they are there because they have been pushed into this work either due to poverty or social conflict or gender discrimination,” Kabir said in the interview.

“It is a demand-driven work, but clients pretend it doesn’t exist. They visit the brothels at night but in the daytime they take on a ‘high morale’.”

According to the country director, Action Aid has gotten media’s support during the different projects that it has worked on. A few years ago, the media played an instrumental role in revealing that many of the younger sex workers were being forced to take steroids in order to boost their physical growth. 

“Drugs used to fatten cows were being dispensed in the brothels for young girls to be forced to grow into adulthood, so that they could serve their client.

“It was then that the media joined us in the campaign – we got support from them – electronic, print media, etc, and they helped facilitate proper discussions between health experts, campaigners, rights workers and sex workers,” said Kabir. 

“We also tried to reach the pharmaceutical companies through the media to ask them to not sell the drugs over counter,” she added.

International media houses, such as the BBC and The Guardian, picked up the story and came here to investigate the matter.

However, although the media’s contribution has helped reduce the steroid consumption among the workers, many workers have felt exposed through the media.

“The sex workers felt that the media was capitalising on their situation, and that there were no returns in terms of legislation, policy action, and action of any sort. So there was a certain amount of disappointment,” Farah added.

She also pointed out that many media houses – both local and international – have used photographs of sex workers without their permission, thus casting a negative impression of journalism on sex workers.

While these were specific issues, what tends to be a general problem with the media is their prioritisation of issues. 

Farah said: “Media gets consumed with political stories. And social issues have to compete with these political issues. They’re also not sustained for long.”

“Media must continue, keeping this issue in focus, raise awareness, and influence the thinking of the society.”

She also stressed, like other activists, on the crucial role the media can play in giving a voice to sex workers and their families.

“As a society, we have much to do in terms of behaving like a civilised community.”