What do the voters want?

At the time of writing, 154 members in our 300-seat parliament have been declared “elected unopposed.” All of these unopposed MP-elects belong to the Grand Alliance – all but a few from the Awami League. Exactly how representative will this new parliament be?

We can answer that question by analysing opinion polls conducted by leading news dailies over the past five years.

These polls are based on random samples of thousand or more people. Bangladeshi pundits, including science professors, wonder whether polls based on such samples can reflect the opinions of over 150 million Bangladeshis. Well, anyone with rudimentary statistics should know that if polls are well designed – and I believe these ones are – random samples of a thousand can quite reasonably reflect the popular opinion. One would do much better to trust these polls than listen to bloviators on TV or trust most op-ed writers or political bloggers.

Each of the polls gives one data point for each of the major party’s vote share in a hypothetical election. This means, we have 14 data points since the last election. In the chart, these points are plotted. 

Of course, each poll is an imperfect guide to the overall political scene. Trend lines aggregate all that information and allow us to see, well, the trend in political landscape. And extrapolating the trend line gives us the projected hypothetical election result.

But how to estimate the lines?

While estimating trend lines, one needs to keep two things in mind: does the trend reflect the qualitative history; and how much weight should be given to the latest data? The first concern rules out a linear trend line. But non-linear trends put more emphasis on the latest data, and one needs to be careful that this does not drive the projection.

Ultimately, the choice of a trend estimate is quite arbitrary. And the conclusion of this analysis is dependent on that arbitrary choice. So take the whole thing with a fistful of salt.

How did I estimate the trend line? I asked excel to fit a cubic function through the dots, starting as close as possible from each party’s respective actual vote shares in December 2008. This, incidentally, has one side effect: it possibly overstates AL’s end point, and underplays BNP.

And what do the lines show?

Let’s start with the AL line. According to the trend line, AL retained its 49% support from December 2008, if not improved on it, throughout 2009. Does this seem sensible?

Let us think back about 2009. The government commanded widespread media support. Its young, fresh-faced ministers were considered to be clean and had good image. Media gave it a free pass on BDR mutiny. And there was a massive sympathy wave for the Sheikh family as the executions of August 1975 killers loomed.

Then we have a period of steady decline in AL’s popularity, until reaching a trough around 32% by the end of 2012. What happened at this period? Share market scam. Padma bridge scam. Several law and order mishaps. High inflation. Vendetta against Prof Yunus and Mrs Zia. Anyone reading the newspapers could come up with plenty of reasons for the dropping popularity.

Interestingly, the AL line shows signs of picking up since the beginning of 2013. Why? Perhaps Shahbag and aftermath rallied the AL base. Whatever the reason, the pick up, assuming it had continued, would have meant AL getting 39% of votes in a hypothetical December 2013 election.

Let’s now turn to the BNP line. Well into 2010, it went backwards from its 33% vote share from December 2008, with popularity falling far below the 30% mark. Then the turnaround started from late 2010.

Again, this seems to tally well with what actually happened in 2009 and 2010. In 2009, BNP was completely missing in action from the public debate about, well, everything. The party was still recovering from 1/11 and the election defeat. By late 2010, it found its feet. Plus, the start of its recovery seems to coincide with the government’s assault on Ziaur Rahman’s residence.

Coincidence? Or public’s innate sense of justice?

The turnaround notwithstanding, it seems that BNP was behind AL throughout 2011. And it appears that AL was losing popularity more quickly, rather than BNP becoming popular rapidly. Again, both seem to gel well with the conventional wisdom of that year.

But its popularity has been rising steadily, and BNP seems to have been on track to be around 47% support by the end of 2013 – should this have come to pass, it would have been BNP’s best ever performance.

A straightforward reading of the trend is that BNP had not only unified its core supporters, it had also attracted a plurality of the “middle,” while the AL had lost the people who swung its way in 2008 (49%), but its 2001 base had returned to the fold.

As of October 2013, the trend lines suggest that BNP was expected to get 45% votes against the AL’s 36%. Extrapolating this to December, and the numbers are 47% BNP vs 39% AL.

Of course, given our first past the post voting system, with 47% votes, BNP would likely have won many more than 47% of seats. How many more? Looking at the two elections where BNP defeated AL in a landslide may provide some clue.

In 1979, BNP won 207 seats with 44% of votes – a seat-to-vote percentage ratio of 4.7. In 2001, 41.4% vote gave it 193 seats – again seat-to-vote percentage ratio of 4.7.  Applying the ratio to 47% vote would imply more than 220 seats – its best ever show.

What about AL? In 1979, it won 39 seats with 24.5% votes – a ratio of 1.6. In 2001, it got 62 seats with 40% votes – ratio of 1.5. Applying these to 39% vote suggest around 60 seats.

That is, based on the opinion polls, we are looking at BNP getting around 220 seats, against AL’s likely tally of 60.

There is another way to translate vote shares to seat numbers. The polls suggest there is a 10-point swing against AL (from 49% to 39%). Even if BNP had not gained any popularity, such a swing, if applied uniformly across the country, would have cost AL nearly 80 seats – in 2008, AL’s winning margin was less than 10% in 79 seats. Add to that the 14 point swing to BNP (from 33% to 47%), and potentially AL could be reduced to less than 30 seats.

How representative will a parliament be where BNP is not represented? 

I wonder if it would be a stretch to compare this election with the one held in the occupied Bangladesh in 1971. In 1971, when the al-Badr and al-Shams were carrying out their atrocities, their Pakistani masters also held elections in the seats vacated by the “outlawed” Awami League. The Pakistanis got 55 collaborators elected unopposed. 

What’s the Bangla word for irony? When this was being written, there were many fiery online discussions and many TV talking heads frothing at the mouth about those dastardly Pakistanis who were questioning our quest for justice in their parliament. 

Is it ironic that the Pakistani parliament is actually a genuinely elected one? 

It’s a fascist regime – that’s a common refrain in Bangladesh. Every opposition party in our history has accused the government of being fascist. And every opposition in the past has been wrong. Until now.

Fascism doesn’t mean any odd dictatorship or undemocratic regime. Mere intolerance of the opposition is not enough to be fascist. To be a fascist regime, a government needs a large enough popular base, a cult of personality, and a dogma/ideology which is going to be invoked by academics and intelligentsia to support the regime.

The 1/11 or Ershad regimes were not fascist – they had none of these ingredients.

Baksal had the cult of personality, ideology and intellectual cheerleaders. Had Sheikh Mujib instituted Bakshal in 1972, he would also have had massive popular support. But by 1975, it was too late.

BNP in 2001 had the popular support to become fascist. But for all its manifold mistakes, it wasn’t fascist because there was no ideology or intellectual support.

The AL is still popular enough, has a sufficiently coherent ideology and a cult of personality, and a very strong intellectual support base.

When Ershad or BNP stepped over the line in terms of censorship or rigged election or sheer decency (think about Mrs Zia’s birthday celebration), there were massive outcries. Nothing like that has happened under the current government because those who are supposed to protest are all on the same side as the government.

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing – said Edmund Burke. As I write this, for far too many otherwise sensible intelligent people, what Imran Khan says in an elected parliament in Pakistan causes more anger than the lack of an elected parliament in Bangladesh. 

And that’s why, dear reader, for the first time in our history, fascism appears to be imminent in Bangladesh.